• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers "Conspiracy" theory

It would make them easier to kill. A can of Raid and a pair of steel-toed boots ought to do the trick. It's not like they can jump from body to body real fast. And that neck snorkel! Dead giveaway there.
 
This prequel is going to try to answer a question due to an episode of - "chronologically to their calendar, not as of date of production", some 2 TV series later technically made several decades prior - that created the invading malignancy and then dropped it? The same malignancy that nobody knew about? (So is the species being introduced going to just create the invading neon purple shellfish? Two things to that:

1. Wouldn't it be more fun to watch the mystery unfold in the original TNG episodes unfold without being spoonfed this "answering in advance", so to speak? Naah. IMHO I wish PIC3 (or "Legacy" if that were to take off) had answered it and closed it instead of the Borg, but for other reasons bringing back the Borg made a certain sense despite their massive overuse. (Keeping in mind scripting deadlines and such, and how Season 1 TNG was not well-received so unless they had a big reason**, they avoided it.)

2. Given the few attempts to line up with (here it comes) continuity where it mattered, why does it matter now? Will it matter? Will viewers care either way? Will it stick out so badly?

All this aside, the idea that another species created the shellfish things that invaded 100-whatever years later (same timeline or not, for this it doesn't matter as much) and then explaining why they would not return (lifespan limits, self-destruct mechanisms, etc), there is some potential depending on how crafty the scripting is to rough out the edges to make it all feel germane and taut*.

But if it's the same species just making a return and a namedrop for no other sake... why? Let the sequel to the sequel address it. It's like a computer programmer is not going to go boot up MS DOS 1.0 and make changes to its source code, recompile, and create a new branch alongside or anything as everyone moved on to newer platforms that all had improvements and drawbacks, etc, etc.


* But that's why I've avoided prequels in general***, even ENT, they usually don't answer anything that needed answering, and the times they do it doesn't really mesh. TNG really got it right, setting itself decades in the future, and not bothering with big canon things because any fans that care can come up with their own connect-the-dots and that doesn't change the credibility of the continuing saga at all. Also, if ENT had a commander named Yarrow, would we have a Yarrow Alert as well as a Reed Alert? Dumb, yes, but now we got the origin to "Red Alert" apparently and that answered the biggestsy question ever that needed addressing for decades... That aside, the change in technobabble to describe ship functions and components was pretty refreshing at times so there's that...​
** Which was more or less limited to Data being "fully functional", but at least they went from the sophomoric first instance to try to make it seem more credible and gave some emotional depth - from the viewer's POV. Which was pretty cool to turn lemons into lemonade as, often, the lemon is just buried or any attempt to improve fails, so there's that... then if it succeeds they wring as much of it out, hence Data's family tree and/or story about androids being people just like us too were getting more and more thin and dim with each passing story. But Lore succeeded and, you guessed it, it all spiraled out from there. Gotta have a sequel sometimes.​
*** IMHO, YMMV, some dig 'em, some don't, even BSG04 had the acclaimed "Caprica" spinoff that some fans balked at because it didn't mesh (logistically to their universe's saga, or for them as viewers due to tone and/or other factors)...​
 
I think the need to explain these new characters arises because their introduction was underdeveloped. Instead of learning about them, we spend an entire episode watching a couple explore a mysterious, multi-dimensional room. Vezda doesn’t resemble the bugs from Conspiracy; we’ve seen them in their full form, before and after they take over a host body. Poor Gamble contracted the infection through an eye blast, and there’s no tail protruding from his neck. It seems a scan would have immediately alerted sickbay equipment to his condition.
 
So the Vezda and the bluegills are the same because... they both want to take over the galaxy and can inhabit a person? With a screenshot photo that may show the two lower teeth looking, at best, SOMEWHAT similar?

That is some incredibly thin reasoning to make that connection. Honestly... I laugh at this. Completely.

First, the Vezda can read minds, which was clearly seen at least twice in the episode. The bluegills cannot.

Second, the Vezda can keep inhabiting a dead person and pose as them being 'alive'. The bluegills can't.

Third, the Vezda left no physical manifestation of them inhabiting a person. The bluegills do by having a (you guessed it) blue gill protruding from the back of that person's neck.

Fourth, the signal at the end of "Conspiracy" was aimed at a region not explored before. Obviously, the Vezda are on a planet that is at least close to Federation space, or the M'Kroon would not be asked to join multiple times. (Never mind the fact that the planet is NOT unknown.)

Fifth, and this might be the biggest one... the bluegills were corporeal. The Vezda are not.


Saying something that can inhabit someone is related to another something that can do the same thing is just ridiculously thin logic.

Might as well be the same creatures from TNG's "Power Play". They were trying to free themselves from their prison on that moon. So they MUST be Vezda, too.

Or they are related to the Paxans... they can inhabit a person, too.

Oh, and the Vezda can read minds. Why not make them the same as Betazoids? Hell, they both have the letter 'z' in their names. There's the connection! They are the same!


The universe in STAR TREK is a big place... the galaxy is full of many, MANY different lifeforms. And that's a great thing!

Why ruin that by making the universe smaller by connecting one-off aliens from nearly 40 years ago with the Vezda? (And I say this as soneone who would LOVE to see those bluegills again. That ending was ripe for their return.)
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top