A scene I'd love to see
- Thread starter EJA
- Start date
Richard E. Grant was the "ninth" Doctor in Curse Of Fatal Death, though I'm not sure what EJA is thinking about idea-wise.
Surely REG was the 'official' (until the new series was announced) Ninth Doctor in Scream of the Shalka and the tenth or eleventh Doctor in Curse of Fatal Death?
^ I meant as far as Grant/9th Doctor watching them inside a sphere.
Was that a story point from somewhere?
REG was #9 in COFD as well with Rowan Atkinson being #8, Jim Broadbent as #10, Hugh Grant as #11 and Joanna Lumley as #12. All within about 2 minutes, so you gotta pay close attention
Was that a story point from somewhere?
REG was #9 in COFD as well with Rowan Atkinson being #8, Jim Broadbent as #10, Hugh Grant as #11 and Joanna Lumley as #12. All within about 2 minutes, so you gotta pay close attention
no, Rowan was 9, REG was 10, Jim 11 and Hugh 12. Joanna was 13.
do pay attention, 007.
do pay attention, 007.
I heard the voice and everything... 
Do you wionder why people keep saying "Scream of the Shalka"?
Some sort of tick?
Ricard was Nine, and Dereck Jacobi was the Master in a cartoon made before the revamp in 2005.
The sphere is either a st elsewhere reference or god forbid Laberynth, but more likely something even more esoteric I have never heard of?
he was talking about Curse of the Fatal Death. REG was in that and was the tenth Doctor. and he got the numbers wrong.
do pay attention, 001
do pay attention, 001
How do you know he wasn't talking about Scream of the Shalka?
You seem positive about this as to correct me while I am correcting you like some sort of correcting train.
Illuminate me.
You seem positive about this as to correct me while I am correcting you like some sort of correcting train.
Illuminate me.
I was definitely talking about Fatal Death, but I got the years mixed up. I wasn't taking the TV movie into account.
Though Rowan looked & dressed similar to McGann, he would have been #9 in the COFD "reality".
And maybe captcalhoun will quote a different movie now
Though Rowan looked & dressed similar to McGann, he would have been #9 in the COFD "reality".
And maybe captcalhoun will quote a different movie now
But you're not EJA.
REG was the 10th Doctor in COTFD and he was the 9th in SOTS.
EJA said Ninth Doctor.
REG wasn't the 9th Doctor in COTFD but he was the 9th Doctor in SOTS.
Defy the logic please.
For you two to be right, EJA would have had to have started his original post balanced on a fundamental fuck up which, honestly we've all been known to do once or twice.
REG was the 10th Doctor in COTFD and he was the 9th in SOTS.
EJA said Ninth Doctor.
REG wasn't the 9th Doctor in COTFD but he was the 9th Doctor in SOTS.
Defy the logic please.
For you two to be right, EJA would have had to have started his original post balanced on a fundamental fuck up which, honestly we've all been known to do once or twice.
Didn't Lance Parkin establish in one of the last Eigth Doctor books that due to some weird timey wimey thing, the Richard E. Grant and Rowan Atkinson Doctors were still 'canon' along with Eccleston?
After all in Doctor Who there have been a few alternate universes here and there-Pete's world from the new series, the alternate Turn Left reality, The Inferno world, and virtual worlds like the Gallifreyan matrix and The Land of Fiction. It's possible each of these have their own time lords or Doctor (and it's possible that each has it's own time war/end of Gallifrey as well). Hey, it works for comic books to explain many of their continuity problems, why not Doctor Who?
After all in Doctor Who there have been a few alternate universes here and there-Pete's world from the new series, the alternate Turn Left reality, The Inferno world, and virtual worlds like the Gallifreyan matrix and The Land of Fiction. It's possible each of these have their own time lords or Doctor (and it's possible that each has it's own time war/end of Gallifrey as well). Hey, it works for comic books to explain many of their continuity problems, why not Doctor Who?
because he said:
REG was #9 in COFD as well with Rowan Atkinson being #8, Jim Broadbent as #10, Hugh Grant as #11 and Joanna Lumley as #12. All within about 2 minutes, so you gotta pay close attention
emphasis mine.
and then he admits it:
irrelevant. Ar said REG was the ninth in COTFD, he wasn't. i wasn't talking about SOTS, i was talking about and correcting his misremembering of the Doctors of COTFD.
it's quite simple, it's not warp physics, you know...
I'd love it if at the end of one episode, after the Doctor, Amy and Rory have just had another one of their mad adventures, the camera pulls back to reveal Richard E. Grant's Ninth Doctor watching them inside a transparent sphere, chuckling to himself.
EJA said ninth first in the op.
I can see how he could be talking about either the entire untold time line of Richard E Grant stories as the ninth Doctor where he did amazing things, amazing "amazing" things in flash animation, but I could also see how for the supposed 30 seconds of life REG's 10th Doctor had in COTFD that when no one was looking he fell through a magic door had a bollocks load or adventures laughed at matt smith and then returned to Turserus to be slightly murdered a few more times just like how we saw that adventure in the first place
Until EJA verifies, it's Shrodingers cat territory, and ruling indefatigably in his absence that one likelihood is impossible might be seen as just a little crass by some people.
You see what I did there again?
I agreed with you, and said you were wrong, at the same time.
So even if you are right, I am still right.
But if you are wrong, I am still right.
There's never no need to go all in.
Where the hell is EJA?
what's EJA's post got to do with me correcting Ar-Pharazon's misremembering of the numbers of the Doctors in COTFD?
chuff all.
chuff all.
