• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Books, Episodes, and Movies

Its been over a decade since I read them, but I seem to recall that A Flag Full Of Stars and the other Lost Years novels had Kirk as the Admiral in charge of the refit, and while he was on Earth, he was still the one that Decker and the rest of the Enterprise-refit crew had to report to. So while he may not have been hands-on with the refit, he was still in charge.

Well, he was Chief of Starfleet Operations, so by analogy with the U.S. Chief of Naval Operations, he should've been in charge of fleet deployments, operational efficiency, crew assignments, asset allocations, and fleet repairs/refits. That would've put the refit under his purview to an extent, but it would've been just one of many, many responsibilities he had to juggle, and he wouldn't have been the guy directly supervising it, any more than the U.S. Secretary of Transportation is directly managing any given highway-repair project.

Besides, Frontier Doctor doesn't just have him generally overseeing the project, it has him managing it on a detail level, running simulations to fine-tune parameters as niggly as the line of sight from the command chair to the defense station. In TMP, he didn't even know that the phaser power circuits were routed through the warp engines. There's no way he could've been that ignorant of the ship's systems if he'd been such a hands-on participant in the redesign. And as CSO, he was responsible for every ship in Starfleet. He wouldn't have had time to micromanage any single ship's redesign. He would've had someone under him who was responsible for that. Heck, TMP established that he hand-picked Will Decker for that job.
 
Yeah, that does seem odd, but then again Byrne did have a Klingon Emperor in the 23rd Century.
 
Are there any episodes I should watch before reading That Which Divides?
EDIT: I got my books mixed up, so let's make that Crisis of Consciousness instead.
 
Last edited:
I don't think so, but you should watch "Who Mourns for Adonais" after it.
 
I apologize if I already asked this, but I didn't find anything when I tried to do a search.
Are there any episodes besides Carbon Creek and Little Green Men that tie into From History's Shadow and Elusive Salvation?
 
OK, thanks. I already know that one pretty well so I don't need to watch it.
 
Are there any episodes I should watch to go along with Catalyst of Sorrows?
 
Are there any episodes I should watch to go along with Catalyst of Sorrows?

I honestly can't think of any. I don't recall a whole lot about this novel, but I don't recall that it uses any significant plot elements from any episodes or movies. It's just basically some of our canon characters at an earlier age (well, and a later age in the case of Uhura and Dr. McCoy). You'll see a lot of familiar names and places pop up. But I actually don't think there's any episodes that tie into the specific plot of the novel.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top