• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

CBS/Paramount sues to stop Axanar

Status
Not open for further replies.
Unfortunately watching the new teaser trailer just confirms to me that any expectation that the movie could be as good as Prelude walked out the door with Christian Gossett. What were they thinking with that barely legible Klingon shouting and then the over-long shot on Alec's "smell the fart" acting? I'm no director or editor, but even I could see that looked bad.
 
Summed up on AxaMonitor. View the full trailer here.
ClTL463UoAA_s9h.jpg
 
Nah, that's totally cool. That's a difference of opinion on how two people experience art, as opposed to two people assessing Alec's objectively unethical behavior.
I should have gone on to point out that I think sitting down and talking reasonably well doesn't necessarily translate into good acting when there's more to do than that though. And based on the "teaser" that's doing the rounds it looks like I may have been right. I was reminded of Joey from Friends and his 'smell the fart' acting technique...
 
That trailer! There are Uwe Boll-level performances there. The direction to the Klingon actor seems to gave been, "Ham it up to eleven," and somehow the actor got it to fifteen!

The thing is, a decent director would have had the actor redo that line. There was no call to action, no desire, no effort to use his voice to change something about the situation, in the delivery. It was just shouting. It's what happens when an actor is either lazy or inexperienced: s/he mistakes volume for drama. And it's boring.

I wouldn't even give a fan film a pass on that one, since it's something every director should be watching out for and any actor with more than a couple of years of experience should be aware of.
 
Summed up on AxaMonitor. View the full trailer here.
ClTL463UoAA_s9h.jpg

Amateur writing that's pretentious, trying very hard to be important when it's really about nothing. The CGI is bland, just a series of lumbering ship shots that have no energy in them. A Garth Stu staring blankly at a tunic followed by a lot of sound and fury signifying nothing.

Yes, this screams "real STAR TREK" and the "greatest STAR TREK movie ever" ... not.
 
The CGI is bland, just a series of lumbering ship shots that have no energy in them. A Garth Stu staring blankly at a tunic followed by a lot of sound and fury signifying nothing.

Rob has been loudly insisting on social media that he's not the director because there isn't a movie. Maybe this is all part of his strategy to show he's not directing! ;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top