• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

A few questions?

GulGoneCrazy

Lieutenant
Red Shirt
These questions always bothered me...
Some of them are stupid but... cardassian curiosity is killing me :cardie:!

1st. Have u ever wandered where all the garbage and biological waste from toilets and other stuff is dumped in starship? Simply in space or there is other solution?

2nd If the replicators can replicate very complicated spare parts of all kind of technology is that mean that gigantic replicators (with powerful energy source) could replicate a entire ship??

3nd How Quark manages to make a profits from drinks he sales ???I mean there are replicators all over the station ,why pay when u don't have to??

4th If holograms can be set to kill mode, why everybody just don't built holographic war ships?

5th If time travel is discovered by so many races ,hows that no one of them tried to change past in global sizes?

6th How different races produce offspring when there is big anatomy or DNA difference?
Shouldn't that end in some kind of mutation?

7th Space is full of resources, there are many planets that are entirely formed of metal or other valuable ores ,hows that galaxy is not swarming with huge numbers of ships?

8th All crews we saw in star trek series are most of their time in ships or stations ,how they don't get sick because they eat replicated food,air is always the same,no sun,and they rarely exercise?
 
These questions always bothered me...
Some of them are stupid but... cardassian curiosity is killing me :cardie:!

You stirke me as new to this forum, as these are all farily beginner questions. But that's fine, we all start somewhere and I'm happy to help.

1st. Have u ever wandered where all the garbage and biological waste from toilets and other stuff is dumped in starship? Simply in space or there is other solution?

It's reprocessed. The stuff that is not usable at all is crushed using a high gravity press into inert cubes and stored til a starbase visit. The rest is cleaned and reprocessed into the basic material the replicator uses to generate new food.

2nd If the replicators can replicate very complicated spare parts of all kind of technology is that mean that gigantic replicators (with powerful energy source) could replicate a entire ship??

No. The replicators are pretty much energy hogs. Using them to make small items is not so much, but the bigger and more complex the item the greater the power requirements. So it just makes economical sense to manufacture things using more conventional methods. Also, there are numerous materials which simply cannot be replicated (such as latinum) and we must assume that such materials are required to build starships. There are, however, large scale industrial replicators, we hear of them in DS9. But they are rare birds indeed, there being something like one or two on all of Bajor and not many more in the Cardassian Union. So, I guess you could say there is a point of diminishing returns for replicator use and replicating whole starships isn't practical.

3nd How Quark manages to make a profits from drinks he sales ???I mean there are replicators all over the station ,why pay when u don't have to??

Most Federation replicators produce synthihol instead of the real deal, and we might assume that the Cardassian replicators on the station have the same restriction. For all we know, it may be that the alcohol molecule is one of those things that don't ever replicate properly. Quark has the good stuff on hand. Even if we don't assume the replicator can't make alcohol, we can assume that it's programs are limited and Quark has a wider selection. At any rate, I think most of his profits come from holo-suite rentals and gambling. After all, his place is half casino and casinos aren't successful because they also have bars...

4th If holograms can be set to kill mode, why everybody just don't built holographic war ships?

The "kill mode" is just that the holodeck won't take precautions like automatically disappearing a prop bullet or bit of shrapnel and that might cut into and damage an unarmored person. After all, the props in a holodeck are physically replicated items controlled by force fields like super-tech puppetry. Normally such a prop would be removed by the safety programs if they threatened a person, but this feature can be shut off for some reason. Warships are well protected from that sort of thing and I doubt a holodeck can create a working phaser. Note that when Picard went to the holodeck and turned the safeties off, he blew away the borgified Ensign Lynch with a tommy-gun, not an energy weapon. I'm sure he chose this program partly because he knew a fake holographic phaser wouldn't do the trick.

5th If time travel is discovered by so many races ,hows that no one of them tried to change past in global sizes?

Sometimes they do. See "Year of Hell" on Voyager.

6th How different races produce offspring when there is big anatomy or DNA difference?
Shouldn't that end in some kind of mutation?

All humanoid life was seeded in the galaxy billions of years ago by some ancient race of proto-humanoid aliens. It was explained on "The Chase" on Star Trek: the Next Generation.

7th Space is full of resources, there are many planets that are entirely formed of metal or other valuable ores ,hows that galaxy is not swarming with huge numbers of ships?

This actually is not true at all. All worlds are formed of a unique collection of ores and minerals (and gases...). What's more, starships are made of complex alloys and manufactured goods, not raw mineral. Such resources need to be found, gathered, processed, and used to make a ship. Not to mention the fact that you need ship yards and a whole infrastructure to support them. Also, there is the bureaucracy needed to organize such large scale projects. Star Trek has always shown us that the future is in many ways, not so different from how things are today, at least where this sort of thing is concerned. Remember one of McCoy's closing lines in ST4, "The bureaucratic mentality is the one constant in the universe."

8th All crews we saw in star trek series are most of their time in ships or stations ,how they don't get sick because they eat replicated food,air is always the same,no sun,and they rarely exercise?

They have holodecks for "getting out." Besides that, most of the crews we've seen have periodic away teams to explore places, so they get some sun. There are the more remote locations, like sub-space relay stations and that sort of thing, but I assume those are fairly short postings, like astronauts and cosmonauts serve on the I.S.S. Plus, the medical technology of the future probably helps compensate in some valuable way. but I assume it can be a problem, especially during TOS, where in more than one episode, McCoy was griping about the crew needing some much deserved R&R.

Hope that helps!

:)

--Alex
 
Most Federation replicators produce synthihol instead of the real deal, and we might assume that the Cardassian replicators on the station have the same restriction.

