• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Babylon 5

Display in C&C. The top display shows Space Craft THX1138 (Circled) in the docking bay just before Captain Pierce is pictured, in a nod to George Lucas. The bottom display shows the aliens scanning the language banks in the station computer. The top word was supposed to be ORAC. They did get FORBIN, NOMAD and SKYNET correct. Acknowledging SCI FI computer systems that have gone rogue.

merge-from-ofoct.jpg

That was a great little reunion party we four had that day. :)
 
There's not much to dissect.

Two of the three podcasts I listen to prove otherwise (I'm going to end up saving the last one for next Friday).

I agree with one of said podcasts that "Believers" is the nadir of Season 1, but my reasoning is based not on the quality of the writing, but on the nature and substance of the story.

I did come to a realization about something in the episode from listening to the podcasts I'm following, though: Kosh's quote of "The avalanche has already started. It is too late for the pebbles to vote" could be construed as preemptively referencing Dr. Franklin deciding to disregard the parents' wishes and perform the surgery, which adds more dimension to the Vorlons and himself, especially coming off of his actions in "Deathwalker" if you think about said actions in the context of
Talia's mind being taken over by a sleeper personality in Season 2.
 
Most of what bothers me about "Believers" is that the episode seriously damages my opinion of Franklin. Or maybe informs my opinion of him in a way that I don't enjoy.

As a doctor, in particular, the whole thing may have been a Kobayashi Maru, and maybe the parents' views are terrible viewed through our humancentric lenses, but their views aren't terrible viewed through their own culture, and he could have shown some respect for that.
 
Franklin's behavior in "Believers" is consistent with how he's portrayed in "Soul Hunter" and "Infection" and informs how he ends up behaving in "The Quality of Mercy; it's unfortunate that the narrative vehicle chosen to expand his character this early on ended up being religious fanaticism, because with a different story, the series could very easily have succeeded in what it was trying to do with his characterization.
 
Of course, "Forbin" wasn't the name of the system. Forbin was the man who designed the Colossus system.
Colossus/Guardian has too many letters to fit on one line in the limited font available in 23rd century Earth Force computer systems. :lol:
 
The early DS9 novel "The Siege" by Peter David (nothing to do with the season 2 ep) ripped off the Believers plot but changed the ending with the mother deciding to have the son treated (and being disowned by the father, though his culture forbids remarriage so this isn't meant as a good end for him either).

The main thrust of the book is Odo facing off against a Changeling (not identified as such at the time and I don't think they'd come up with the idea of the Dominion yet) serial killer.
 
It could be that the book was released after the episode aired but written beforehand. The vagaries of scheduling and such.
 
"Babylon Squared"

A bonkers, heavy episode that feels drenched in significance. Time travel, Great Wars, prophecies, destinies, and more. The show's grand arc seems to be getting started.

I got chills when the "flash" occurred sending Sinclair and Garibaldi into an intense, unknown future (?) - that's effective. The show hasn't been afraid to present prolonged mystery, and a dose of drama was much needed.

The question of what exactly caused the Minbari to halt the war on the brink of victory is answered... but as ever, this answer begs endless more questions. The only part of this I wasn't too fond of was Delenn's overly grovelling praise of humanity as an amazing, noble, courageous, intelligent, great, remarkably important race.

Other than that minor blemish, this was a very good episode. Let's not even get started on the appearance of the aged Sinclair and what this portends going forward. The occasionally awkward table-setting part of the show seems to be done - with two episodes left in the first season, the story feels like it's truly beginning.

Rating: ****

-Acting with Jerry Doyle: "Take that! How about you! Take some take some!!!"
-Some decent comedy moments here as well, which is encouraging in that Londo doesn't need to be present for the show to be funny. The characters are more likeable when they can at least make you smile rather than cringe.
-"Zathras does not want to die. But if it is the only way, then Zathras dies."
 
The only part of this I wasn't too fond of was Delenn's overly grovelling praise of humanity as an amazing, noble, courageous, intelligent, great, remarkably important race.
Always consider the perspective. The Minbari have essentially been...I don't want to use the word "stagnant" but let's say "a plateaued trinary homogony" for going on a thousand years. They have what they feel is a perfectly elegant system: three castes. You pick your lane, you stay in it, you continue to do so until you die and always do what your elders tell you.
A race that leaps from not being able to escape their own planet's gravity to being a galactic power in a quarter of that time, all while ceaselessly bickering with each other would blow the mind of any Minbari. By rights, according to their world view we should have murdered each other into extinction before we even split the atom.

Humanity's "importance" isn't some mystical touch of divinity, it simply has a catalysing factor (diversity) in the existing dynamic of mostly monolithic and insular galactic cultures. A wildcard. Such things are important during times of change, and Delenn knows a change is imminent. It just makes sense to her based on what she's seen that the humans are to play a role.
 
