• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Another Space Station or Starbase Show

My issue isn't the Federation, my issue is that the Federation comes off as too human-centric, in a sense?
This...
When TNG rolled out, people didn't like it, but it found its footing and became one of the greatest Trek shows ever made.
is at odds with this as TNG had two non human characters out of the main cast, and TOS one alien. Both are considered the greatest Trek shows, yet they primarily center on the humans responding to the alien situations.

It still needed that grounding element.
 
This...

is at odds with this as TNG had two non human characters out of the main cast, and TOS one alien. Both are considered the greatest Trek shows, yet they primarily center on the humans responding to the alien situations.

It still needed that grounding element.
True enough.

I think TNG did great, although in future shows, I wish they did more with alien crewmembers.
 
This is where the issues start here, is that the narrative and in universe elements have to suffer because of the studio and audience has a certain viewpoint of what the show should be. Star Trek shouldn't be afraid to be bold, when it is afraid to be bold, we get watered down plots.
Star Trek is owned by a corporation and as such it has to dance to that corporation's tune.
My issue isn't the Federation, my issue is that the Federation comes off as too human-centric, in a sense?
The shows do have a budget and it's cheaper to have human characters as there's no prosthetics or makeup to make them look alien.
When TNG rolled out, people didn't like it, but it found its footing and became one of the greatest Trek shows ever made.
Became one of the most popular Trek shows ever made, and as a result has become the template of what the higher-ups want Star Trek to be. And even then, TNG got lucky it was allowed to continue to the point where it gained popularity.
 
I'd definitely like a less human-centric Federation depending on the budget

Overall, I'd actually like a series set on a planet, maybe one further from the Federation, and/or on a smaller runabout-type ship
 
The idea is sound as a budget saver back to the original concept of DS9 and B5: the action is happening somewhere else "off camera" and this is the place where they debate and talk about it. Of course there WOULD still be action there....
 
I have to assume the fact that nobody has brought up the obvious Starbase 80 backdoor pilot Lower Decks ended with is the idea is so good it doesnt even need to be stated.

Having a series about Klingons or Romulans would be far too niche to be viable. Sure, it could attract a few Trek fans, I could likely see myself enjoying such a series. But the only audience it could get are pre-existing, you would not draw any new fans to such a show and like it or not, Star Trek needs to draw in new blood into the fandom.
They should use their podcast show idea to make stuff more niche like a Klingon series
 
My issue isn't the Federation, my issue is that the Federation comes off as too human-centric, in a sense?

Humans are the baseline. Start with/center around them and everybody's basically familiar with human biology and culture; you can develop the alien cultures a little at a time. Start with the new interesting alien cultures and you have to introduce a lot of lore (or at least it seems that way).
 
My issue isn't the Federation, my issue is that the Federation comes off as too human-centric, in a sense?

I've had this issue forever. My hot take: Trek bit off more than it could chew when it made the Federation one united interplanetary government instead of a looser UN style alliance, where Starfleet would just be based on Earth

To answer the OP, I'd definitely like another Trek set on a space station or even a planet
 
I have had a lingering concept in my head for a show featuring a planetary base or colony, which either became isolated through the Burn, or if in a different time period, was the result of a ship crashing or being forced to land (maybe even a voluntary stranding for the greater good) and then never recovering interstellar capability.

It could be taking elements of Mr Sahil from Discovery, and those episodes (Children of Time, E2 and Twilight) that have components of an isolated or stranded crew. The series could story arc from the original stranding through to a reconnection event with Starfleet and potential conflict and reluctance of either an original crew, several years on, (allowing for our long between-season gaps), or their descendants, being suddenly compelled to reintegrate into Starfleet.

Other series like Terra Nova, the 4400 and similar could be influences, creating an anthology of quite different seasons, but keeping the same crew and environment or sets. We would see the colony growing and new cast arriving.

I also like the idea of the planet initially being thought to be Minshara class but with no sentient population, (perhaps that influencing why it is selected), only to at some stage find there is in fact a native intelligent life form (Prime Directive issues).

As the show progresses, the colony transitions into a planetary base - we follow the population and leadership's struggles with than, and the series develops into a more "outstation DS9" feel.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top