Contractor: Rima And Kirk Cut Scene

[TrekToday]

Nazneen Contractor, who played Rima Harewood, the mother of a sick daughter whose illness set in motion a terrorist attack by her father, explained how her role originally was a bit larger than what appeared on the screen. “I thought it was a very important role and it was much bigger, what we shot, than […]

More...

 

[DEWLine]

Having seen much more of Contractor's range as an actor on The Border, I do wish that scene could've been fitted into the finished movie.

 

[drumvan]

another case of a potentially very cool scene being cut just to save 30 seconds of screen time. this might have greatly helped the final scenes seem not so rushed.

 

[22 Stars]

Even just show it during the closing VO montage, it's called closure, a simple thematic tool that JJ seems to ignore. Introduce something at the beginning and pay it off at the end.

 

[YellowSubmarine]

Now I want an alternative cut of the film.

 

[22 Stars]

This should be on the bonus disc, available only at 7 Eleven, on Wednesday afternoons.

 

[Enterprise is Great]

I wouldn't have cared to have had it in the film but deleted scenes like this should've been on the blu-ray/dvds.

 

[Franklin]

Good cut. I'm not sure that scene added anything important to the movie. We know the girl was going to get better, and we know she and Kirk both have Khan's blood. Why do they have to share a knowing moment? It was far better to segue seamlessly from Kirk's speech to the crew on the Enterprise about to embark on their five-year mission.

 

[shapeshifter]

Yeah, how dare JJ assume we'd be bright enough to understand she made a full recovery without taking up more screen time to show her alive and well. The Nerve!

 

[YellowSubmarine]

If a film was about knowing what happened, we would simply read the plot on Wikipedia. It's about experiencing it.

 

[shapeshifter]

Perhaps the studio slapped a running time restriction.

 

[Ovation]

If a film was about knowing what happened, we would simply read the plot on Wikipedia. It's about experiencing it.

It's also about the director deciding whether it makes his story better--in his judgement, clearly this was not the case. You are, of course, free to disagree (no one should object to that) but the idea that audiences do not have to be shown a resolution to every single element that was introduced earlier is a legitimate one. I hate when films spend too much time explaining things I can easily figure out for myself as though I was not intelligent enough to do so.

In this case, I can see the appeal of the cut scene, but I think it's placement in the structure of the final moments of the film would have proved somewhat problematic (along the lines pointed out by Franklin). But that's just my opinion.

 

[Therin of Andor]

There was a publicity pic released of the main crew (in their hats) in San Francisco interacting with the little girl, Lucille, but it wasn't clear if it was for an actual scene or if she and Contractor were early for the wrap party.

 

[M'Sharak]

There was a publicity pic released of the main crew (in their hats) in San Francisco interacting with the little girl, Lucille, but it wasn't clear if it was for an actual scene or if she and Contractor were early for the wrap party.

I'm pretty sure that was identified as behind-the-scenes when it originally appeared. It's one of several called "set photos" here.

See also:
http://translate.google.com/transla...2/05/31/jovem-atriz-indiana-em-star-trek-xii/

 

[Malaika]

oh nice another scene that would make the more even more a Kirk show than it already is...

I wouldn't have cared to have had it in the film but deleted scenes like this should've been on the blu-ray/dvds.

agree.