I absolutely loved this movie.
I've seen it twice since it has come out, and I think it's probably the most fun movie of the year so far (I haven't seen Toy Story 3 yet). Where Iron Man 2 felt dutiful and slightly pedantic, The A-Team was an extremely fun movie which had a terrific balance at story and characterization. In an ensemble movie like this, the chemistry of the leads is very important and it worked perfectly. You believed that these guys were a team and that they were close. The casting was pitch-perfect: Liam Neeson added a lot of gravitas to Hannibal, Bradley Cooper was the perfect amount of suave over-manliness as Face, Sharlto Copley absolutely nailed the zany craziness of Murdock, and Quinton Jackson actually surprised me as B.A. He could have been a lot more obnoxious and annoying, trying to emulate Mr. T, but director Joe Carnahan took a page out of J.J. Abrams' notebook and allowed the actors to give their own individualized interpretations of the characters, verses repeating the performances of the originals verbatim. I'd say as a result The A-Team is a perfect example at how to adapt a beloved TV series into a modernized motion picture, alongside Abrams' own Star Trek revival.
Was the film crazily over-the-top, ridiculous and unbelievable? Absolutely, but this is The A-Team that we are talking about so you drop reality at the door. Nevertheless, the film was rooted in the interpersonal dynamics of the four leads, and that is where the film succeeds the most. I also enjoyed Patrick Wilson as "Lynch", who seemed to be really having fun in the role. It's a nice departure for him, who is accustom to playing darker roles like in Little Children and Watchmen. When Carnahan said he could have made a better Mission: Impossible III (he was once attached as director before Abrams stepped in) I scoffed at the notion but seeing at how incredibly and surprisingly well this movie worked I might have to give him some credence. While I still really liked M:i:III, Carnahan was somehow able to really mix all of the ingredients necessary to make a really fun, involving, and heartfelt film.
I usually despise dumb summer movies (I'm looking at you, Transformers movies) but probably because this was so much fun that I just ran with it and suspended my disbelief without a hitch. I would seriously love to see a sequel, so long as Carnahan is back as is Neeson, Cooper, Copley and Jackson.
Did anyone else really enjoy Alan Silversti's score? It's nice to see him scoring eventful summer tentpoles again (I didn't see G.I. Joe: The Rise of Cobra...) since I'm a big fan of his big summer action movie scores of the 80's (the Back to the Future movies, Mac and Me, Predator, The Delta Force, and of course his TV scores for CHiPs and Starsky & Hutch). I thought, seeing as how The A-Team was an adaptation of a 80's TV show, his hiring was appropriate.