We extremely seldom hear of there being any difficulty in obtaining booze. Bashir and O'Brien got pissed in their cabin in "Explorers" easily enough, and then pondered going to Quark's, or switching to synthale, until it turned out they were too drunk to do either.

Quark probably just sells the ambience. It's not as if we ever see his customers pay for their drinks, after all.

As for the need for sun or exercise or fresh air or food that has been grown in dirt or cut off screaming animals, that's just wishy-washy treehuggerspeak. Humans do just fine without!

Timo Saloniemi
 
In an enterprise episode in which I fought to stay awake (as with most all enterprise episodes) archer mentions the poopoo that can not be broken down into reusable proteins is recycled into insulation, building materials ect

Star fleet officers eat poo, literally
 
Quark ... It's not as if we ever see his customers pay for their drinks, after all.
After Bashir and O'Brien were apparently killed, Quark said: "They were good customers, they always paid their bar bills on time."

Not their gambling debts, or holodeck rental fees.

:)
 
Star fleet officers eat poo, literally

...But at least it's human poo, as opposed to the cow poo that we all eat nowadays.

After Bashir and O'Brien were apparently killed, Quark said: "They were good customers, they always paid their bar bills on time." Not their gambling debts, or holodeck rental fees.

Good point. I guess Quark could still sell ambience if every drink had a sufficiently low price tag attached. Although it may be there are price tags on drinks no matter where they come from; Bashir and O'Brien might have to pay their cabin replicator bills (or have Starfleet pay them for them) at the end of each month, assuming the replicator systems are in Bajoran commercial hands. After all, Starfleet is just administering the station for Bajor, and would have an interest in charitably letting the Bajorans reap direct financial benefits.

Sisko does point out to Quark that he could charge the bartender rent (and back rent) on the premises, but how much of that is bluff, we don't know. It just goes to establish that Starfleet is indeed doing charity work there, at least from Quark's point of view. Fleet personnel maintain the replicators, but having Quark charge for their use would be a logical extension of the charity work.

Timo Saloniemi
 
1st. Have u ever wandered where all the garbage and biological waste from toilets and other stuff is dumped in starship? Simply in space or there is other solution
It was established in ENT that the ‘waste’ was recycled for other uses. By the 23rd and 24th centuries they would continue to do the same, though with more advanced tech.

2nd If the replicators can replicate very complicated spare parts of all kind of technology is that mean that gigantic replicators (with powerful energy source) could replicate a entire ship??
Some parts may not be able to be replicated so would need to be built. Also with the size of ships, the replicator would need to be enormous, the energy demands and raw material requirements would also make it a less-favourable option.

3nd How Quark manages to make a profits from drinks he sales ???I mean there are replicators all over the station ,why pay when u don't have to??
Because you go for the mood and enjoyment and shenanigans you could get up too. It’s always more fun to drink in a bar with others than to do so at home alone.

4th If holograms can be set to kill mode, why everybody just don't built holographic war ships?
Technical malfunction. A hologram is a tool, only as good as its made. Besides not everyone is space is looking to kill others.

5th If time travel is discovered by so many races ,hows that no one of them tried to change past in global sizes?
ENT threw up a Temporal Cold War (which has to be the stupidest idea ever, but I digress). The Krenim wanted to change timelines, but never got it right. Time is a dangerous mistress, there is no way of knowing what might happen, to who, and when. Destroying one planet might eradicate a cure for a deadly plague that kills all life in the universe, or stops the inhabitants from formulating a means of stopping the Borg, etc.

6th How different races produce offspring when there is big anatomy or DNA difference?
Shouldn't that end in some kind of mutation?
Not every species will be compatible. In DS9, Jadzia was undergoing ovarian resequencing treatment to have a child with Worf, so there are ways and means around some species barriers.

7th Space is full of resources, there are many planets that are entirely formed of metal or other valuable ores ,hows that galaxy is not swarming with huge numbers of ships?
Not every species will want to explore space. Plus all the ones who aren’t advanced enough. Space is vast and ships are small.

8th All crews we saw in star trek series are most of their time in ships or stations ,how they don't get sick because they eat replicated food,air is always the same,no sun,and they rarely exercise?
Replicated food is eaten everywhere, so most people will have eaten it all their days, those that eat fresh food are in the minority. The air is recycled using highly advanced life support and environmental systems, so it is clean and pure every minute of every day (unless they go offline). Holodecks provide artificial sun, they go on away missions and have regular shore leave. We don’t see them exercising, but there are frequent mentions of it, as well as gyms being established on most series. They are the military wing of the Federation, which would mean they would need to reach and maintain a certain degree of fitness to be eligible for active duty.
 
GulGoneCrazy wrote:
5th If time travel is discovered by so many races ,hows that no one of them tried to change past in global sizes?

Most big races have a DTI, according to Bennet the Klingons, Romulans and the Faederation have one. Maybe some others too but i cannot recall.
 
Most Federation replicators produce synthihol instead of the real deal, and we might assume that the Cardassian replicators on the station have the same restriction.

We extremely seldom hear of there being any difficulty in obtaining booze. Bashir and O'Brien got pissed in their cabin in "Explorers" easily enough, and then pondered going to Quark's, or switching to synthale, until it turned out they were too drunk to do either.

Worf also says in "Up The Long Ladder" that the replicators can produce standard booze in addition to synthehol, although the quality of the replicated whiskey is apparently debatable to some drinkers. ;)
 
GulGoneCrazy wrote:
5th If time travel is discovered by so many races ,hows that no one of them tried to change past in global sizes?

Most big races have a DTI, according to Bennet the Klingons, Romulans and the Faederation have one. Maybe some others too but i cannot recall.

DTI?

--Alex

Department of Temporal Investigations, introduced on the DS9 episode Trials and Tribble-lations.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top