• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Bashir replaced by a Changeling: the implications

t_smitts

Fleet Captain
Fleet Captain
The nice thing about the timing of the DS9 crew's transition to the "First Contact" uniforms, and the fact that the real Bashir was seen in the older style uniform gives us a rough estimate of how long a Changeling's been impersonating him. Now definitely, any episode from "Rapture", on he's a Changeling, perhaps even further back than that for an episode or two like "The Ascent". (I think any more than that is stretching things, since it was supposedly only four weeks, and if you go by what the Okudas came up with the Chronology, every episode is separated by about two weeks, with the episodes themselves possibly taking up as much as the same time themselves).

Rewatching those episodes with that knowledge puts a spin on things. With regard to the infant Changeling, the DS9 Companion, I believe, included some interview with one of the writers explaining away his lack of attention by the Changeling being aware that the infant couldn't be saved, but does seem like not much effort was made to determine that, let alone bringing it home to its people. (The Female Changeling once told Weyoun that Odo meant more to the Founders than the entire Alpha Quadrant, after all).

But setting all that aside, there's also the issue of the Bashir-Changeling performing brain surgery on Sisko in "Rapture". Obviously, when Changelings replaced Bashir, they couldn't possibly have known which medical procedures Bashir might be called on to do, and therefore, to avoid suspicion, would have to become just as knowledgeable as a Starfleet Officer who graduated second in his class after EIGHT YEARS of medical school. Does the Dominion have some way of implanting that much knowledge into someone in a relatively short amount of time? Do Changelings have eidetic memories?

On top of that, it's interesting that the Bashir-Changeling passed up an opportunity to have Sisko die from some sort of "complications", thereby ridding the Dominion of Starfleet's most troublesome captain, and striking a devastating blow to the morale of the Bajorans. Maybe the plan to destroy the Bajoran sun with a bomb took priority, and the Bashir-Changeling couldn't blow it's cover under any cirmcumstances (assuming, of course, that was it's mission all along. We don't know).

Two sidenotes on this arc:

1) I've read a few things (including the Encyclopedia, I believe), suggesting the bomb was a suicide mission. I don't buy that, mainly for the reason of what the Female Changeling said. Besides which, the runabout could easily outrun the blast, even at warp 1 (of course so could the alliance fleet, which is why the plan never made much sense, along with the question of what that would do to the wormhole, no matter how much stronger it had become).

2) I retrospect, I really wish that "Doctor Bashir, I Presume" was not the first episode to follow the real Bashir's return. It makes no sense that neither Bashir's parents, nor Zimmerman, would've brought up what happened. (Yes, they couldn't brought it up off-screen, but that just seem like a cop out for avoiding something that realistically should've been addressed).
 
A few notes:

Bashir was supposedly abducted in his sleep. Why, then, was he in uniform, be it old or new? If he sleeps in his old, soft uniform but wears his new, stiff one during the working day, then all bets are off as to when exactly he was kidnapped.

The Changeling infant that restored Odo to Changelingness might have been an expendable piece of goo sent to do exactly that. Remember that the Founders don't really care all that much about their so-called infants - they kick them out into space for use as reconnaissance drones, not even caring to recover them until they themselves somehow manage to return. Possibly infants are just so much raw material for them, and only those that have already collected information and matured to deliver it are considered worth recovering.

Was the Dominion really interested in nova-bombing the Bajoran sun? The way the episode played out, this seemed like mere diversion so that the more important mission, that of jamming the wormhole open and starting the invasion of the Alpha Quadrant, could be conducted. For all we know, the fake Bashir never had a nova bomb (since the Dominion never had access to such a thing in any other episode), only a device sending enough signals to fool our heroes into believing in a bomb.

(And as a side note, this is one of those episodes where using warp drive inside a star system is considered "risky". Perhaps Bajor has horrible subspace weather, such as in "Invasive Procedures" or "Things Past", and this was one of the worse days, making it likely that a fleet trying to warp to safety would in fact end up hurting itself big time? However, this is not a requirement if we just assume the nova bomb was a sham and a diversion.)

