• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

TNG Rewatch: 4x15 "First Contact"

Trekker4747

Boldly going...
Premium Member
FirstContact.jpg


As the episode opens Riker is rushed into an emergency treatment room in an alien hospital, as the alien doctors begin working on Riker they point out various oddities in his physiology (the look of his hands, placement of his heart, number of ribs he has) standing back in awe wondering what he is. As Riker comes to and talks to his doctors he covers up his physical oddities as being birth defects and requests to leave to seek out his "own doctor" but is told his injuries are too great and he must recover.

Meanwhile, an alien scientist is talking with her leaders about an upcoming test of their first warp-vessel, a remarkable achievement in what seems to be a very traditionalist society until fairly recently under their more forward-looking leader. Though she is met with some resistance by another leader, a security minister, who prefers they stick with their more traditional values.

That evening the scientist is greeted by Picard and Troi as they beam down to make "first contact" with an alien world, they offer to bring the scientist aboard ship to show her they are telling the truth. After the visit the scientist introduces Picard to the planet's chancellor who is also welcomed onto the ship and shares a drink of Picard Wine in the Ready Room as Picard and the alien leader discuss what the Federation is and the role they'll play (if any) in the alien culture's development as they embark into space.

Meanwhile on the planet, Riker puts into action an escape plan from the hospital but is ambushed by hospital staff and has his injuries amplified to the point of putting him critical condition. All of this goes on with the knowledge of the security advisor who revives Riker for questioning, putting Riker's health at risk. The advisor attempts to martyr himself by staging an attack by Riker using a phaser. (Not knowing the weapon is set to a non-lethal setting.)

Once learning of Riker's (and other Starfleet observers) presence on the planet the chancellor is initially angry but still sees the reason in it, and trusts Picard, allowing Riker to be released into the care of Doctor Crusher.

Riker and the alien advisor survive their injuries but the actions of the advisor convince the chancellor that his people are not ready to accept the existence of an interstellar community and declines any further contact with The Federation and delays the warp program. The alien scientist asks to be allowed to stay on the Enterprise which Picard allows offering a friendly parting to the alien chancellor as the the ship leaves orbit.

Another episode that is one of my favorites and also one with a pretty strong focus on non-Enterprise characters as, really, the only members of the main cast that get any meaningful moments are Riker and Picard (Data, Worf, Troi and Crusher are all pretty secondary) and their experiences with the aliens (Riker with those in the hospital, Picard with the alien leader(s).)

As it's not likely there's very many cases of a Federation ship encountering a planet right on the cusp of warp travel it's an interesting look at how such a situation is handled and down the road interesting to contrast it with what we eventually learn about Earth's first contact with Vulcan through the movie First Contact and in "Enterprise."

In some way its understandable why the alien leader would be so unnerved by learning that the Federation had observers in disguise on the planet. We already know that the Federation observes pre-warp cultures using hidden duck blinds and we learn "cloaked" people are used in "Insurrection" but here we see that the Federation takes on a slightly more sinister role in gathering information by having specialists disguised as natives on the planet. While they're certainly not brain-washing or trying to indoctrinate the citizens and are purely being observational it certainly can come across as compelling.

A couple times in the episode the native characters say their society believes themselves to be "the center of the universe", it's probably very unlikely they think this to be literally true if they've been doing any astronomical studying whatsoever, but it's still an oddity if they've had any kind of meaningful space observation where they've likely observed stars in the sky similar to their own and, hell, even if they have telescopes and such equivalent of what we have today on Earth they could observe stars likely harboring planets that contain life.

Also interesting to note the social level the aliens in the episode are at when they are on the verge of warp travel and compare that to where humanity was when breaking the light-barrier.

This is a good episode that's always enjoyable to watch, particularly nice is the interaction between Picard and the alien leader as well as the conflict between the more idealistic alien leader and the traditionalist alien security minister.

GOOD MOMENTS:
Bebe Neuwirth (Lilith Crane on Cheers) as an alien doctor/nurse who offers to help Riker escape in exchange for his, ahem, "services."
Riker trying to talk his way out of this situation.

Picard shares the bottle of wine he got from Robert at the beginning of the season with the alien chancellor. (I don't think that's what Robert meant, Picard!)

INTERESTING NOTES:
The very 20th century look of the alien hospital including regular doors with even the sheet-metal push guards and strike panels.

The alien scientist showing a degree of embarrassment over The Federation learning of her people by watching their tv programs and listening to their popular music.

