Why are all these people helping this guy that just commited cold blooded murder? It isn't really relevant if this changeling is discriminated against, he still murdered that Klingon and should receive due process. This is the second time Odo has gone off the deep end (first time was with the female changeling), a man of law and order he is not.
About Chimera s7e14
- Thread starter damfino
- Start date
My gripe is the opposite. What we saw was a standard Klingon duel, including a public challenge and all. If you die, it's your own fault. So why are the Klingons making a fuss?
The hero position here is pretty clear. The Klingons around them do that all the time, to people who can actually die. It's about time they got to pay some sort of a price for it.
As for Odo, he ever was a man of law. He always was law. His law. Which is sort of understandable, as he got his job exactly because he actively despised law and was good at perverting and ignoring it. This served both his ever-changing masters and his personal yearning for order and domination just fine.
Timo Saloniemi
The hero position here is pretty clear. The Klingons around them do that all the time, to people who can actually die. It's about time they got to pay some sort of a price for it.
As for Odo, he ever was a man of law. He always was law. His law. Which is sort of understandable, as he got his job exactly because he actively despised law and was good at perverting and ignoring it. This served both his ever-changing masters and his personal yearning for order and domination just fine.
Timo Saloniemi
First, Laas would not have received due process from the Klingons, just summary execution.
Second, there’s a self defense argument. It’s not clear if Odo was right the Klingon was reaching for a disruptor. If he was, or if Laas believed he was, I guess it depends if Bajor has a “Stand your ground” law.
Second, there’s a self defense argument. It’s not clear if Odo was right the Klingon was reaching for a disruptor. If he was, or if Laas believed he was, I guess it depends if Bajor has a “Stand your ground” law.
C
Captain pl1ngpl0ng
Guest
it wasn't "all these people", it was only Odo who wanted to help him.
And i can see why Odo felt that there was some prejudice against Laas,
granted, there really was no need to kill the Klingon. With all his powers he could
have stopped him without deadly force.
Then they could have had that Changeling Pride-Demonstration on the Promenade...
And i can see why Odo felt that there was some prejudice against Laas,
granted, there really was no need to kill the Klingon. With all his powers he could
have stopped him without deadly force.
Then they could have had that Changeling Pride-Demonstration on the Promenade...
Because most Klingons are cowards
Because despite how Klingon religion and ethics might view murder, it still might be considered a crime against the state. Moreover, it could be in the interest of the military to protect its resources and obtain latitude for its soldiers.
I agree that it's out of character for the Klingons to be making a fuss about getting killed after a challenge.
However, Klingon law is irrelevent on the station. Odo's law was supposed to be Station law as layed out by the Magistrate, Sisko, and Bajor. The self defense argument clearly doesn't apply; Laas was in no more danger from the Klingon than an adult from a child's squirt gun. Laas should have restrained himself. And Odo doesn't like killings on his watch. No weapons on the promenade, doesn't carry a phaser, etc. He's clearly stretching a point to let Laas go just because he's another changeling. Not satisfactory; would Sisko let a person who committed murder go just because he was another human? I hope not.
Similar threads
