• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

50th Anniversary Rewatch Thread

Having just recently discovered time travel, it makes sense that Starfleet would play around with it a bit before deciding it was too risky for routine use.

Doesn't seem very responsible. It sounds like a kid playing with a box of matches. Do we wait till he starts a major fire before taking it away from him?
 
It's weird they have records on exactly what kind of adventures Gary and Bob got up to, which was presumably not widely known to public, but have to send a starship to research actual history... :shrug:

Right. This episode has a lot of cool trappings, like Seven's physical prowess, the nature of the aliens who sent him, the beautiful (x2) cat, dialogue like "Impossible for you, not for them," and even the mysterious deaths of the two agents that Seven was checking up on, but boy is the Enterprise shoehorned in. I give them credit for trying, though. Do we know what the new show was going to be called?
 
Doesn't seem very responsible. It sounds like a kid playing with a box of matches. Do we wait till he starts a major fire before taking it away from him?
I was picturing a situation in which the Enterprise returned to their century to find things mostly the same but with subtle changes, then advised Starfleet Command that maybe casual use of time travel wasn't a great idea.
 
Assignment Earth is a good episode. Good pilot episode for another series. Robert Lansing and Terri Garr are good together. I would have like to have seen that series.
At the risk of sounding like an echo chamber, the problem with "Assignment Earth" is that it's a pilot for a completely different series awkwardly shoehorned into a Star Trek episode, and it's a poor fit. The contrivance of intentional time travel for the purpose of "historical research" is, well, contrived.

One thing I worried about is Isis when she and Gary Seven are way up in the air sabotaging the rocket. I worry that she was going to fall.
Don't you know that cats always land on their feet? :rolleyes:

. . . I don't like it how Seven owned Kirk and Spock and then even a ditzy girl like Roberta got the droo on them.
The "droo"? I'll chalk that up to a typo -- unless there's a new slang word I haven't heard yet. :)
 
I was picturing a situation in which the Enterprise returned to their century to find things mostly the same but with subtle changes, then advised Starfleet Command that maybe casual use of time travel wasn't a great idea.

Like someone finding out that his previous wife was now married to his rival for example...
 
They had to make Roberta plucky and resourceful so viewers would want more of her. Not sure that worked out.
 
Yup, Teri Garr never seemed to embrace Star Trek very much. Perhaps because for her, it was a failed pilot. Her loss.
Her loss? Frankly I think she dodged a bullet. Actors who did sci-fi shows often got typecast, and in the 70s she landed roles in a lot of movies from The Conversation to Young Frankenstein to Close Encounters and in the 80s was in Mr. Mom nominated for an Oscar for her role in Tootsie.
 
Her loss? Frankly I think she dodged a bullet. Actors who did sci-fi shows often got typecast, and in the 70s she landed roles in a lot of movies from The Conversation to Young Frankenstein to Close Encounters and in the 80s was in Mr. Mom nominated for an Oscar for her role in Tootsie.

She's quite good in Young Frankenstein!
 
^^
I does highlight how futuristic ST was by comparison... "See this large black&white hall with hundreds of people... all this is going to be replaced by a tiny bridge... in glorious colour!" ;)
I should add to this exchange that in my other 50th anniversary viewing, I'm finding that TV shows in this era are littered with references to the Moon program. In particular, people have already started saying "We can send a man to the Moon, but...," and it hasn't even happened yet!
 
Right. This episode has a lot of cool trappings, like Seven's physical prowess, the nature of the aliens who sent him, the beautiful (x2) cat, dialogue like "Impossible for you, not for them," and even the mysterious deaths of the two agents that Seven was checking up on, but boy is the Enterprise shoehorned in. I give them credit for trying, though. Do we know what the new show was going to be called?

I don't know maybe Assignment:Earth would have a been a great title for the show if it had gone to series?
JB
 
I don't know maybe Assignment:Earth would have a been a great title for the show if it had gone to series?
JB

Referring to Seven's assignment, then, instead of the Enterprise's; sure, that makes sense. I don't know if that was the planned title.
 
@ssosmcin is credited on some, assignmentearth on another. Whoever’s responsible, all are cool and way faithful to the period. If only … if only.

Oh my, you dug those up? Man, it's been years since I tooled around with making opening credits for fun. Thanks for the shout out. :)
 
Just rewatched Assignment Earth.

Spock scoffs at petting tribbles but has no problem petting a cat....

Spock claimed he was immune to tribbles.

SPOCK: (stroking a tribble) A most curious creature, Captain. Its trilling seems to have a tranquillising effect on the human nervous system. Fortunately, of course, I am immune to its effect.
(Everyone stares, he suddenly realises what he is doing, and puts it down. Spock and Kirk leave.)

That's because cats are awesome! :techman:

Spock didn't say anything about how silly it was to pet cats. So Spock basically pets both the critters he makes fun of other people for petting and the critters he doesn't say are silly to pet.

Laura Cynthia Chambers said:

Because by doing so he makes contact with her mind and senses there is more to her?

Possibly. Or maybe Spock decided that petting pets was an illogical human action that was harmless and worth indulging in to relax.

wayne66 said:

...One thing I worried about is ISIS when she and Gary Seven are way up in the air sabotaging the rocket. I worry that she was going to fall...

Once a falling creature reaches its terminal velocity it doesn't matter how much farther it falls because it won't get any faster and it won't hit any harder. Cats are noted for being surefooted tree dwelling animals so Isis probably wouldn't fall off the gantry, though a sudden gust of wind might blow her off.

Isis would have a much better chance of surviving a fall off the gantry in cat form than in human form.

https://sciencebasedlife.wordpress.com/2012/04/13/how-do-cats-survive-falls-from-great-heights/
 
Last edited:
Cats and tribbles are Spock's weakness.
Maybe that weird dog in "The Enemy Within" too.
THANK GOODNESS the Klingons didn't know.
 
I don't know what they were planning to call that series.
41360628202_77f34db66d_b.jpg
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top