• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

5 Trek Promotions that should have happened (and Harry's name is NOT on the list)

....Most of the Department heads on the Carrier were Commanders. So that would open the position of Chief Engineer for a promotion to CDR for Gordi as well.

Which makes the reboot movies even more ludicrous, the idea of cadet to Head of department overnight, the only ones qualified to be a Commander was Scotty and perhaps McCoy since he was already a qualified doctor. Ok assuming the Vulcan education system made an Earth Phd = to a Vulcan high school diploma Spock might be qualified as well
 
It's interesting how it's so commonplace to declare that because Janeway didn't promote Harry (or any other ensign save the one she "created"), he was an ensign forever. Realistically speaking, it's unlikely. Starfleet probably just reviewed all the ship's personnel's files, determined evaluations, time in service, the kind of work they did, commendations, reprimands, brig time (if any), and whether they were Voyager, Maquis, or Equinox. And, they doled out assignments and rank pips accordingly.

Most of the better ensigns probably achieved full lieutenant rank. The ones who struggled, or were former Maquis who retained their commissions, maybe had to settle for JG. Harry was probably one of the former. Given that his service was exemplary and he'd done LT-level work from the start, he might have made LCDR if not for the reprimand of his record.

Also, given that Janeway is the only captain who actually reprimands people for interspecies romance, maybe that was ignored as well.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top