• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice - Grading & Discussion

Grade the movie...


  • Total voters
    224
Yeah I thought it was just sort of a permanent way of symbolizing that they'd been beaten by the bat so that they don't forget that he's watching. There's a delete scene where Bruce is at a farm watching a cow being branded and then a lightbulb goes on in his head with the origin of the idea. That last part I made up.
 
It brings up the question, but doesn't follow through in my opinion. Are you saing that Batman is branding people because he feels powerless? Batman brands people because Superman exists?
The moment Superman shows up, completely invincible with the powers of a god, Batman just becomes a schmuck in a goofy costume that beats the crap out of people. Not very scary compared to a demigod. So, he starts branding people, which has the effect of getting a beat down in prison, and people start becoming scared of the Batman again :shrug:
 
The moment Superman shows up, completely invincible with the powers of a god, Batman just becomes a schmuck in a goofy costume that beats the crap out of people. Not very scary compared to a demigod. So, he starts branding people, which has the effect of getting a beat down in prison, and people start becoming scared of the Batman again :shrug:

Why would people stop being scared of one hero just because there's a more powerful in existence? And even assuming they did, why would the prospect of a simple prison beating get anywhere near reversing the effect? I'd think Batman's own capabilities ought to strike more fear than prison.
 
Yeah, that's like saying you're no longer worried about your personal bully in school because a new bully showed up and is even meaner than the first. If you're still getting bullied by the first, it really doesn't matter.
 
I had thought the branding was just a way to show that he was becoming more violent, and taking things farther than he used. It could have also just been as a permanent reminder that he stopped them.
 
I thought the branding was a homage to Batman's Zorro roots. Zorro, who used to mark his adversaries with a "z", using his sword.
 
Watched the UE for a second time and find myself liking the movie more and more. The only drawback continues to be that it's just way too long, and takes far too long to build up to the big battle. And there's also a lot more gritty political thriller in this than thrilling superhero movie, which I'm not exactly sure was the best choice for the story. Ultimately it feels like Snyder is just trying a LOT harder than he needs to to justify a story about Batman fighting Superman.

One thing I do find myself more comfortable with though is this much darker Batman, especially knowing that this ultra violent streak is only something that's been occurring in the last 18 months since the Metropolis attack. The movie doesn't really get that point across as strongly as it should, but I do think it helps mitigate the idea quite a bit, to know that Bruce is simply in a really dark place at the time we see him, and just needs someone to break through and pull him back into the light again.
 
Last edited:
Amazon finally shipped my order of the Ultimate Edition. I can't wait to see if it improves upon the film, which I already gave an A, if anyone's curious.

I'm still not much of a fan of Man of Steel (and doubt another viewing would change my mind), but I really enjoyed this movie, and Suicide Squad as well. I'm really liking what WB is doing with the DCCU and I think Wonder Woman looks great too. I know others don't, and that's fine too, but I think it would be a shame to prematurely end this universe after so much groundwork is being laid. I know that's not a worry right now, but I know I've read (maybe not here, but other places) that some people want these films to crash and burn so WB will end the DCCU
 
Henry Cavil posted this on his Instagram.

https://www.instagram.com/p/BJI-eYSgRR8/


Also there is this cool photoshop by georgeevangelista.
https://www.instagram.com/georgeevangelista/
tumblr_obmetdOShn1qjzyxso1_1280.png
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top