• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Alexander addressing Worf as "Sir"

Respect has to be earned. Lots of parents do an awful job of parenting and don't deserve their children's respect. But in general, though, I agree with you. Growing up, my parents always had the last word, and my sister and I knew it. But because they were and are decent people, it just gave us a sense of security. My husband and I are trying to do the same for our son, and so far it seems to be working.

I'm from Finland, and I've grown up in a culture where children call their teachers by their first name, or even a nickname. The only time I've called anyone sir or miss was when we lived in the UK for a year when I was in my early teens. In all my years of going to school in Finland I've never seen teachers have as many problems keeping order in class as I did during that year in the UK. So the expected form of address doesn't necessarily correlate with genuine authority.

When I went to college, one of the exchange students I used to hang out with was a member of the French aristocracy, and he told me that he addressed his parents with the formal 'vous' rather than the informal 'tu' and I thought that was really strange.

Alexander was fairly old when he first met Worf. I'm not sure if he ever learned to relate to him emotionally as a father, although he accepted him as an authority figure.
 
Alexander was fairly old when he first met Worf. I'm not sure if he ever learned to relate to him emotionally as a father, although he accepted him as an authority figure.
Probably not. One of the biggest things that surprises parents when I am working with them is that emotional relationship begins extremely early, in infancy, with a child. It is difficult to build but not impossible as a child gets older. After all, a child only knows what is modeled or taught, but they also learn what emotions are OK or not OK.

Alexander and Worf probably had a lot of struggles, and the use of "Sir" is potentially indicative of that.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top