• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Confirmed List Of S5/1 Writers (With Mild Spoilers)

"The Unicorn and the Wasp" is indeed excellent

You're insane. Roberts actually seemed to think he'd written something as clever as an Agatha Christie murder mystery. He didn't seem to appreciate that the only resemblances were cosmetic and there was no possible logic to work out who the killer / giant fucking wasp was. That episode sits right next to "Love & Monsters" and "Fear Her" as the only episodes of nuWho that I will never, ever watch again. ("The Shakespeare Code" isn't far behind ... I've never actually fallen asleep during an episode of Doctor Who before.)

While I wouldn't call The Unicorn & The Wasp excellent, I think you are a little hard on it - I didn't mind it so much. I'd never rank it anywhere near as low as Love & Monsters which I agree is really, really awful.
 
20679238022246798500291.jpg

I had wondered how DWM would utilize the new logo (and which variant of the logo) for the mag. That looks pretty good. What issue is that, btw?
 
As I recall, the BBC was so impressed with the production staff's ability to do 14 episodes (including the Christmas special) on a 13-episode budget in 2005 that there was something of a budget reduction in subsequent seasons. As a result, every year has now had an episode with only a few appearances from the Doctor and his companion, to save money.
It's not to save money, it's to save time. It lets them film fourteen episodes in the time they would spend on thirteen to have a Doctor-lite episode, as they can shoot two episodes simultaneously by double-banking them.
 
^ Also, they did thirteen episodes for the 2005 season, which is why there's no Doctor-lite episode that season. The tradition didn't start until 2006, when the addition of the 2005 Christmas special meant they had to film fourteen episodes in the same span of time as thirteen. (Christmas specials, with the exception of "The Next Doctor", have always been filmed with the following season.)

Which makes it odd that we might get one this season, as they're back to doing thirteen episodes, since there's no preceding Christmas special to worry about.
 
So it has been officially confirmed that the Silurians and Sea Devils are returning? Hopefully it'll be much better than Warriors of the Deep but I have to say I'm not too keen on the make redesign (assuming that's them in the Series 5 trailer).

That aside, a nice line up of writers and stories, although I sad to see no Neil Gaiman on the list but I wasn't holding my breath.

I use to be a Chris Chibnall hater but he did so some very good episodes in season 2 of Torchwood and "The Unicorn and the Wasp," while far from perfect, it's still an enjoyable episode. That being said, I'm no fan of Gareth Roberts.

I've seen a few other reports that have said that the Cybermen are the villains in the season finale.

It'd be nice if they were Mondas Cybermen, as opposed to DELETE DELETE DELETE, but I'm not holding my breath.
I can only hope! *crosses fingers*
 
Cool! Thanks for that, although I only see the Silurians being mentioned.

Some episode titles are out already. Very exciting! :D
 
^WEELLL more of a guess not The official list.

Rumors say the finale could be Cybermen or it could be Omega.
 
(It's almost like he doesn't care about the opinion of the handful of people on the Internet who don't like them!)

Yes, because the first two seasons of Torchwood, "The Shakespeare Code," "The Unicorn and the Wasp," "Planet of the Dead" and "42" were so excellent.

"The Unicorn and the Wasp" and "Planet of the Dead" were perfectly fine episodes, nice little romps. And I for one happen to adore "The Shakespeare Code" as the perfect Doctor Who comedy-adventure episode. (And Christina Cole ain't too shabby, either. ;) )
 
With the whole season layed out like that, it makes me kind of sad BBC makes 13 episode seasons.

"I'M Still HUNGRY..........for more Doctor WHO"

Yeah. After all the waiting and anticipation, it kinda sucks that we're going to get such a pitifully small number of episodes.

We still don't know if BBC will split the season in two due to the world cup. So April to May or early June then to return in mid July/early August ?

Basically a 7/6 split.
 
"The Unicorn and the Wasp" is indeed excellent

You're insane. Roberts actually seemed to think he'd written something as clever as an Agatha Christie murder mystery. He didn't seem to appreciate that the only resemblances were cosmetic and there was no possible logic to work out who the killer / giant fucking wasp was. That episode sits right next to "Love & Monsters" and "Fear Her" as the only episodes of nuWho that I will never, ever watch again. ("The Shakespeare Code" isn't far behind ... I've never actually fallen asleep during an episode of Doctor Who before.)

Oh, you must be having a laugh there. See, Unicorn and the Wasp starred the character of Donna Noble. Now, as we all know, Donna Noble is the most fantastic female companion in the history of everything. Just by her very prescience, she made the episode 10 out of 10. The only way it could be better would be if she suddenly had a twin.

So yes, you must watch Unicorn and the Wasp three times by this weekend. It's the law.:bolian:
 
The only work I've seen by Chibnall is "42" as I've not watched Torchwood. However, I really enjoyed that episode which is an opinion that goes against the grain to say the least. :lol: That said, I can't say I'm overly fond of Gareth Roberts' return. The Shakespeare Code was just awful.
 
(It's almost like he doesn't care about the opinion of the handful of people on the Internet who don't like them!)

Yes, because the first two seasons of Torchwood, "The Shakespeare Code," "The Unicorn and the Wasp," "Planet of the Dead" and "42" were so excellent.

You're nuts. I enjoyed everything on that list.

:bolian:
 
^ So did I, not to mention Chibnall's work on Life on Mars. I swear he's gonna be wearing that sex-gas-alien episode albatross on his neck for the rest of his career. I also don't know why everyone dislikes 42 either. Loved it on every occasion I've seen it.

Roberts is fine for some fluff. I don't rank any of his episodes of DW or SJA very highly but none of them are complete trash either.

The only rumour I want confirmed is the title of the first episode. Someone suggested to me it might be called The Eleventh Hour. This is the best title ever and must be used. Or I will be sad.
 
You're insane. Roberts actually seemed to think he'd written something as clever as an Agatha Christie murder mystery. He didn't seem to appreciate that the only resemblances were cosmetic and there was no possible logic to work out who the killer / giant fucking wasp was. That episode sits right next to "Love & Monsters" and "Fear Her" as the only episodes of nuWho that I will never, ever watch again.

"Love & Monsters" is also excellent.

Sorry, your license to disagree is revoked :)
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top