As for the brain surgery and the failure to "fumble" it and kill Sisko... Well, Changeling mimicry is perfect in the general case. Only one impostor was ever revealed through a slip-of-the-tongue type mistake (in "Heart of Stone"), and that wasn't due to holes in knowledge, just a failure to understand in full the psychology of the situation. This would seem to call for extremely good and complete absorption of information, including the full knowledge, skills and personality of the victim of the impersonation. So perhaps it indeed is something psychic or technological that the Founders do as a matter of routine - whenever they impersonate somebody they have captured for study?

Timo Saloniemi
 
I refuse to let the uniform dictate which episodes Bashir was a Changeling in. Look at Sisko when he went to Earth in Homefront/Paradise Lost; different uniform than he normally wears. Maybe not a perfect excuse, but enough for me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JLA
I refuse to let the uniform dictate which episodes Bashir was a Changeling in. Look at Sisko when he went to Earth in Homefront/Paradise Lost; different uniform than he normally wears. Maybe not a perfect excuse, but enough for me.

Uniforms were a costume/art department choice, not a storymaking choice. It is interesting to speculate what effect the changeling may have had had he replaced Bashir at an earlier stage, the uniform change does not necessarily date the abduction/replacement. Moreover, different types of uniform coexisted--see Voyager.
 
With regard to the infant Changeling, the DS9 Companion, I believe, included some interview with one of the writers explaining away his lack of attention by the Changeling being aware that the infant couldn't be saved, but does seem like not much effort was made to determine that, let alone bringing it home to its people. (The Female Changeling once told Weyoun that Odo meant more to the Founders than the entire Alpha Quadrant, after all).

I don't think that is a hard and fast rule: it seems that other Changelings have been willing to expose Odo to lethal danger, and that Odo would at least have been incinerated when the Bajoran sun blew up in By Inferno's Light.

But setting all that aside, there's also the issue of the Bashir-Changeling performing brain surgery on Sisko in "Rapture". Obviously, when Changelings replaced Bashir, they couldn't possibly have known which medical procedures Bashir might be called on to do, and therefore, to avoid suspicion, would have to become just as knowledgeable as a Starfleet Officer who graduated second in his class after EIGHT YEARS of medical school. Does the Dominion have some way of implanting that much knowledge into someone in a relatively short amount of time? Do Changelings have eidetic memories?

The Adversary establishes that a talented Changeling can replicate an organic lifeform down to the cellular level, indistinguishable by scans. This would suggest that they are capable to understanding the anatomies of the creatures they are imitating at the deepest levels. This knowledge might allow them to improvise advanced medical skills. OTOH, brain surgery might not be more complicated in the 24th century than "insert probe here."


Maybe the plan to destroy the Bajoran sun with a bomb took priority, and the Bashir-Changeling couldn't blow it's cover under any cirmcumstances (assuming, of course, that was it's mission all along. We don't know).

Short-term gains, long-term losses. Good operatives don't spoil well-made plans with random attacks

2) I retrospect, I really wish that "Doctor Bashir, I Presume" was not the first episode to follow the real Bashir's return. It makes no sense that neither Bashir's parents, nor Zimmerman, would've brought up what happened. (Yes, they couldn't brought it up off-screen, but that just seem like a cop out for avoiding something that realistically should've been addressed).
Three consecutive episodes (or more) of not playing the true Bashir may have greatly affected Siddig's patience. It was also the first episode of the season that focused on his character's development, so it was bound to be disappointing. The fact that his abduction was not made part of DBIP suggests that it was not part of long term planning of the series, therefore not written into episodes previous to In Purgatory's Shadow.
 
I refuse to let the uniform dictate which episodes Bashir was a Changeling in. Look at Sisko when he went to Earth in Homefront/Paradise Lost; different uniform than he normally wears. Maybe not a perfect excuse, but enough for me.

Uniforms were a costume/art department choice, not a storymaking choice. It is interesting to speculate what effect the changeling may have had had he replaced Bashir at an earlier stage, the uniform change does not necessarily date the abduction/replacement. Moreover, different types of uniform coexisted--see Voyager.
So...we agree?

It was a storymaking choice though. The uniform was specifically mentioned in the script for the episode. Not that that changes anything, just thought I'd mention it. :)
 
I refuse to let the uniform dictate which episodes Bashir was a Changeling in. Look at Sisko when he went to Earth in Homefront/Paradise Lost; different uniform than he normally wears. Maybe not a perfect excuse, but enough for me.

