• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

"Balance of Terror" is a touchstone for the Discovery story arc

Agree. And I can't understand why DS9 is so popular. It just doesn't feel like very STAR TREK, and not because they were stuck on a space station. But because it was about war, in the end. And in TOS war was something to be avoided at all cost, including having to start a real one to stop a neverending, sanitized war.

Well, Kirk did get pissed when the Organians kept the Federation and Klingons from killing millions. :lol:
 
I'm pretty sure the comments about Balance of Terror are just about tone, and maybe even just the type of story that it was, I doubt DSC will actually be related to it's story. I see a lot of people talking about the Romulans as bad guys, but I really doubt we'll see Romulans in the show, given the time period Klingons seem to me like the most likely bad guys.
 
I read it as a model for having fleshed out characters on either side of the conflict (as much as any episodic show in the 60s could have). If so, it should mean no important characters will be uni-dimensional cliches. Beyond that, no way to tell, really.
 
This.

I really want Trek to go back to its "Twilight Zone"/"The Outer Limits" roots, where the universe was this weird and wild place where anything could happen. More political drama like DS9 would make me very, very sad.
Well I think you're going to be disappointed then.

I like when Star Trek gets weird, but I can't see those strange one off type episodes happening in STD.

I hope I'm wrong. We know the series is going to be a big story arc, but I would like to see some one off episodes inserted here and there, but I don't think it fits the format when you're only doing 10 episodes per season.
 
If it comes from "Balance of Terror", it would have to come from Sulu and Stiles concerns about infiltrators.

I tend to think the divided arrowhead from early on means "Number One" is going to have some kind of divided loyalties. So it would fit with the lines from "Balance of Terror". It would also fit Fuller's many ranks comment.

Your post and this thread made me suddenly think that
Line in the delta represents the Neutral Zone.
 
Well... Maybe the entire series its about Romulans, and the neutral zone bases ....yeah, a full story and development, but .... at the end, the Discovery is destroyed in his secret mission and the federation never knows (or never talks) about them. A Talos IV sort of thing.
We know the Romulans, we have a good story, and they keep safe the prime timelime
 
To be clear-- whether Balance of Terror is a literal reference or just the spiritual foundation for the new series I am happy. But I also enjoy wondering how the literal references from that episode (and others) might fit in.

Speculation is a human trait!
 
She has to be another species, or why would Fuller make the comment that she's a Lt. Cmdr but she'll have many ranks. Clearly she's a Vulcan who went undercover with the Romulans and now this mission pertains to whatever she uncovered. I'm 100% positive that this is my uninformed opinion.
 
She has to be another species, or why would Fuller make the comment that she's a Lt. Cmdr but she'll have many ranks. Clearly she's a Vulcan who went undercover with the Romulans and now this mission pertains to whatever she uncovered.

I think it is the other way around. She's Romulan, masquerading as a Starfleet officer. A deep cover assignment, much like T'Pel from "Data's Day".
 
I read it as a model for having fleshed out characters on either side of the conflict (as much as any episodic show in the 60s could have). If so, it should mean no important characters will be uni-dimensional cliches. Beyond that, no way to tell, really.

This meshes with the rumor that there will be a Klingon Captain in the main cast.
 
I read it as a model for having fleshed out characters on either side of the conflict (as much as any episodic show in the 60s could have). If so, it should mean no important characters will be uni-dimensional cliches. Beyond that, no way to tell, really.
That would be scifi heaven :bolian:
 
I would want the romulan side entirely in Rihannsu (which spellchecks as Rihanna's U. A very different scifi..um..heaven?) for that authentic Das Boot feel.
I remember this from the books "My Enemy, My Ally" and the "Romulan Way". Read them decades ago.
 
I remember this from the books "My Enemy, My Ally" and the "Romulan Way". Read them decades ago.

I keep trying to get through the books, but the language also shows up in STO.
Am pretty sure I read some of them way back, but they didn't stick in memory.
 
She has to be another species, or why would Fuller make the comment that she's a Lt. Cmdr but she'll have many ranks. Clearly she's a Vulcan who went undercover with the Romulans and now this mission pertains to whatever she uncovered. I'm 100% positive that this is my uninformed opinion.

I think it is the other way around. She's Romulan, masquerading as a Starfleet officer. A deep cover assignment, much like T'Pel from "Data's Day".

That's the whole Discovery story arc right there.

https://www.wired.com/wp-content/up.../uploads/2012/10/Federation_RomulanPoster.jpg
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top