• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Best writers?

Mistral

Vice Admiral
Admiral
Saw the "Best SCIFI TV show " thread and got to thinking.

Who is the best episode writer (no movies) in the television scifi sub genre?

Who do you really like?

In no particular order I favor:

Rene Echevarria
Ronald D Moore
Ira Steven Behr
Craig Sweeny isn't bad-but I think I'd like to see more from him before deciding if he really is good for scifi on tv. Ditto for Robert Hewitt Wolfe.

What do you guys think?


 
I'm not sure who is the best in the abstract since it seems to be influenced by the particular show. Weddle & Thompson didn't write much good stuff on DS9, but the wrote some great stuff on nuBSG.
 
My favourite Sci-Fi writers:

Chris Carter - may have produced a muddled conspiracy, but there are a multitude of exceptional one-offs from X-Files and Millennium he wrote which fully outweigh this. The Millennium pilot is in fact one of the finest out there for setting mood, tone and style.

David Kemper
- I think, as a whole. the writing staff on Farscape had a wonderful dynamic, yet list all of Kemper's episodes and you'll see that the vast majority of the brilliance came from his keyboard. Sure he had many of the pivotal arc episodes, but that didn't stop him writing some of the finest character moments on the show. And, heck, ALL TV writers need to take a lesson from him about how to write romance convincingly. His writing of John and Aeryn is one of the most real and complex TV romances full stop.

Ira Steven Behr - Big ideas, big pay-offs. One of the grander SF TV writers building cities in the sandlot whilst others settle for little castles.

Ron Moore - again, loses it in the bigger picture, but his writing can be devestating. With the ability to write wonderfully silly stories like Take Me Out To the Holosuite and In the Cards, and then throw out a Rocks and Shoals, or Occupation is remarkable. In fact his his finest writing for me came out of Carnivale, with Pick a Number and The Day That Was The Day. Needs to rein in his ego somewhat, but when he puts out something like the pilot to Caprica, then I'll give him some latitude.

Joss Whedon - he's certainly a love or loathe him kind of writer given, no matter what he scribbles, it has it's own sence of flippancy and dialogue-patter. Still, heck of a show runner and episodes like The Body, Once More With Feeling, The Gift, Becoming, Objects in Space and A Hole In the World, punch him up into the upper echelons for me.

JMS - his dialgue might be hokey, his plotting a touch convenient at times, but Babylon 5 is a hell of a show, flaws and all. Everything that is good about JMS is in there (HUGE ideas, deep spirituality, tenderness and high tension), as is everything that is bad (a tendancy to over-reach, jingoistic rah-rah "we will win it all" themes), but in the end it's a huge, sprawling complex series that deserves to be near the top of anyones list, as does JMS himself. Though it doesn't match it for grandeur, Jeremiah also shows off some of JMS' writing skills (and foibles).

Rene Echevarria - the unsung hero of DS9 for me. Whilst RDM and ISB were bashing Roddenberry's idealistic Trek universe against the wall, Echevarria constantly tapped into the romanticism of the universe, grounding the characters and making them not only relatable, but loveable too. This trait has come through other shows like Now and Again and Medium, where a real sense of heart shines from the characters. A wasted talent on Terra Nova.

David X Cohen - Head writer of Futurama and on listening the commentaries, clearly the guiding light for most of the character relationships. Whilst the show regularly plays pin-ball with wonderful sci-fi and physics theories I feel he kept it all in check by making us love them all, even the tiny characters like Scruffy.

Michael Piller - hell of a writer, hell of an ideas man, and more importantly, hell of a leader.

Tim Minear - or as I like to call him "The Man That Made Angel". There is no doubt that he and Joss Whedon riff off each other to an almost combustible level, but for me, his work on Angel and Firefly made those shows. On top of that his production of Wonderfalls (and the episodes he wrote) and heck, even The New Adventures of Superman show a continuous level of talent for making the daftest of ideas palatable. The man has had disasterous luck trying to get other shows off the ground (as either creator or showrunner), with wonderful off-beat shows like The Inside, Drive and Terriers dying quick and painful deaths, but all of them have his quirkiness and off-kilter view of their respective universes.

I could go on but these are the SF writers I love and will go out of my way to watch if they produce new material, genre independant.


Hugo - waffler
 
I agree with some of the names already mentioned. And I'll add Steven Moffat and Bryan Fuller to the list.
 
Going back a few decades, writers like Harlan Ellison (even though he didn't write that much science fiction when it came to television), D.C. Fontana, and Samuel A. Peeples should be recognized, too. They did great work on the original Star Trek, as well as a number of other shows.

