• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Can You Believe It's Been Ten Years Since TPM Premiered?

*sighs wistfully*

Of course I can't believe it's been 10 years. I'm traumatized as if it were yesterday! :(
 
My reactions to The Phantom Menace...and keep in mind, I was 14 were:

....well, I was going "the advanced buzz didn't like it? this is okay...wow, Jedis fighting droids!"

...basically, everything until they got down to Naboo and met Jar Jar, I thought "wow, this is Star Wars'

Some people hated that "the opening scrawl contained too much information"....hey, I don't think so; I mean they had to say "the Republic is in decline, its taxing the outlying trade routes as a result, but this is making the corporations like the Trade Federation upset that can afford their own private armies; war is looming"

...the "heavy asian accents" for the Neimodians....I kind of thought were odd when I first heard them. But you know what? I said; hey, the Imperials sounded "British...even though its space and there's no Britain"....so I let that go.

I thought the whole thing felt completely flat from the beginning. The opening crawl signaled that Lucas was suddenly taking this universe WAY too seriously. Then once everybody started talking in that stilted, formalized way it was clear that the fun and energy of the OT was gone too.
 
Bilbo Bagshot: The Phantom Menace was eighteen months ago, Tim!
Tim: I know, Bilbo. Okay. It still hurts! It's just that kid wanted a Jar Jar doll!
Bilbo Bagshot: Kids like Jar Jar!
Tim: Why?
Bilbo Bagshot: What about the Ewoks? They were rubbish! You don't complain about them!
Tim: Yeah, but Jar Jar Binks makes the Ewoks looking like... fucking Shaft!
 
In a couple of weeks we will be at the tenth anniversay since the premiere of the release of TPM.

Wow. I vividly remember going to see it. There were four of us: me, my sister, her husband, and Laura, a friend of my sister's I'd met just a few times. After the movie we all went out for a beer and a snack, which meant more quality time with Laura. Wasn't much longer before she and I were officially an item, and we got married a couple years later, and we're still happily together.

Oh, the movie? Bearing in mind that three of us were seriously into SF movies and that sort of thing, and my sister, though not really into it, had grown up on the original movies, we all thought it was really lame. Great evening, though, despite the movie.
 
Bilbo Bagshot: The Phantom Menace was eighteen months ago, Tim!
Tim: I know, Bilbo. Okay. It still hurts! It's just that kid wanted a Jar Jar doll!
Bilbo Bagshot: Kids like Jar Jar!
Tim: Why?
Bilbo Bagshot: What about the Ewoks? They were rubbish! You don't complain about them!
Tim: Yeah, but Jar Jar Binks makes the Ewoks looking like... fucking Shaft!

You beat me to it!

But, working for the Social Security, I also appreciated when she rushed through Tim's benefit application because he hated TMP :)

Plus of course, Peter Serafinowicz who played the guy who stole his boyfriend was the voice of Darth Maul!
 
It's probably different for everyone depending on their age and interests. For me, the 25 years since Terminator kills me.
 
I fell out of love with Battlestar Galactica when season 3 started and I realized "they're making this up as they go along and there is no "Cylon Plan" to the point that they're picking Final Five Cylons based on who would be most shocking, breaking all of their own rules and flat out needing to retcon certain things".........and then I said "maybe its just that BSG is a TV show, and like Farscape season 4 before it, inherently its hard to tell stories on the scale they want because the network will always interfere with their creative freedom...
Actually the "networks" didn't interfere at all with them. Just that RDM and company ran out of steam and couldn't deliver what they promised. They wanted to reel in the female viewers by shoving in stupid romantic plots out of the blue and still left the storylines hanging. The show was called "Battlestar Galactica" which sounds to the average viewer as a scifi action show, now scifi soap opera.
 
It's probably different for everyone depending on their age and interests. For me, the 25 years since Terminator kills me.

Oh yeah??? Well, all those 18-year-olds you see running around who'll be graduating high school this year -- they weren't even ALIVE when Home Alone, Dances With Wolves, Total Recall, Die Hard 2, Pretty Woman, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles and Back to the Future Part III came out!!! :p
 
The CGI looked bad back in 1999. Instead of blending in and helping to sell the story, it was front and center and WAS the story. It looked like a video game back then, it still does now.

It's nowhere as bad as CGI: The Movie (also known as Ultraviolet), but it was still pretty bad. The CGI creatures interacting with the human actors and the space battles were fine, but it was the 100% CGI environment that sucked big time with The Phantom Menace.
 
Ewoks aren't as bad. At least they didn't talk.:lol:

Are you sure?

I thought you were going to show the part in ROTJ where it sounds like the Ewok says " This guy's wise"

Yep...10 years. I basically am a prequel supporter...I just wish George Lucas had somebody watching over him and asking "Are you sure you really want that person to say that?" and "Do you really need that many elements in one effects shot? It may look cluttered."
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top