• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The OFFICIAL STNG-R general discussion thread!

Status
Not open for further replies.
With TNG's 25th anniversary being next year, does anyone think it's likely or even conceivable that season one might be released on Blu-ray next year?
Call me an optimist or a fool if you will, but I'm banking on us being at least half-way through TNG by the end of 2012. If we're not up to season 3, I'll be vey disappointed.
 
With TNG's 25th anniversary being next year, does anyone think it's likely or even conceivable that season one might be released on Blu-ray next year?
Call me an optimist or a fool if you will, but I'm banking on us being at least half-way through TNG by the end of 2012. If we're not up to season 3, I'll be vey disappointed.


You're going to be very dissapointed. But to Admiral Bear's question, they've already said Season 1 would be out next year.

I imagine it very likely the seasons will start to come out like this:

Season 1; Fall 2012

Season 2; May 2013 (Star Trek XII is released)

Season 3; Fall 2013 (Trek XII Home video release)
 
Depends on the speed of the film, but as ISO 100 35mm film is generally reckoned to be roughly equivalent to a 24 megapixel digital image so 4k sounds about right (4000 * 4000 * 1.33 = 21.3 megapixels).

People often overestimate the amount of info in film. Here's a comparison of a medium format negative vs a 12mpx DSLR. The digital file seems to come out on top in nearly every aspect. You could get 4k from 35mm, but you'd be blowing up a lot of grain.

http://www.luminous-landscape.com/reviews/shootout.shtml

Hey, those pictures were taken just down the street from my place in Toronto! :cool:
 
I imagine it very likely the seasons will start to come out like this:

Season 1; Fall 2012
Season 2; May 2013 (Star Trek XII is released)
Season 3; Fall 2013 (Trek XII Home video release)

Yes, I'm expecting a season to be released every 6 months starting Q3 next year, so season 7 won't come out until 2016. If they want the sets to retail at $100+ for as long as possible, they can't afford to saturate the market with them.
 
Last edited:
I imagine it very likely the seasons will start to come out like this:

Season 1; Fall 2012
Season 2; May 2013 (Star Trek XII is released)
Season 3; Fall 2013 (Trek XII Home video release)

Yes, I'm expecting a season to be released every 6 months starting Q3 next year, so season 7 won't come out until 2016. If they want the sets to retail at $100+ for as long as possible, they can't afford to saturate the market with them.

With the amount of trawling throught the archives for the master footage, trying to find missing reels (it's inconceivable there won't be anymore over what we already know about), and then all the work needed to put the HD episodes together ie HD visuals, new CGI planets, HD transport/phaser effects etc etc, I think a season every 6 months is very optimistic.

I know the DVDs came out one season every 6 months, but they didn't need anywhere near the same level of work.
 
Well I expect there will be a lot of stock shots and planets that they can reuse, and with practice they'll probably also get better at reconstructing the episodes. If initial sales bode well, they might also commit more resources to the effort knowing that the seasons after the first two will undoubtedly sell in larger volumes. But yes, 6 months is probably on the optimistic side.
 
You never know, we might get the 7th season of TNG just in time for the 30th anniversary. :lol:

Bloody hell, will Blu-ray still be around in 6 years time?
 
If they're smart they'll scan the negatives at the highest res possible so they don't have to go through this exercise again.
 
If they're smart they'll scan the negatives at the highest res possible so they don't have to go through this exercise again.

That's what I'm hopping for aswell. I'm convinced CBS is following a long term strategy with this project so it would be perfectly reasonable to assume this is what they are doing. Then again, once they have the finished product edited on film, it wouldn't be too difficult to rescan at a higher resolution?
 
Then again, once they have the finished product edited on film, it wouldn't be too difficult to rescan at a higher resolution?
There's no way that they'll have a finished product edited on film. Maybe if it was just slugging all the pieces together, but they also have all the comps/effects to include.

No, they're almost certainly just scanning the film & doing all the edits on a computer (as a digital intermediate). Hopefully at 4K, but I wouldn't be surprised if it's just 2K/1080p.
 
Bloody hell, will Blu-ray still be around in 6 years time?

Probably, but CBS isn't spending money on this project for home video -- the real money to be made here is in syndication, and HD will probably remain the television standard for a while.
 
Then again, once they have the finished product edited on film, it wouldn't be too difficult to rescan at a higher resolution?
There's no way that they'll have a finished product edited on film. Maybe if it was just slugging all the pieces together, but they also have all the comps/effects to include.

No, they're almost certainly just scanning the film & doing all the edits on a computer (as a digital intermediate). Hopefully at 4K, but I wouldn't be surprised if it's just 2K/1080p.

You don't think they'd scan everything in at 4K, archive it, and then resize it for the editing?
 
all the work needed to put the HD episodes together ie HD visuals, new CGI planets, HD transport/phaser effects etc etc

Has it been officially confirmed that effects, planets, etc. will be redone with CGI? Everyone here seems to take this for granted, but what if the effects are just being upscaled?
 
all the work needed to put the HD episodes together ie HD visuals, new CGI planets, HD transport/phaser effects etc etc

Has it been officially confirmed that effects, planets, etc. will be redone with CGI? Everyone here seems to take this for granted, but what if the effects are just being upscaled?

In the trailer, there's at least one effect (Qo'nos) that has been re-done in CGI. Anyway, considering the money being spent on this project, I'd highly doubt any upscaling being done when they didn't have to.
 
Has it been officially confirmed that effects, planets, etc. will be redone with CGI? Everyone here seems to take this for granted, but what if the effects are just being upscaled?
A vivid HD Enterprise orbiting a very badly rendered SD planet would make for a bit of a jarring viewing experience.
 
In the trailer, there's at least one effect (Qo'nos) that has been re-done in CGI.
Has it, though? To me it looks like they worked with the original matte painting and just added some minor CGI tweaks here and there.
 
In the trailer, there's at least one effect (Qo'nos) that has been re-done in CGI.
Has it, though? To me it looks like they worked with the original matte painting and just added some minor CGI tweaks here and there.

He is talking about the space shot of Qo'nos not the city on the planet. Watch the trailer and see for yourself or go back a few pages in this thread to see the comparison. Its definitely a new render.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top