Uniforms were a costume/art department choice, not a storymaking choice. It is interesting to speculate what effect the changeling may have had had he replaced Bashir at an earlier stage, the uniform change does not necessarily date the abduction/replacement. Moreover, different types of uniform coexisted--see Voyager.
So...we agree?

It was a storymaking choice though. The uniform was specifically mentioned in the script for the episode. Not that that changes anything, just thought I'd mention it. :)

We do agree, and no, it was not necessarily a story making choice. That line could have been inserted on sight on the basis of production decisions rather than writers' choices. Hell, they could have used that line with the old uniform, and it would have seen just as odd and clunky.
 
Perhaps the Changeling Bashir simply didn't consider it in its people's best interests to have Sisko die in "Rapture". That's not what it was there to do. It wasn't important to the mission. Besides, if the Bajorans' beloved Emissary dies, that could affect Bajor's status re: the Dominion, and I doubt they wanted to risk that (wasn't Bajor putatively allied with the Dominion at some point?).

For similar reasons that Michael Eddington (in "Our Man Bashir", I think it was) still worked as hard as he could to save the holodeck-trapped crew, even though he was Maquis. It wasn't in the Maquis' radar to let them die. That wouldn't have been important to their mission, either.

Three consecutive episodes (or more) of not playing the true Bashir may have greatly affected Siddig's patience.

That reminds me, was Sid actually TOLD (before the reveal) that he was playing a Changeling? Did he know all along that Bashir would be replaced, or did the writers only tell him when the changeling was 'unmasked'?
 
Three consecutive episodes (or more) of not playing the true Bashir may have greatly affected Siddig's patience.

That reminds me, was Sid actually TOLD (before the reveal) that he was playing a Changeling? Did he know all along that Bashir would be replaced, or did the writers only tell him when the changeling was 'unmasked'?

Good question. I would like to think that Bashir is judging Odo when he is diagnosing his back pain in The Begotten, signaling that this was a changeling, but I might be trying to hard. It's at least more likely that Alexander Siddig was being cantankerous because his character's development was being ignored. Siddig was getting lines, but his character wasn't going anywhere.

ETA: depending on how tight the storywriting and script delivery was, Siddig may have known while filming Inferno that his character--his real character--would be exposed in DBIP.
 
2) I retrospect, I really wish that "Doctor Bashir, I Presume" was not the first episode to follow the real Bashir's return. It makes no sense that neither Bashir's parents, nor Zimmerman, would've brought up what happened. (Yes, they couldn't brought it up off-screen, but that just seem like a cop out for avoiding something that realistically should've been addressed).

Particularly since the title itself seems to bring up the issue.
 
They didn't take the changeling fear as far as I thought they would. We never found out who the final five hidden changelings were. ;)
 
If the Founders can engineer plagues and clones. They can certainly perform brain surgery on a human.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JLA
That reminds me, was Sid actually TOLD (before the reveal) that he was playing a Changeling? Did he know all along that Bashir would be replaced, or did the writers only tell him when the changeling was 'unmasked'?

The latter.

"Apparently, I'd been a changeling for the previous three or four shows before this fact was revealed in "In Purgatory's Shadow". But I didn't know it until the last minute. So obviously it had no impact in how I'd played him in those earlier episodes. Once I did know, I had a chance to do something about how the other Bashir behaved. But what a shock!" - Alexander Siddig (Star Trek: Deep Space Nine Companion).
 
  • Like
Reactions: JLA
I'm glad they didn't tell him, even if it's because they themselves hadn't decided yet. I'm not the biggest fan of Sid's "I have a dark secret" acting style. By not telling him, you can be guaranteed that he won't ham it up as Secret Bad Guy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JLA
Siddig was told during filming of "For the Uniform":

"I was told during "For the Uniform" where I had one scene which was played as a Changeling. They must have decided not to tip their hand at that point and give anything away so they cut the scene."
 
  • Like
Reactions: JLA
Siddig was told during filming of "For the Uniform":

"I was told during "For the Uniform" where I had one scene which was played as a Changeling. They must have decided not to tip their hand at that point and give anything away so they cut the scene."

And ironically, his one and only scene in that episode (in which he and O'Brien talk about Eddington) wound up on the cutting room floor.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JLA
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top