The only reference we've had is the rock-climbing teams in ENT and VOY, neither being horizontal gaps..
An away team come to a large ravine. Do they re-beam or use equipment to get across?
- Thread starter hxclespaulplayer
- Start date
Forcefield bridge.
But yeah on TV they'd probably use the transporter rather than splash out on new FX.
But yeah on TV they'd probably use the transporter rather than splash out on new FX.
I'm not sure we'll find a better answer to this question that is otherwise best left to scholars and philosophers.
Realistically, it would depend on how much of a budget the episode or movie in question had.
And whether Sir Patrick's representation demanded an action scene for him?
Answer: They'd jump in the Starfleet dune buggy they've ALWAYS had onboard.
This short documentary shows why site-to-site beaming is not recommended in proximity of large ravines.
I think this is actually a plot beat in the TOS novel Uhura's Song by Janet Kagan. I think some characters opt to beam over and some opt to use a teetery rope bridge, or something like that.
"Lifesigns detected just north of your position."
"Beam us over."
"No, it's only like 50ft from your position."
"Beam. Us. Over."
...I'd be a very lazy captain.
"Beam us over."
"No, it's only like 50ft from your position."
"Beam. Us. Over."
...I'd be a very lazy captain.
“Sorry, Away Team. We are experiencing transporter malfunctions due to an ion storm that started seconds after you beamed down. Our projections say, it’s over in 38 minutes in time for the credits. Have fun.”
If your away team is under the command of a geriatric idiot, you don't beam to the other side of the wall - you waste time cutting through it with your phaser.
Apart from that, though, the heroes basically never ran into a situation where the transporter would have been an option for defeating terrain. It doesn't work in deep caves, or beyond the horizon, or inside shielded structures, or close to weird anomalies and exotic substances, or when there's high wind. Am I forgetting a case we could use to argue the ravine issue?
Timo Saloniemi
Apart from that, though, the heroes basically never ran into a situation where the transporter would have been an option for defeating terrain. It doesn't work in deep caves, or beyond the horizon, or inside shielded structures, or close to weird anomalies and exotic substances, or when there's high wind. Am I forgetting a case we could use to argue the ravine issue?
Timo Saloniemi
high wind, light mist.. reasons not to beam..
Reading a book the other month.. beam us to the shore of the lake that the evil stronghold is in the middle of.. Okay crew.. how do we get there? uhh...
Why didn't we beam in?
"it has a scrambler and cant beam to it"
"okay, can they send down a dingy?"
" to big to transport"
"I ain't swiming in there.. who knows what kind of Shark-turtle combo creature is in there"
" as a leader.. I have to make sacrifices for the greater good.. Get in the water"
" With all do respects.. %&$^##@ you sir, I refuse"
"then all the inhabitansts will DIE!"
"&$#(#&.. %&**#&#^&@ .. natives.. can't we just let these guys die.. just this once?"
"No"
"But its dangerous!"
" no Red shirt.. you have to go in to prove how dangerious it is"
"...."
"Go"
"fine.. but my blood is on your hands"
"fine"
gets in.. Sharkturtle grabs him and grinds him to a pulp
" Oh.. guess its danegerous.. Someone call up for a shuttle!"
Reading a book the other month.. beam us to the shore of the lake that the evil stronghold is in the middle of.. Okay crew.. how do we get there? uhh...
Why didn't we beam in?
"it has a scrambler and cant beam to it"
"okay, can they send down a dingy?"
" to big to transport"
"I ain't swiming in there.. who knows what kind of Shark-turtle combo creature is in there"
" as a leader.. I have to make sacrifices for the greater good.. Get in the water"
" With all do respects.. %&$^##@ you sir, I refuse"
"then all the inhabitansts will DIE!"
"&$#(#&.. %&**#&#^&@ .. natives.. can't we just let these guys die.. just this once?"
"No"
"But its dangerous!"
" no Red shirt.. you have to go in to prove how dangerious it is"
"...."
"Go"
"fine.. but my blood is on your hands"
"fine"
gets in.. Sharkturtle grabs him and grinds him to a pulp
" Oh.. guess its danegerous.. Someone call up for a shuttle!"
Last edited:
And then suddenly, after posters have presented rational explanations and ideas, in leaps the Evil Leaper John Logan...
Logan: "I know -- we'll have Picard break out the 24th century dune buggy again and jump it like the General Lee!"
Logan: "I know -- we'll have Picard break out the 24th century dune buggy again and jump it like the General Lee!"
Last edited:
From The Cage:
Similar threads
