• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Carnival Row - New Amazon Prime Victorian Era Fantasy Series from The 4400 creator, Rene Echevariia

Yeah, I fear the same for me.

I haven't watched any of the new episodes yet. I keep meaning to but just haven't had the hence yet.
 
Hubby and I reviewed the IMDB page and started season 2. We're two episodes in and...maybe it's been too long but I can't say I'm enjoying it very much. It's pretty dreary and depressing with not much to get excited about. Maybe more happens later on?

It feels like I'm watching the Russian Revolution played out with fantasy characters.
 
It's got a beautiful, expensive production design and extremely detailed, lived-in world building. But the story is rather underwhelming.
 
I haven't finished my rewatch of Season 1 yet, so I haven't started 2, but so far, most of the reactions I've seen haven't been very good, even from people who liked the first season.
 
I'm as far as S2E6, and IMHO, it's pretty damn bleak with horror elements. As AuntieHill said up thread, it does feel like "the Russian Revolution played out with fantasy characters." Fantastic production values though.. Budget definitely ended up on-screen.

Q2
 
Though really, some major plot stuff really is moronic in this show:

1) Absalom Breakspear's wife only marries him because she hears a prophecy of how the man's son will be even greater than he is. Rather than stay faithful to him, she cheats on him with a rival and the son she has isn't Absaloms at all...even though she WANTED her child to also be Absaloms all along!

2) Absalom dies and somehow the way their political system works is that his son inherits his elected position. How does that work?
 
Episode 5 was very got like with how it handled some characters. That creature is very creepy looking.
 
Though really, some major plot stuff really is moronic in this show:

1) Absalom Breakspear's wife only marries him because she hears a prophecy of how the man's son will be even greater than he is. Rather than stay faithful to him, she cheats on him with a rival and the son she has isn't Absaloms at all...even though she WANTED her child to also be Absaloms all along!

2) Absalom dies and somehow the way their political system works is that his son inherits his elected position. How does that work?

Yeah, I don't really get the "elected to a Monarchy" thing is supposed to work, either.

I'm actually finding this second season too dreary and depressing. It's the Russian Revolution--I get it. It's the corrupt oligarchy that has to be stopped. I get it. But can we move it along, please? If it weren't for hubby's determination to watch it to the bitter end, I'd have given this up already.
 
If I had known this season was going to be airing two episodes a week instead of the usual one, I would've kept up with the season better. I don't like this new trend that Prime is doing with two episodes a week. They did it with Hacks and The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel, too. They keep changing from full season to weekly to two episodes weekly that it's hard to keep up with and it's pretty annoying.

That said, considering all of the madness of this season, I suppose I'm somewhat grateful that it took me this long to catch up and just in time for the last two episodes.

I've enjoyed most of the season from the big mystery regarding the Sparas (a creature created for this show?) and Tourmaline's terrible connection to it to Agreus and Imogen's adventures with the New Dawn standing in for the Russian Revolution, complete with the wonderful Joanne Whalley stealing every scene. Some great character arcs for Darius, Runyan, and Berwick in addition to the aforementioned characters, with a few surprising deaths midway through the season. As much as I like Vignette, I'm pretty much done with the back and forth nature of her relationship with Philo.

However, I've been less of a fan of the heavy horror elements of this season, most notably the level of gore the Sparas inflicts and its actual appearance. That's the kind of thing that immediately put me off of Penny Dreadful even though I really wanted to like that show (yes, I get that's part of the draw of that show but I don't like heavy gore).

I'll hold off on detailed thoughts until the final two episodes and when everyone else has also caught up. Seems like we're all going at it different paces.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top