On the new Battlestar Galactica, the contributions of the writing team of David Weddle and Bradley Thompson cannot be underestimated. Ronald D. Moore (deservedly) gets a lot of credit, but Thompson and Weddle wrote a lot of the show's best episodes.

On Farscape, I think Ricky (Richard) Manning needs some praise. He contributed a lot to that series, both as a writer and a producer.
 
Braga and Menosky - It is amazing how many eps Braga did on Enterprise alone that were decent. As soon as Similitude hit and Coto came aboard the writing went south and the characters were grossly distorted and tortured and the ideas were mediocre. I would have rather seen Moore join Enterprise and that's saying alot.

Menosky is a monster thinker, which is really what Trek boils down to. It's funny though how Braga is going from one show to the next and burning them down for some reason, even his own show. I guess he really doesn't believe in them deep down and therefore feels obligated to destroy them. He's not a creator or good showrunner but he is an incredibly inventive, innovative and unusual thinker. So much so that other sci-fi heavy weight writers refer to odd ideas turned on their head as Braga-esk, which is quite a compliment.

Naran Shankar is also another phenominon and surprising thinker. One good writer makes all the difference as one bad writer can make in a negative way. Moore's meglomania might have been a good match for Enterprise, oddly enough.
 
Really, this list should be Rod Serling, Richard Matheson and then everybody else.

Yeah, I was scrolling through the thread looking for their names.

I'll add Theodore Sturgeon and Jerome Bixby.

And for someone more recent, how about Tracy Torme?
 
Really, this list should be Rod Serling, Richard Matheson and then everybody else.

If we're talking Twilight Zone writers, then we can't forget Charles Beaumont, and to a lesser extent George Clayton Johnson (also author of "The Man Trap" on Star Trek, as well as uncredited re-writer of "What Are Little Girls Made Of?").
 
Really, this list should be Rod Serling, Richard Matheson and then everybody else.

Well you gotta include GR then - the guy who set the template and standard with eps like 'Return of the Archons' and the like.

I have a feeling Manning and Beimler are going to join RH Wolfe with his 'Untitled' Star Trek thing on the sy-fy channel. If Kemper joined as well that would be ideal for me at least.
 
Doesn't Rockne S. O'Bannon also have a project in development at SyFy? If that gets off the ground, I wouldn't be surprised if the Farscape writers ended up there.
 
Really, this list should be Rod Serling, Richard Matheson and then everybody else.

Well you gotta include GR then ...

I considered doing so but in my mind at least GR did not have the same extensive, and consistent, history of brilliant output.

Yes, he created Trek but I see his talents more as those of a great producer or showrunner.
 
Putting Rockne and Wolfe together would be so interesting because they are diametric opposites. Can you imagine them working with each other. Rockne is wierd and off beat and RH is steady and solid - just the opposite of their names.

As for GR not being a great writer - did you ever try writing something as good as 'Return of the Archons' or the like? You'll find it slightly difficult. Serling was the best writer ever period who's like will not be seen again for maybe fifty generations.
 
Besides the Twilight Zone crew, there were the Outer Limits writers, Stefano et al. Star Trek had Gene Coon. X-Files had a couple of writers whose names I'm blocking on (Darin Morgan? Glen Morgan? Somebody Wong?)
 
I suppose I should mention Vince Gilligan. He's better known today as the creator and executive producer of Breaking Bad (a brilliant show), but not too long ago he was one of the best members of the writing staff of The X-Files. He more or less took over the comedy episodes (though he also wrote great dramatic hours) of that series when Darin Morgan left the show after season three.

Darin Morgan, although he only wrote five episodes, was possibly the finest writer The X-Files ever had. He also wrote and directed two wonderfully off-beat episodes of Millennium during that show's second season. They didn't really fit tonally with the rest of the series, but they were great on their own.

His brother, Glen Morgan, wrote some good episodes of both series (with James Wong), but wrote plenty of stinkers, too. Not one of the best writers to come up under Chris Carter, I don't think (as evidenced by his rather unremarkable output in the last ten years).
 
What happened to Alan Brennert? He did the Twilight Zone, which let's face it, is very similar to Trek storywise. In fact alot of these stories are interchangeable not only between the various space show franchises but between the various related Earth bound sci-fi shows like The Outer Limits, One Step Beyond, Fringe, etc., etc.
 
What happened to Alan Brennert?

He hasn't worked in film/television (or at least, had something produced) since he wrote a couple of episodes (one good, one bad) during Enterprise's final season in 2004-2005 according to IMDB. Wikipedia mentions a couple of historical novels he's written since.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top