• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Best of Una McCormack

Arpy

Vice Admiral
Admiral
I recently finished McCormack’s Last Best Hope and remembered how much I liked her. I’m thinking of reading something else of her’s and am wondering what order you’d put some of her Trek works in and why.

They are:
Autobiography of Kathryn Janeway
Autobiography of Mr. Spock
Typhon Pact: Brinksmanship
The Fall: The Crimson Shadow
DS9: Enigma Tales
DS9: Hollow Men
PIC: Last Best Hope
DS9: The Missing
DS9: The Never Ending Sacrifice
DSC: The Way to the Stars
DSC: Wonderlands
Worlds of DS9: Cardassia
 
DS9: The Never Ending Sacrifice

Purchased out of habit. Despite being a Niner, the scenario and character focus didn't appeal much. It sat on my pile without making much effort to rise to the top.

Read it eventually. Definitely in my top three Trek novels ever.

On the right day it could even be in the top one.
 
DS9: The Never Ending Sacrifice

Purchased out of habit. Despite being a Niner, the scenario and character focus didn't appeal much. It sat on my pile without making much effort to rise to the top.

Read it eventually. Definitely in my top three Trek novels ever.

On the right day it could even be in the top one.
What’s pretty high praise. What’s some of the stuff you liked about it?
 
Character, warmth and soul. It's definitely the exact opposite of the star straddling epic, although there is some background "sweep" with some major DS9 events in the background.

It's an organic outgrowth from the show, exploring a small corner of the universe few apart from Una would have thought worth exploring.

Fewer still could have made it great.

I'd have added not to try it unless you have an interest in Cardassia and Cardassians, but ignore that - if it connects with you you WILL have an interest in Cardassia and Cardassians...
 
DS9: The Never Ending Sacrifice

Purchased out of habit. Despite being a Niner, the scenario and character focus didn't appeal much. It sat on my pile without making much effort to rise to the top.

Read it eventually. Definitely in my top three Trek novels ever.

On the right day it could even be in the top one.
I was mostly the same. Avoided the book for years as thought it would never appeal to me (I like books about people on starships solving problems). But this was a really engrossing read with great characters.
 
Another vote for The Never Ending Sacrifice, but moving on from that I will say The Way to the Stars. Which is very surprising as I disliked Discovery and gave up on it after season 2. But one of my favorite parts was Tilly, and this novel is an amazing exploration of her character and backstory.
 
Right now, I would put The Crimson Shadow and The Way to the Stars as my top two Una recommendations. All of those books are worth a read, though.
 
Speaking of her non Trek books, today she released a Firefly novel. Firefly Carnival! I had it preordered just based off the series without realizing she wrote it and went nuts when it downloaded last night and found her as the author
 
Speaking of her non Trek books, today she released a Firefly novel. Firefly Carnival! I had it preordered just based off the series without realizing she wrote it and went nuts when it downloaded last night and found her as the author

I also preordered It before I saw that she wrote It :)
 
I like Hollow men I think it's a really good story and never Ending Sacrifice Also her Picard novel Last Best hope..Una's Doctor Who books are really good stories too. I got them from the library to read a long time ago.I'm really looking forward to get her Picard Raffi novel next year. I like all of her books it's hard to pick a favorite when you like them all equally!
 
Last edited:
Okay, Never Ending Sacrifice is at the top of my McCormack list to check out.

Can anyone comment on some of her other work? Enigma Tales, Brinksmanship, Crimson Shadow, Missing…

I remember reading Hollow Men a while ago too. Vreenak on the cover reeled me in. She’s great giving you the quality of something. I really felt the characters. And I still time to time think about the scene with the latinum vials. Must be part Ferengi.
 
The Never Ending Sacrifice, The Crimson Shadow and Enigma Tales make a great Cardassian trilogy. The latter two books are more directly connected than the former, but they all do a great exploration of their culture.
I would add throw in A Stitch in Time by Andrew Robinson too.

I think Hollow Men is the only book by Una McCormack that didn't leave much impression with me, but I don't recall thinking it bad. Maybe more a case of little interest in the subject matter on my behalf.
 
So, The Lotus Flower, The Never-Ending Sacrifice, The Crimson Shadow and Enigma Tales all cover the rebuilding of Cardassia following the Dominion War.

I read The Lotus Flower years ago and remember enjoying it, with its focus on the O'Briens' life on Cardassia and a tense political situation in a not yet stable nation. The only caveat would be that, in English, it only comes bundled with the Andor entry in the Worlds of DS9 series, so if you don't want to also read that (personally I didn't really enjoy it) it might financially make more sense to buy any of the other novels.

The Never-Ending Sacrifice is truly amazing. It's a great character study of Rugal and 2370s Cardassian society as a whole. It also gives you a bit of a look behind the curtain of what was going on on Cardassia during DS9, tying in with important events such as the various regime changes. I actually read this after the other books mentioned above and I think that works just as well.

The Crimson Shadow has a focus on Captain Picard, but there's still a major Cardassian element and explores the pushbacks of the more regressive groups of Cardassians against Federation aid. This book is also the second book the Star Trek: The Fall mini-series, but I think you can safely read this without being majorly confused about the what's going on. It overlaps with the first book, so this is really the start of the story from the perspective of the characters here. I'd definitely recommend this one.

I recently Enigma Tales, just before The Never-Ending Sacrifice, and it's quite good! Enigma tales, within Cardassian society are considered "low-brow" mystery stories, with that twist that everyone is actually guilty and the state is great (pre-war Cardassia, am i right?) and this novel is somewhat of a twist on that concept. Two caveats continuity-wise: Some elements of this novel spin out of the Section 31 novel Control and may be a bit surprising. The novel also features Kathryn Pulaski and Peter Alden, who have appeared in other McCormack stories, previously. Which brings me to...

Brinkmanship and The Missing. Brinkmanship introduces Starfleet Intelligence guy Peter Alden and is a very interesting look at the structure and workings of Tzenkethi society, so if you're at all curious about that species, Brinkmanship is the novel for you. It's been a looong while since I read it, but I do remember it fondly. It also has Captain Ezri Dax in it, so that's cool too, right?

The Missing is a tad bit weird, in that it's a DS9 novel starring Kathryn Pulaski and Beverly Crusher, as well as having Captain Picard log entries at the start of every chapter. Honestly, I don't remember much about this one, but if you like Pulaski, or are open to liking a version of her that's two decades removed from her TV self you might enjoy this novel. I'd still recommend Enigma Tales over it any day.

I'll also second The Way to the Stars as a great coming of age story.
 
This was a really nice thread to find. Thanks, folks. FWIW, I would've loved to do a final Cardassia book, wrapping up the story there, and a few threads from other books, such as the end of Peter Alden's story, and some Tzenkethi stuff. Alas, not to be. But instead there's a Firefly novel, so yay for that!
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top