With respects to the other 'what if?' casting thread in this section, I got to thinking about Gene Roddenberry's aborted second Star Trek series from the mid-70's. The one originally called Phase II that would have aired in September 1978 with Lieutenant Ilya, Will Decker and Xon the boring Vulcan.
Let's try to imagine what interesting up-and-coming tv actors, past-their-prime movie stars, or competing series leads from the mid-70's would have been Roddenberry and the casting director's ideal choices to appear as random characters on the newer Star Trek.
But remember, former TV actors such as John Travolta, Farrah Fawcett and Mark Hamill are ineligeable: Travolta bolted from Kotter in spring '77, Fawcett from Charlie's Angels in '77, and Hamill in '75.
(1) George Peppard: 'Hannibal' was in-between series during this time (Banacek and The A-Team) and would have made a great Matt Decker-type of character...
(2) Tim O'Connor : just one year away from signing on Buck Rogers as Dr. Huer
(3) Michael Gray: He played teen heartthrob Billy Batson on the SHAZAM saturday morning show
(4) Martin E. Brooks or Richard Anderson: Oscar Goldman & Dr Rudy wells from the Six Million Dollar man...
(5) Maren Jansen as Athena from the original Battlestar Galactica. Not a great actress, but a scorchin' hottie that would have been aces in a Bill Theiss outfit!!
(6) Gregory Sierra and Abe Vigoda from Barney Miller (who knows , they could have brought along James Gregory for a second kick at the can
)
(7) Bill Bixby: just before fate took him down the road to immortality...
(8) John Vernon, canadian actor and the original TV Iron Man!! (ok, also Dean Wormer)
(9) Patrick McNee, a few years away from the Avengers, the same year he appeared on Galactica...
(10) Robert Englund : still a few years before V and Freddy, he was doing shows like Nancy Drew at this time...
(11) John Schuck: just coming off the trainwreck that was Holmes & Yo-Yo, have him play the same Klingon from ST 6?
(12) Dick Gauthier: had done a sitcom with Larry Hagman a few years prior, but less than a decade away from the iconic role of Serpentor!!
(13) David McCallum: Ilya of Man from UNCLE, and a couple of years after his series the Invisible Man...
(14) Darren McGavin : was exiled to crap movies unfortunately after the astounding Kolchak the Night Stalker series, a guest shot here would have been awesome!..
(15) Peter Graves: Mr. Phelps!!
(16) Jodie Foster: did a lot of tv series before 1976's TAXI DRIVER but could have done a guest shot (yes, I know I'm breaking my own rules)
(17) Roddy McDowall: nuff said...
(18) Tom Selleck: Was a semi-regular on the Rockford Files at the time (don't remember if he had the 'stache, though)
(19) James Earl Jones: despite Star Wars, he would still do a bit of television, witness Roots: the Next Generation in '79
(20) Richard Roundtree: it's Shaft, 'nuff said!
(21) Carl Weathers (Apollo from Rocky) The Six Million Dollar Man was lucky to get him, he would have played a totally intimidating Klingon (if we follow the later ST series who primarily cast black actors in Klingon roles)
(22) Ken Howard, the coach from my favorite show of 1979, White Shadow...
Let's try to imagine what interesting up-and-coming tv actors, past-their-prime movie stars, or competing series leads from the mid-70's would have been Roddenberry and the casting director's ideal choices to appear as random characters on the newer Star Trek.
But remember, former TV actors such as John Travolta, Farrah Fawcett and Mark Hamill are ineligeable: Travolta bolted from Kotter in spring '77, Fawcett from Charlie's Angels in '77, and Hamill in '75.
(1) George Peppard: 'Hannibal' was in-between series during this time (Banacek and The A-Team) and would have made a great Matt Decker-type of character...
(2) Tim O'Connor : just one year away from signing on Buck Rogers as Dr. Huer
(3) Michael Gray: He played teen heartthrob Billy Batson on the SHAZAM saturday morning show
(4) Martin E. Brooks or Richard Anderson: Oscar Goldman & Dr Rudy wells from the Six Million Dollar man...
(5) Maren Jansen as Athena from the original Battlestar Galactica. Not a great actress, but a scorchin' hottie that would have been aces in a Bill Theiss outfit!!

(6) Gregory Sierra and Abe Vigoda from Barney Miller (who knows , they could have brought along James Gregory for a second kick at the can

(7) Bill Bixby: just before fate took him down the road to immortality...
(8) John Vernon, canadian actor and the original TV Iron Man!! (ok, also Dean Wormer)

(9) Patrick McNee, a few years away from the Avengers, the same year he appeared on Galactica...
(10) Robert Englund : still a few years before V and Freddy, he was doing shows like Nancy Drew at this time...
(11) John Schuck: just coming off the trainwreck that was Holmes & Yo-Yo, have him play the same Klingon from ST 6?
(12) Dick Gauthier: had done a sitcom with Larry Hagman a few years prior, but less than a decade away from the iconic role of Serpentor!!
(13) David McCallum: Ilya of Man from UNCLE, and a couple of years after his series the Invisible Man...
(14) Darren McGavin : was exiled to crap movies unfortunately after the astounding Kolchak the Night Stalker series, a guest shot here would have been awesome!..
(15) Peter Graves: Mr. Phelps!!
(16) Jodie Foster: did a lot of tv series before 1976's TAXI DRIVER but could have done a guest shot (yes, I know I'm breaking my own rules)
(17) Roddy McDowall: nuff said...
(18) Tom Selleck: Was a semi-regular on the Rockford Files at the time (don't remember if he had the 'stache, though)
(19) James Earl Jones: despite Star Wars, he would still do a bit of television, witness Roots: the Next Generation in '79
(20) Richard Roundtree: it's Shaft, 'nuff said!
(21) Carl Weathers (Apollo from Rocky) The Six Million Dollar Man was lucky to get him, he would have played a totally intimidating Klingon (if we follow the later ST series who primarily cast black actors in Klingon roles)
(22) Ken Howard, the coach from my favorite show of 1979, White Shadow...
Last edited: