Re: A Challenge For Everyone - Please Read & Comme
Looks like I've missed the kerfuffle on the forum over the last couple of months but as someone who's enjoyed joining in with the fun on a few occasions in the past here's my two pennyworth (from a quick scan of the thread so far I see some of my points have been made already and I've borrowed others but I'm just laying out some of the ideas I like).
I think something that would cut down on any arguments once a contest being underway is being specific about what should be included in the opening post by the previous month's winner - i.e. formalise the headings to ensure all valid information is available from the start.
So the opening post should specifically state, for example:
Title / Subject e.g. "Down and Dirty" / "Surprise" / "Enterprise - the movie" / etc
Format e.g. landscape / starscape / movie poster / advert / badge / uniform / any (by default)
Medium (which IMO should be suggested rather than proscriptive) e.g. drawing / painting / photoshop / 3D CG modelling / whatever
Image size - e.g. 1024 x 768
Additional info - any other point to clarify the content, or at least what's in the originator's mind when setting up the competition. Also re-iterating ongoing rules such as "no using wholesale existing compositions", and "WIP threads nice but not essential".
Closing Date for discussion of topic - date by which any comments or questions clarifying competition rules should be made
Closing Date for competition itself i.e. midnight on final day of month (GMT?)
Submission of valid entries - e.g. usually by email to current holder (showing email address to be used), though some winners don't seem to mind picking up from existing threads as well (but it needs to be laid out here)
Voting period - e.g. up to fourth day of next month
And there are probably some other key facts which I can't think of which need to be included as well.
I think that by at least laying out all the facts in the opening post in a clear manner and consistent manner, it means that subsequent debate centres around meaningful discussion points rather than "what did he mean by that?". Also, the first headings should make it pretty clear how constraining a competition will be from the get-go, leaving one or two of these criteria blank will open up a competition (though personally just having a title / subject for me is a little too freeform, like others - when I do enter - I like something to focus on to stimulate and challenge a bit more).
If this idea or similar were to work I would suggest that
Ptrope advise the new holder of what should be included in the opening post at the close of the previous month's poll and then once the advised time period for discussion has been made, either the thread is closed and a new one opened with revised conditions or
Ptrope edits the original post (though this might cause confusion on re-reading the thread). At least then nobody can validly say "But I didn't understand the rules" when their picture is omitted on the final polling thread.
And while I think about it - the rules should be repeated on the poll thread too - at least then people will know what criteria they
should be judging it against. (Whether they do or not of course is a completely different matter all together)
Anyway like I said that's just my two pennyworth. Hopefully some of the ideas above might help. Use or ignore as you wish.
While I'm here for the record, my personal views on some of the other points raised.
WIP threads - I like them, and when I did enter some compos way back when (the book cover and the movie poster come to mind) some of the advice given was very useful. But they shouldn't be mandatory either; I've done a couple of fun entries, the humour of which would be completely lost if I had to post in advance.
Competition winners re-entry - I haven't got the skill to win any of these competitions but if I did manage to struggle through one month and persevere to victory I'd be pretty pee'd off if I couldn't enter with an idea I wanted to try. While the contest should be a lot of fun, it would be nice to get some reward out of it too.
That's it for now and hopefully there'll be a contest within the next couple of months which I'll feel inspired enough by and confident enough to enter.