• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sarek

tomalak301

Fleet Admiral
Premium Member
I don't watch TNG as much as I probably should anymore, but whenever it's on say BBC America or WGN, I will stick on that episode and watch it. It happened a few weeks ago with The Offspring, and it happened tonight when I caught the final 10 minutes of This Amazing Episode.

When I tuned it, they were just about to get to one of TNG's most remarkable scenes in the entire series (Picard having to experience Sarek's Anguish) and I just couldn't turn away. This scene almost gives me chills every time, probably now more than ever because I had actually just seen Journey to Babel a few nights ago. Just seeing Sir Patrick Stewart eat up the scenery in that scene alone was as close to epic as you can get. In that mental breakdown, it's almost as if you can feel that same anguish, that same guilt, and it's just one of my favorite moments in the entire Franchise.

TNG often get's criticized as not being respectful to the original and I think the mentality of that is they should bow down to the cast. I mean look at some of the complaints against Relics. Scotty was mistreated, Geordi should have gone out of his way to treat Scotty as royalty, especially in Engineering. Then you had DS9's Trials and Tribble-Ations and my one big complaint against that episode, it was still awesome, was DS9 went out of it's way to bow down to the original series. I see an episode like Sarek, and I think this is more of the crossovers I really wanted to see. Perhaps it's because I came to like Star Trek after TNG and DS9, but this series didn't bow down to the original. They took one of the popular characters, gave him a mental illness, and it was handled in one of the most delicate and respectful ways you could handle it. Also, when the Captain gives up himself to save this man's dignity, I just think how much more respectful can you be.

I know I'm rambling just on the final ten minutes, but this is really why I love TNG. It dealt with things not using action like Voyager or Enterprise, but letting the characters/actors do their thing and just step back. I'm not sure If I would put "Sarek" in my top 10, but it comes really really close. Just another amazing episode to go with an amazing season like Season 3.
 
Just finished watching this for the first time in years, and completely agree. I think part of the reason the crossover in this episode feels so much more natural than something like Relics is that it (AFAIK) wasn't originally planned as a TOS tribute episode, but instead as an Alzheimer's/aging episode, that eventually evolved into using Sarek to lend more emotional resonance and a sci-fi grounding.

The final 10 minutes are stunning, as is the concert scene in the first third of the episode. Both Stewart and Mark Lenard give some of the best performances of the series.
 
Perhaps the most amazing guest appearance in the entire Trek catalog. Lenard & Stewart were doing acting like the show has never seen
 
I can't agree more. I've always loved this episode. Having a recurring character like Sarek be the one who is afflicted with Bendai Syndrome was a powerful move, and made the episode into a classic. It really made the point that horrific diseases like Alzheimer's happen to real people. Good job, TNG.
 
I can't agree more. I've always loved this episode. Having a recurring character like Sarek be the one who is afflicted with Bendai Syndrome was a powerful move, and made the episode into a classic. It really made the point that horrific diseases like Alzheimer's happen to real people. Good job, TNG.

Agreed. I had a friend who, until this ep, still thought De Kelley was a better actor than Patrick Stewart and still regarded TNG as an imposter. When she saw this one, it changed her mind that (a) Stewart was the better actor, and (b) TNG was a worthy successor to TOS.
 
Coincidentally I watched this last night. I agree. Great episode. Mark Lenard is a great actor.
 
Their followup in Unification with Sarek's death, after seeing how far he had deteriorated was sabsolutely spectacular. Even for those who found the over-all episode disapointing, you have to admit, Sarek's part of Unification was great.
 
I just caught this one the other night as well. I remembered it being very good. I hadn't remembered it quite possibly being in the top 5 of all Star Trek episodes. Very powerful, strong message, and brilliantly acted. It really doesn't get any better than that.
 
Their followup in Unification with Sarek's death, after seeing how far he had deteriorated was sabsolutely spectacular. Even for those who found the over-all episode disapointing, you have to admit, Sarek's part of Unification was great.

I thought how they handled Sarek overall in TNG, and Picard's attachment to him, was some of the best stuff the series did. I like Unification for a number of reasons, but the first was really the attachment Picard had with Sarek, and then the end with the Mind Meld with Spock. I felt that whole character arc came full circle in those scenes, not just integrated in TNG, but also from Journey to Babel and the movies.
 
I like it and I don't like it. What takes away major points for me is the throwaway line about Spock getting married. Sure, it could have been another "son of Sarek" , but it's highly doubtful. It just seems kind of disrespectul to alter the destiny of a major character in such a casual way.

I also didn't like Sarek's new wife. She pales in comparison to Amanda.
 
I liked Perrin, but Amanda's roles in Journey to Babel and TVH were different.

One was a proud wife of an aging legend, the other was Spock's mom, hard to compare the two.
 
Then you had DS9's Trials and Tribble-Ations and my one big complaint against that episode, it was still awesome, was DS9 went out of it's way to bow down to the original series.

It was written specifically as a tribute to TOS, on Trek's 30th anniversary, I'm not seeing the problem there.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top