• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Anyone else hate the aliens?

The casting people probably requested that aliens come to to audition, but only humans kept showing up. Go figure.
 
"This cardboard villain race role has to be ours. The Klingons are at a rock festival, the Romulans are all sick, The Ferengi are out of town and the Cardassians weren't told where the auditions are being held!"
 
The Kazon were supposed to be based off Hispanic street gangs who were just as often fighting one another as they were fighting everyone else.

The writers just didn't bother thinking up a real gang hierarchy or relations between the gangs. It might have worked out better if each faction LOOKED different from the other (even in coloring and clothing) and if they were competent rulers of each of their territories. And if there were some actual value/social differences between the tribes.
I just shows how blind the writers are of the cultures and races that surround them every day.

Like the Romulans, if they had bothered using real Roman history we could've had some wonderful stories of how they rule the Empire with a Senate composed of elected officials and "Old Families" with hereditary political powers, the clashes between these groups, whom the Tal Shiar are more loyal to, how both feel about the Vulcans, etc.
 
The Kazon were supposed to be based off Hispanic street gangs who were just as often fighting one another as they were fighting everyone else.

The writers just didn't bother thinking up a real gang hierarchy or relations between the gangs. It might have worked out better if each faction LOOKED different from the other (even in coloring and clothing) and if they were competent rulers of each of their territories. And if there were some actual value/social differences between the tribes.
I just shows how blind the writers are of the cultures and races that surround them every day.

Like the Romulans, if they had bothered using real Roman history we could've had some wonderful stories of how they rule the Empire with a Senate composed of elected officials and "Old Families" with hereditary political powers, the clashes between these groups, whom the Tal Shiar are more loyal to, how both feel about the Vulcans, etc.
I always saw the Romulans more like Russians than Romans.

Tal Shiar= KGB
Neutral Zone= Iron Curtain
The silent competition of info & technology= Cold War aspects
 
Yeah, but the TOS Klingons were the Soviet analogues. Since the Romulans were meant to be space Romans (with some Germany in there too) they may as well run with it.
 
Yeah, but the TOS Klingons were the Soviet analogues. Since the Romulans were meant to be space Romans (with some Germany in there too) they may as well run with it.
I thought in TOS the Klingons were based on Mexican Banditos?
 
Klingons remind me of Samurai.
Their hair, honor system & armor
Kazon are like black gangsters.
Nappy afros or dreadlocks, tribal colors & fur.

Hmm but I always think that most Klingons are black :guffaw:
I don't find any traits that represents that in them.

Could be because I'm black, and I can identify a bit with klingons(i'm a B'Elanna, I have a temper) so therefore I see myself? Or just cuz Worf is black...No, but seriously, aren't most of the Klingons black? Well, the actors that portray them...
 
Hmm but I always think that most Klingons are black :guffaw:
I don't find any traits that represents that in them.

Could be because I'm black, and I can identify a bit with klingons(i'm a B'Elanna, I have a temper) so therefore I see myself? Or just cuz Worf is black...No, but seriously, aren't most of the Klingons black? Well, the actors that portray them...
I'm African-American too and theres more to us than just an attitude.:lol:
It would be sad if that's the only thing we as a race bring to the table.

...and no, most of the actors that played Klingons are not black.
Be'Lanna is half Klingon/half Latina.
The majority of Klingons that are prominately featured in Trek have been played by White actors.
 
I don't find any traits that represents that in them.

Could be because I'm black, and I can identify a bit with klingons(i'm a B'Elanna, I have a temper) so therefore I see myself? Or just cuz Worf is black...No, but seriously, aren't most of the Klingons black? Well, the actors that portray them...
I'm African-American too and theres more to us than just an attitude.:lol:
It would be sad if that's the only thing we as a race bring to the table.

...and no, most of the actors that played Klingons are not black.
Be'Lanna is half Klingon/half Latina.
The majority of Klingons that are prominately featured in Trek have been played by White actors.

Ok, when I reach the Klingon era in DS9 I'll take a look.
As for the temper, I have a temper, this has nothing to do (as for a I know) with my colour, but with me. What I meant was identifying with a character. And since I'm half black/half white, in winter I actually have the B'Elanna colour, but in summer I'm more of a Worf :)

But to get back on topic; Klingons make up had been done very well. But I'm always wondering if the writers or make up people or who ever makes up how the aliens should look, actually think of function for their "otherness". (such as the ridges with Klingons, nose Bajorans, spots Trills etc) WHat comes in mind now is the ears of the Ferengi, they are said to have better hearing.
 
Could be because I'm black, and I can identify a bit with klingons(i'm a B'Elanna, I have a temper) so therefore I see myself? Or just cuz Worf is black...No, but seriously, aren't most of the Klingons black? Well, the actors that portray them...
I'm African-American too and theres more to us than just an attitude.:lol:
It would be sad if that's the only thing we as a race bring to the table.

...and no, most of the actors that played Klingons are not black.
Be'Lanna is half Klingon/half Latina.
The majority of Klingons that are prominately featured in Trek have been played by White actors.

Ok, when I reach the Klingon era in DS9 I'll take a look.
As for the temper, I have a temper, this has nothing to do (as for a I know) with my colour, but with me. What I meant was identifying with a character. And since I'm half black/half white, in winter I actually have the B'Elanna colour, but in summer I'm more of a Worf :)
:guffaw:

I see you're light skinned, like me.
Mostly African-American/West Indian with Native American and Asian mixed in for good measure.
 
I hated that they tended to all look the same. A few bumps on the head, or a ribbed nose, and you have your alien of the week. With few exceptions this was always true.
 
I hated that they tended to all look the same. A few bumps on the head, or a ribbed nose, and you have your alien of the week. With few exceptions this was always true.

But it was extraordinary how different the principal Klingons looked; Gowron, Martok, Kor and Worf were no mere identikits. They were incredibly different. The Ferengi on DS9 were the same. However I will agree that aside from DS9 which was exceptional in character development, the other shows were indeed forehead decoration alien of the week.
 
I liked some of them. Such as the "Mr Potato Head" species ("Tinker, Tenor, Doctor, Spy") whatever they were called.
 
No, I don't hate the "bump on the forehead aliens".

But I always wished that they would come up with something more different, like the aliens in "The Swarm".

They should have made more computer-animated aliens.
 
In 1995, it would have been too expensive to do CGI. It's why they got rid of the 8472 aliens.
 
I liked some of them. Such as the "Mr Potato Head" species ("Tinker, Tenor, Doctor, Spy") whatever they were called.
The Higharchy.
..or at least that's what their government was called.
They never gave the aliens themselves a name.

I always got a craving for a Butterball Turkey every time I saw them. They had that "I've just been basted" look to them. :lol:
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top