ODDITIES:
Riker says he'd be in better care under his own doctor, but when asked who that is he uses Crusher's own name. An odd thing to go considering Crusher doesn't seem to have a name that matches that of the natives and he had to know they'd look up such a person and wouldn't find her.

The chancellor's receptionist seems pretty uninterested over the intercom over having seen AN ALIEN come up to be buzzed into the office.

The alien nurse's suggested exit route to Riker apparently took him past a nurses' station.

GOOD LINES:
"I'll call you the next time I pass through your star-system." - Riker, after being asked by his alien lover if she'll ever see him again.
 
I like this episode.

But it troubles me that the Federation is placing individuals in undercover operations and trying to dictate the terms of first contact with a newly capable warp civilization. The blunders there caused damage to the groups who wanted to explore the stars and likely set the Malcorian space program back decades or centuries.

It continues a disturbing trend in the Modern series that humans know best and are in space to spread their wisdom on the uneducated. They began to feel more like missionaries and less like explorers.
 
This is one of my top 5 first contact episodes from any SF series. While this episode can't actually be reconciled with procedures we've generally seen in other Trek episodes before it, at least it tried to make some sense of the whole situation.

Good moment: Loved the look at another civilization's first light speed craft from the video monitors.
 
I like this episode.

But it troubles me that the Federation is placing individuals in undercover operations and trying to dictate the terms of first contact with a newly capable warp civilization. The blunders there caused damage to the groups who wanted to explore the stars and likely set the Malcorian space program back decades or centuries.

It continues a disturbing trend in the Modern series that humans know best and are in space to spread their wisdom on the uneducated. They began to feel more like missionaries and less like explorers.
That's why I appreciate the final choice made by the chancellor, it's a good "IN YOUR FACE THE FEDERATION". I dislike the 24th century's interpretation of the Prime Directive and this First contact procedure isn't better.
 
Yeah, going to the world itself for first contact seems like a terrible idea for this very reason, especially skulking around disguised as them, infiltrating their society. You can learn a great deal about them by monitoring their communications networks, & then when they do launch into space with the plan to engage in light speed travel, you show up in the vicinity to properly introduce yourself. After all. I'd imagine most beings would prepare for the notion that they'd encounter life in space when they embark into it. We sure thought along those lines when we did



Seems like that prime directive wouldn't want you anywhere near that world at all, if they have no clue at all what's out there yet. Same goes for the Mintakans. Haven't these gits ever heard of the Observer Effect? That they are willing to go to these lengths to invest themselves into underdeveloped cultures & yet can't lawfully intervene in the Boralan situation is the most woefully contradictory thing about TNG.
 
We know there's ways they can do it but it's odd to me it's never mentioned in the episode on how the Enterprise was in orbit around this planet undetected. Consider that on our own planet people are watching and monitoring the skies all of the time and there are active organizations out there believing in, and looking for, intelligent life. (And obviously people on the planet here had considered the notion of extraterrestrial life since they had a warp-program, fantasies about sleeping with aliens and even don't seem to greatly surprised when actual aliens show up.)

It's possible to look up in our night sky at times and see the ISS with the naked eye and it's obviously vastly smaller than the Enterprise. So wouldn't the Enterprise be visible as a moving object in the sky? Wouldn't it be detectable by planet-based systems monitoring the sky or by space-based satellites used for monitoring planet-based activities?

Again, we "know" there's ways to hide from sensors and such as it's come up from time-to-time it's just odd no mention of it was made here.


On the Prime Directive front:

We could probably consider how the Vulcans dealt with humans. We know that they had, on occasion, monitored Earthlings/humans from time-to-time pre-Warp and that the launch of our first warp-capable ship caused them to come visit us and bring us into the interstellar community so what we see Starfleet doing here seems consistent with that. It's just that things seem to have gotten muddied up here by the situation with losing Riker. Otherwise it's "possible" that they may have waited until the warp-ship was launched and returned home before introducing themselves.

And while it's odd and a bit "uncomfortable" they had ground personnel we should know "well enough" that these "specialists" were there in a passive, observation-only, capacity and not trying to influence the population or directions the planet was taking socially and technologically.
 
And while it's odd and a bit "uncomfortable" they had ground personnel we should know "well enough" that these "specialists" were there in a passive, observation-only, capacity and not trying to influence the population or directions the planet was taking socially and technologically.

