• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

11th Doctor Casting announcment tommorow

Lol, just checked out the OG site, and it's the most ridiculous thing I've ever seen. How many different threads do they need to discuss this one topic?

Have you seen the Star Trek XI forum here? :vulcan:

Wait...whoa, whoa, whoa! There's going to be a Star Trek XI???

But Shatner and Nimoy are so old! How will they work around the age issue? :confused:

...

Nothing makes sense anymore. :(
 
Well it's all a little too convenient isn't it. If the Doctor wants to have more regenerations then all he has to do is immediately after regenerating chop his hand off or his penis off and then grow another back and then use that hand or penis next time he dies to regenerate into the same form and literally 'save' a regeneration.

That's bonkers.

I think it was all part of special circumstances. The hand started off as new and got cut off. The hand had small traces of regeneration energy.

It probably wouldn't work now if Doctor 10 chopped off his "fightin hand!" right now. There wouldn't be any residual regeneration energy.

Goodness gracious me.

Check my post again, i've quoted it in this post and highlighted the relevant parts you missed.
 
one thing that does worry me is that when he meets the Sontarans, they might mistake him for a "half form" and treat him as seen in SJA, hell alot of the aliens will have trouble taking him seriously.

Yeah...but last night I watched Matt Smith walk into a police station and hack a detective's head off (and then be amusingly blase about it) Certainly I'll take him seriously :lol:
 
I hate outpost gallifrey.

"He's younger than me!"

So? What does that prove? You're older than someone, here's a fucking medal. Why do people keep saying this as if it's any kind of valid point?

Aghghghg.

And y'know something I'm preemptively pissed about? I know that one day, in 2010, I'll post something less than complementary about some aspect of season 5. It could be an episode, a moment, an actor's decision... but something. And on that day, one of you will accuse me of being a Matt Smith naysayer.

"I remember" they'll say, "you spent that entire week calling him too young and ugly". "You're no fan, why are you even here?".

It's tough having the (well deserved) reputation of being a cunt. Boo hoo, etc.
 
And y'know something I'm preemptively pissed about? I know that one day, in 2010, I'll post something less than complementary about some aspect of season 5. It could be an episode, a moment, an actor's decision... but something. And on that day, one of you will accuse me of being a Matt Smith naysayer.

"I remember" they'll say, "you spent that entire week calling him too young and ugly". "You're no fan, why are you even here?".

I'll keep a note of that ;)

Is OG really that bad? I have an account there but after it was approved I don't think I logged in.

I've been exposed to an LJ group but prefer to use sub forums like this one as the online fan base always seemed really, really irritating. Especially with the "everything new is shit" arguments I saw constantly popping up.
 
I hate outpost gallifrey.

"He's younger than me!"

So? What does that prove? You're older than someone, here's a fucking medal. Why do people keep saying this as if it's any kind of valid point?

Aghghghg.

And y'know something I'm preemptively pissed about? I know that one day, in 2010, I'll post something less than complementary about some aspect of season 5. It could be an episode, a moment, an actor's decision... but something. And on that day, one of you will accuse me of being a Matt Smith naysayer.

"I remember" they'll say, "you spent that entire week calling him too young and ugly". "You're no fan, why are you even here?".

It's tough having the (well deserved) reputation of being a cunt. Boo hoo, etc.

Don't worry, Jim, I'll remember you're not a naysayer, but I'll play along with the crowd just for my amusement when you go off on your rant, because they're always fun...;)
 
Paradoxically, by predicting it, I've probably stopped it from happening. Good ol' Wibblywobblytimeywimey.

*sniff* I miss Emh.

Is OG really that bad? I have an account there but after it was approved I don't think I logged in.

It's great for news and tidbits, etc. But as a discussion community I find it immensely irritating and full of whinging pricks. I lurk a lot, basically.

I've been exposed to an LJ group but prefer to use sub forums like this one as the online fan base always seemed really, really irritating. Especially with the "everything new is shit" arguments I saw constantly popping up.

"everything new is shit" - brilliant, someone at OG should translate that into latin and use it as the site motto. :D
 
Paradoxically, by predicting it, I've probably stopped it from happening. Good ol' Wibblywobblytimeywimey.

*sniff* I miss Emh.

Is OG really that bad? I have an account there but after it was approved I don't think I logged in.