Last edited:
Maybe of some interest: Warner Brothers has remastered the show and has put up the new 4:3 SD-Version on iTunes and Amazon Prime. The Complete Remastered Series is currently on sale for $30 on iTunes. The show may still just be SD but just look how much clearer and sharper it is now. Check out the console the guy is walking past between 0:25 and 0:30 or the signs in the backround at 2:36 in the video for an example.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

https://twitter.com/straczynski/status/1328634855823876097
 
Last edited:
Maybe of some interest: Warner Brothers has remastered the show and has put up the new 4:3 SD-Version on iTunes and Amazon Prime. The Complete Remastered Series is currently on sale for $30 on iTunes. The show may still just be SD but just look how much clearer and sharper it is now. Check out the console the guy is walking past between 0:25 and 0:30 or the signs in the backround at 2:36 in the video for an example.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

https://twitter.com/straczynski/status/1328634855823876097
Interesting. I was watching on a phone, but I was noticing that on like Marcus’s moustache you can make out the individual hairs vs the original were it’s just a brown thing. So if they went to the film masters that Straczynski said they had to deliver at the end of each season, then it looks like Warner Brothers at least made a 480p scan, (maybe even a PAL 576p at 24 frames and then for NTSC converted from that) whereas the original 90’s transfers, even the widescreen versions were all done at 480i and 576i (the PAL masters, which are the source for the NTSC widescreen DVD’s and files would’ve been in 576i, which is PAL SD).
 
Last edited:
The Complete Remastered Series is currently on sale for $30 on iTunes.

Not yet, apparently.

I just checked - individual remastered seasons are available, but not the entire series in one bunch.

(Also, all five remastered seasons, if bought together, add up to about $40.)
 
Last edited:
Not yet, apparently.

I just checked - individual remastered seasons are available, but not the entire series in one bunch.

(Also, all five remastered seasons, if bought together, add up to about $40.)
The Complete Remastered series is available on iTunes Canada for $59.99 CAD. Odd thing though, it appears that, according to the couple of episode trailers I checked, the main episodes are in 4x3, for all 5 seasons, but “The Gathering” is included and it’s been Remastered in 16x9 Anamorphic Widescreen!!! So on the DVD’s and for years on streaming “The Gathering” was in 4x3 for both versions while the rest were widescreen,, but now they’ve Remastered it in Widescreen and put the Rest of the Remasters in 4x3!
 
Maybe of some interest: Warner Brothers has remastered the show and has put up the new 4:3 SD-Version on iTunes and Amazon Prime. The Complete Remastered Series is currently on sale for $30 on iTunes. The show may still just be SD but just look how much clearer and sharper it is now. Check out the console the guy is walking past between 0:25 and 0:30 or the signs in the backround at 2:36 in the video for an example.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

https://twitter.com/straczynski/status/1328634855823876097

I'm super-curious what the source is for the "before" videos. At first I assumed they were the DVDs, cropped back to 4x3, but there are some uncropped VFX segments, so they must be from the videotapes, the laser discs, or rips of one of the earlier 4x3 online streaming releases (I think Netflix had Babylon 5 in the original aspect ratio for a while).

The Complete Remastered series is available on iTunes Canada for $59.99 CAD. Odd thing though, it appears that, according to the couple of episode trailers I checked, the main episodes are in 4x3, for all 5 seasons, but “The Gathering” is included and it’s been Remastered in 16x9 Anamorphic Widescreen!!! So on the DVD’s and for years on streaming “The Gathering” was in 4x3 for both versions while the rest were widescreen,, but now they’ve Remastered it in Widescreen and put the Rest of the Remasters in 4x3!

I just checked, it's a crop. Ironically, "The Gathering" had been the best-looking Babylon 5 production on DVD since it wasn't put through the original widescreen remaster. Judging by the iTunes preview, the opposite is now true.
 
I'm super-curious what the source is for the "before" videos. At first I assumed they were the DVDs, cropped back to 4x3, but there are some uncropped VFX segments, so they must be from the videotapes, the laser discs, or rips of one of the earlier 4x3 online streaming releases (I think Netflix had Babylon 5 in the original aspect ratio for a while).



I just checked, it's a crop. Ironically, "The Gathering" had been the best-looking Babylon 5 production on DVD since it wasn't put through the original widescreen remaster. Judging by the iTunes preview, the opposite is now true.
Well for Babylon 5 we know that there are Digital Betacam 4x3 NTSC & PAL masters from the 90’s, 4x3 35mm film masters that were last viewed in the 90’s and Digital Betacam 16x9 PAL masters. I’ve only looked at them on a phone but the remasters look like they came from a new film scan at 576p or 480p (Or they could’ve done a 4K or 1080 scan and only released the SD versions.). Even in SD, on a phone there was more detail than the old masters has. Of course if they did an HD scan of the film it would be nice if a Blu-Ray was released!

As for “The Gathering”. are the live action scenes crops or was it framed for widescreen and the film master was preserved in anamorphic (also which cut is it, the original or SE) ? I know some will people will point out that TG apparently wasn’t made widescreen in 98, but Straczynskinski was also working on a limited budget and simply couldn’t afford to rescan every frame.
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top