• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Starship design history in light of Discovery

a clearer render of Baron Grimes' ship. Saw it on Facebook, apparently comes from one of the Eaglemoss booklets.

ySiyIlC.png
'bout freaking time.
 
This was decided early on as a way to represent a "new type of warp drive" from TOS, before the decided only Disco was going to get the spore drive.

This is Eaves ‘head canon’, not something he got from Fuller or the writers.
It was his own personal rationalization for the nacelle differences.
 
a clearer render of Baron Grimes' ship. Saw it on Facebook, apparently comes from one of the Eaglemoss booklets.

ySiyIlC.png
So yeah, I got the EM Qoj Klingon Starship model today and this pic is included now, in the "Coming Soon" section at the back of the booklet.
I'm heading off to work for the evening in a bit, so I'll post pics tomorrow sometime.
:techman:
 
Like the primary hull and its 'bow' shape but those engineering hulls/ nacelles are hideous, imo. Why so huge and bulky?

Should have drawn from more modern catamaran design, I think.

http://www.dubrovnik-travelcorner.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/krilo-Eclipse.jpg

I think they're supposed to look huge and bulky, to be tacky. Big ass nacelles could be the rich space-guy equivalent of gold rims or a lift kit. I think they look ugly too, but that's actually why I feel like they totally work for the design overall.
 
STO is doing a Excelsior inspired redesign of what I assume is the Walker Class (It's called the USS Georgiou), this is the only image released so far. I'd expect more tomorrow, if not than next week.

FAXl4CZ.png
They're also doing 25th Century redesigns of the Magee and Shepard, but in their style which is fine but not amazing.
geyiqD8.png

vyi99zp.png
 
The winglets and stubby projections work on 22nd century Earth Starfleet vessels but not so much on Federation ships from the 24th century and beyond. The fewer "fins" that Starfleet vessels have the better for the most part.
 
I fundamentally disagree with John Eaves' understanding of Starfleet vessels. They are ocean-going ships, from the age of sail and steam. They are not something Chuck Yeager would fly.

Doesn't make him a bad designer, but it does make him a designer who produces work that annoys me.
 
I like Doug Drexler's designs more than I do Eaves' but enjoy both.
i like a lot of what eaves did for discovery, at least a lot of what he did has grown on me over the past year. but i can't help but wish they got somebody new to do something completely fresh. discovery deviates so much from what we expected ships to look like in this era, they might as well have gone further outside the box.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top