Well, if their goal was recreating the Daily Show than they were doomed to fail either way.
I think it's just pissed off Daily Show fans trying to find a reason other then the ratings have dropped very low and it takes up a lot of slots running 5 nights a week in prime time.
It was on primetime (a mistake, I reckon - it should always have been on after 11, as I never got to see it while I was commuting) on More4, not Channel 4.
Those slots are now filled with more property porn, which is pretty much all More4 runs now, aside from cookery shows and one prestige documentary a week. Total waste of a Freeview slot - makes ITV2 look cerebral.