I think nothing could beat the first time. I was completely unspoiled, so everything came as a surprise, George Kirk's death, the Spock/Uhura relationship, the destruction of Vulcan, the original music on the end credits... what a ride. No other viewing could come close to the first.
This.


so not that many things came as a surprise. I liked it much better the second time, I didn't need to get used to the actors and everything, I was far more relaxed, and I noticed many things I had not the first time. I'll see it for the 3rd time on Wednesday.