It's great for news and tidbits, etc. But as a discussion community I find it immensely irritating and full of whinging pricks. I lurk a lot, basically.

I've been exposed to an LJ group but prefer to use sub forums like this one as the online fan base always seemed really, really irritating. Especially with the "everything new is shit" arguments I saw constantly popping up.

"everything new is shit" - brilliant, someone at OG should translate that into latin and use it as the site motto. :D


I miss Emh too. :(

I'll second the notion of OG being full of whiny bitches. Its not all bad though. Just stick with the more positive threads that're shorter than 3 pages. In most topics the "cor blimey. The new Doctor/companion/monster sucks!" crowd starts to post around Page 2.

I'm hoping the new Doctor is a success, just so I can go over there and rub the haters noses in it.
 
Last edited:
I wonder what Emh would have to say about the new Doc. No doubt he'd have an insightful and positive take on it.

Is anyone in contact with him?


Also, it was just pointed out to me that Orson Welles was just 26 when he directed and played the title role in Citizen Kane. Think on that.
 
Last edited:
I hate outpost gallifrey.

"He's younger than me!"

So? What does that prove? You're older than someone, here's a fucking medal. Why do people keep saying this as if it's any kind of valid point?

Aghghghg.

And y'know something I'm preemptively pissed about? I know that one day, in 2010, I'll post something less than complementary about some aspect of season 5. It could be an episode, a moment, an actor's decision... but something. And on that day, one of you will accuse me of being a Matt Smith naysayer.

"I remember" they'll say, "you spent that entire week calling him too young and ugly". "You're no fan, why are you even here?".

It's tough having the (well deserved) reputation of being a cunt. Boo hoo, etc.

It's not like there aren't comments like that around here as well. Personally I don't have problems posting there, it just takes some time for the threads to come up for me for some odd reason.
 
I hate outpost gallifrey.

"He's younger than me!"

So? What does that prove? You're older than someone, here's a fucking medal. Why do people keep saying this as if it's any kind of valid point?

The new Doctor is younger than me! Do I get a medal, now? Pretty please?

OG sounds like fun but they didn't want me with my shabby free mail addys... :(
 
Last edited:
It's not like there aren't comments like that around here as well.

True, but in general, this place comes across as more reasonable. And far less whiny.

Or maybe I just have a natural aversion to a forum in which "SQUEEEE!" is a perfectly acceptable, nay, encouraged expression of excitement.
 
It's not like there aren't comments like that around here as well.

True, but in general, this place comes across as more reasonable. And far less whiny.

Or maybe I just have a natural aversion to a forum in which "SQUEEEE!" is a perfectly acceptable, nay, encouraged expression of excitement.

You don't spend much time in the Star Trek XI forum then do you?:lol:
 
:lol:

Fair point... but I was referring to this subforum specifically. Honest.

To be fair to the Trek 11 hater crowd though, at least we (they) actually know a bit about this film, and have a trailer no less. We know next to nothing about Series 5 and Doc 11.
 
:lol:

Fair point... but I was referring to this subforum specifically. Honest.

To be fair to the Trek 11 hater crowd though, at least we (they) actually know a bit about this film, and have a trailer no less. We know next to nothing about Series 5 and Doc 11.

We know the 11th doc is younger than many of us :p

Interesting that the last 2 Doctors have both been younger than me, and at 38 I'm faced with the fact that even if the 12th Doctor reverts to late 30s early 40s he might still be younger than me.

Guess you know you're getting on when Timelords start to look younger...:lol:
 
I've been exposed to an LJ group but prefer to use sub forums like this one as the online fan base always seemed really, really irritating. Especially with the "everything new is shit" arguments I saw constantly popping up.
"everything new is shit" - brilliant, someone at OG should translate that into latin and use it as the site motto. :D

My latin isn't great - my greek is more recent and I've been playing with Hebrew etymologies most recently but try:

" Quicquid novus merda est!"
 
I've been exposed to an LJ group but prefer to use sub forums like this one as the online fan base always seemed really, really irritating. Especially with the "everything new is shit" arguments I saw constantly popping up.
"everything new is shit" - brilliant, someone at OG should translate that into latin and use it as the site motto. :D

"Panton novus merda est"

Probably grammatically awful, it's an e-translator's attempt. Hopefully one of our more scholary posters can do better.

ETA: Already trumped! We now return you to the regularly scheduled thread.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top