>>I've watched the film now and read your summary. The film itself is ok. It's a bit jarring seeing another actor trying to play David Tennant playing the Doctor, but the actor doing it has at least some skill as an actor, which goes a long way. If it had simply been some random guy trying to imitate Tennant, it would have been quite irritating.<<
Having watched a full season of Matt Smith's Doctor, I see that the professional TV folks are working hard to give Smith his own particular personality. I have to admit it's taking me much longer than usual to warm up to the new Doctor. Still, the stories have usually been imaginative and indeed pretty quickly paced. So far, so good.
>>As for your summary Randy, really my only question concerns the following paragraph:
On the other hand, some things are different in the universe constructed by Eldon Letkeman and Robert Westendorp than the continuity as first established by Russell T. Davies and continued by new head exec Steven Moffatt. (Don’t worry, it’s not much.)
What's the point of mentioning this if you don't elaborate on it? Whether abstractly or down to the nitty-gritty -- like noticing a superficial touch like mimicking Tennant's front cowlick -- that paragraph strikes me as rather pointless if you don't cite at least one thing to back your claim up.<<
But I do elaborate on it several paragraphs into the review:
>>With both the Doctor and Thoms alive and aware of the secret reason behind Victimsight, Smith reveals herself to be the Rani, one of the Doctor’s biggest enemies. (Yes, all the other Time Lords and Ladies are supposed to be dead as a result of the war between Gallifrey and the Daleks, but if the Master can figure a way out, then so could she.)<<
>>Other than that, thanks for posting this ... I probably wouldn't have known about this fan film otherwise, and it was overall an enjoyable viewing.<<
Glad you liked it. For the foreseeable future, I'm going to review at least one non-Trek fan effort per month. I've seen a Doctor Who fan episode that takes place right here (gulp) in the burbs of Baltimore, Maryland, and that group wants to be to Doctor Who what Phase II is to Star Trek. And I hear the first Firefly fan film with be out in the next month or so.
If anyone's got a favorite Trek or non-Trek fan film, let me know about it and send me a link. I'm at a bit of a disadvantage with other series since I know Trek so deeply. I saw something of a Lord of the Rings fan film, but I didn't know who was chasing who and why.
And I do try to review full stories if at all possible. If I'd posted a review so far on what I've seen of Exeter, I'd be hovering over the ending for years!
Randy