It really doesn't matter to me. The Federation is still invading someone else territory in the name of exploration.
 
Theres no reason you couldnt study planets if you dont reveal yourself. The difference is in TOS they were much more loose about this. First Contact woukd be the right way to do it..minus Riker being hurt.
 
I usually skip this episode. It's mostly good, but the Riker parts seem repetitive and they drag the episode down for me. I much prefer the scenes with Picard with Mirasta and the Prime Minister. The paranoid Krola was good too.

But everytime it switched back to Riker, yawwwwwwn. I know a story like this needs something else to add tension, but it wasn't my cup of tea.
 
Basically, Riker can't leave the ship on his own without it making a mess, First Contact, Frame of Mind, The Game :lol:
 
I'm not really a fan of episodes that have main cast members in alien makeup as a disguise for long periods... although Who Watches the Watchers was really good despite that. It just takes me out of the episode, not really a fan of that concept.

My favorite part of this one is Picard's line about his mistakes "I've made some fine ones in my time"
 
A Matter of Perspective, and The Outcast too. I swear, leave that guy alone somewhere for 5 minutes and you got a recipe for catastrophe... Unless he's on a Klingon ship. Then he fits in just fine :rommie:
 
I'm not really a fan of episodes that have main cast members in alien makeup as a disguise for long periods... although Who Watches the Watchers was really good despite that. It just takes me out of the episode, not really a fan of that concept
You know, it's that way with me too. The Face Of The Enemy might just be the very best Trio centric episode, but I'm not that into it, because she just looks ridiculous
 
A Matter of Perspective, and The Outcast too. I swear, leave that guy alone somewhere for 5 minutes and you got a recipe for catastrophe... Unless he's on a Klingon ship. Then he fits in just fine :rommie:
:rommie: He can save the situation on a Klingon ship full of Klingons, but he can't save the Enterprise from two Klingon ships full of Ferengis.
 
A couple times in the episode the native characters say their society believes themselves to be "the center of the universe", it's probably very unlikely they think this to be literally true if they've been doing any astronomical studying whatsoever, but it's still an oddity if they've had any kind of meaningful space observation where they've likely observed stars in the sky similar to their own and, hell, even if they have telescopes and such equivalent of what we have today on Earth they could observe stars likely harboring planets that contain life.
It was surely on a philosophical/spiritual angle. Krola talked about his traditionnal way of life. I suppose it implied a religious conception of the world. Or perhaps it's a metaphor about humans in general who act like they were the center of the universe.
 
It really struck me as a forward-thinking liberal/science political movement vs. a conservative/traditionalist type movement. Not to too much connect it to present-day politics butits what I got out of it. You have the scientists and idealists advancing, wanting to move forward and then you have those holding on to a mythology, wanting things to stay the way they are and thinking things are moving to fast.

Can sort of relate it to some present-day political movements and societal beliefs.

I really do how much of the planet's TV programs and popular music Riker watched, or was watched on the ship. I have this funny image in my head of Riker getting hooked on the planet's equivalent of Cougar Town or Real Housewives.
 
Overall well done episode (issues mentioned in this thread notwithstanding), though it did bug me that they weren't able to find Riker by scanning for is distinct (human) lifesigns from the ship, as has been done countless times in other episodes.

It would've been fun to have seen where the chancellor ended-up in a future episode.

Also - how many children has Riker fathered throughout the galaxy at this point... I'm picturing long lines of young half-human/half-something-else Starfleet hopefuls applying to the Academy, wondering wistfully if they'll ever get to meet their father.
 
What others said, but I adored how Picard admitting he made a mistake.

Mirasta telling Picard "I hate to think how you would judge us based on our popular music and entertainment" may or may not be a 4th wall-breaker, but it's a fantastic line no matter what. I doubt it's a joke referencing REM's "Shiny Happy People"... Excuse me for 15 minutes while I go play Grand Theft Auto...

... *cough* Okay, I'm back. I shouldn't have installed patches, now that coffee add-in won't work.

Anyway, Carolyn Seymour returning and not as a Romulan, though she's brill every time she plays a Romulan! TNG really missed out on an opportunity by not doing a followup episode with her. Mirasta Yale is a fantastic character - of the same sort as your human nonconformist who gets to get whisked away by cool aliens or humans from the future. Only Yale isn't human. Like alien abduction except the alien is being abducted, by choice.

Easily one of season 4's better episodes and continues an impressive overall run of TNG episodes.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top