• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Romulan drill in San Francisco Bay

Just a drill that blocks sensors and subspace communications. Yeah, they might want to take a peek at it.
 
I find it hard to believe that this drill from a simple mining ship is capable of:

• Disrupting long range sensors
• Jamming communications
• Rendering transporters useless

Just think about that for a moment. They have this simple tool that is the capable of rendering a lot of key space traveling components useless. Why would Nero ever turn the darn thing off? Is he afraid he might hit someone with the beam while traveling through space? The film NEVER establishes that the drill consumes enough power to hinder standard operations, so why doesn't he just keep the drill on?

And need I point out that this device is less of a drill and more like a glorified phaser array? Those things that shoot constant beams of energy that cuts into solid objects and has even been used on planet environments like land? Calling this thing a drill is like me calling a gatling gun a lawnmower even though all I do is shoot at the grass.

And why cut in the middle of the water? The moment you turn that drill off, all that water is going to flood down into the hole and refill it with dirt.

Freaking context sensitive plot devices. And to think everyone praised this film for not using technobabble to pull things out of their @($ in order to save the day.

I for one am glad they didn't talk about the power levels of the drill and how they couldn't use it constantly :guffaw:
 
Just a drill that blocks sensors and subspace communications. Yeah, they might want to take a peek at it.

My guess is just that the drill is so energy intensive, a lot of 'waste' energy used in generating he beam causes interference to such systems. The amount of times we've seen sensors or transporters being interfered with by high energy fields in the various TV series and movies, it doesn't surprise me that such a device would cause something similar.
 
That's a lot of waste energy if it blocks the people on the planet from even knowing there's a ship there. The distress call simply mentions seismic disturbances.
 
yeah, if you had enough Kelbonite to block sensors so that you couldn't tell there was a miles long ship in orbit. I guess a shell of the stuff between you and low orbit would work. :rommie:
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top