If the series retells the "exodus" story, we get the thing that made the RDM/Eick series work, even if there aren't returning characters involved.
Battlestar Galactica getting rebooted (again) for NBS's streaming service
- Thread starter StCoop
- Start date
If the series retells the "exodus" story, we get the thing that made the RDM/Eick series work, even if there aren't returning characters involved.
We could if they made it a prequel. Tell the story of the exodus from Kobol to the first Earth. Then do a show about the exodus from the first Earth to the 24 colonies. That whole "all this has happened before and all of it will happen again" business. They should have don those instead of CAPRICA and BLOOD AND CHROME.
At first I thought they should set nunuBSG in or around present-day Earth, but then I realized we already have that story. It's called Blade Runner.
(IIRC, Edward James Olmos himself has said that he considers BR to be part of the BSG universe.)
(IIRC, Edward James Olmos himself has said that he considers BR to be part of the BSG universe.)
^^^ And Gav was his descendant.
Regardless of what they do, I think there's a strong likelihood that the "Daybreak" denouement of Head!Balter and Head!Six walking around 2009 Earth plays a part in the setup of the series' storyline.
Sam Esmail.
The only reason Caprica failed is they made the narrative conceptually convoluted without substantiating the complexity with a coherent philosophical or emotional core.
I’d be skeptical of a Kobol series just because it’s be hard to tell us anything we don’t already know.
A series focusing on what happened to the toaster cylons who went off on their own at the end in present day could be cool.
I’d be skeptical of a Kobol series just because it’s be hard to tell us anything we don’t already know.
A series focusing on what happened to the toaster cylons who went off on their own at the end in present day could be cool.
Caprica failed because it only gave the audience nudity in the pilot. We got a taste for it, but they left us raw for another year before the series petered out.
Is it true that Caprica was originally a standalone series that had nothing to do with any other show, but had the BSG elements slapped onto it at the last minute?
Sort of.
Around 2005, RDM and Eick started talking about doing a prequel spinoff of BSG, but the project never went anywhere. In 2006, Remi Aubuchon submitted a completely unrelated idea for a story about artificial intelligence to Universal Pictures, who passed on the project, but then sent it down to Universal Television, who brought Eick and RDM into the conversation, at which point Aubuchon's original idea morphed into something that could fit within RDM and Eick's version of the BSG universe, which is why both Aubuchon and RDM are credited as co-creators of the Caprica series.
Which is more what I had in mind instead of a series taking place on Kobol. It could be about the exodus from Kobol to the first Earth. Focusing on a ship, or a convoy (not necessarily a fleet) of ships that can, but doesn't need to be lead by a military ship.
I find when someone is the perfect choice to do something, the results usually end up lackluster. Three years ago? Kurtzman working on Discovery?! Yes please! Now...
Just because someone has a magic touch with one project, doesn't necessarily mean that magic touch is going to travel with them to the next one.
Very true.
Nothing can improve on the beginning of that show, but the middle and end can certainly be improved.
Dwight Schrute should be happy.
NuBSG game out in an era where there weren't a lot of alternatives. ENT was struggling and soon to be gone. Firefly had had its season. Lexx had just got cancelled. Farscape ended about the same time that BSG started. If you wanted a space based serious sci-fi show, NuBSG was it. It became more iconic than the original.
The entertainment market is different now, and in terms of sci fi, it's getting saturated. Add to that rebooting a reboot is a different matter than rebooting a one season episodic show. I have trouble seeing it work out.
NuBSG game out in an era where there weren't a lot of alternatives. ENT was struggling and soon to be gone. Firefly had had its season. Lexx had just got cancelled. Farscape ended about the same time that BSG started. If you wanted a space based serious sci-fi show, NuBSG was it. It became more iconic than the original.
The entertainment market is different now, and in terms of sci fi, it's getting saturated. Add to that rebooting a reboot is a different matter than rebooting a one season episodic show. I have trouble seeing it work out.
Last edited:
I really enjoyed the entire series to be honest so I would rather they made the new series around the first Cylon war than a third version of the same story. I was rooting for Blood and Chrome when it came out but sadly that wasn't to be.
What I think really helped BSG out at the start was the Sci-Fi Fridays where they had it on with Stargates SG-1 and Atlantis. It can't be a coincidence that all three shows took a hit on their ratings when they split them up.
Similar threads
