• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Small Things You Want Answered

2. Why was there a polar bear on the island and what does it have to do with Walt?
DHARMA brought the polar bears for research.
That's how the polar bears got there, not why they were brought there. It's particularly perplexing since the Hydra station was only shown to have two cages, too. What exactly did they need with two polar bears in a jungle environment? And why just two polar bears?
 
Clearly, they had a third at one point, because it ended up in the Tunisian desert. It's likely they sent a bear through time at one point.

Unfortunately, the internal logic of the Dharma Initiative doesn't seem likely to ever be explained in entirety. There are certain aspects where they seem to take a more complicated (but dramatic) method over a simpler one.
 
^I always just assumed The Others took them to get DNA samples,
Me too. But I don't think most of the audience would get the connection between the luggage tags and the hair in the brushes having DNA, so that it's easy to match up the samples with the owners and no one's the wiser. So they should explain it. Even having the brushes discovered in a lab, in containers labeled with everyone's names would be enough.
What the hell was with the vaccines that Desmond and Kelvin were taking religiously?
Might have been a cover story, but I've wondered whether it was a mis-interpretation of the "disease" that Danielle was worried about - if they thought that the disease was communicable instead of caused by being resurrected as a Smokey-controlled demon (or whatever), then maybe the vaccines and the suits were a precaution against it?

As for the polar bears, isn't there something about the island that raises animal intelligence (though it sometimes has the opposite effect on humans :D) and Dharma wanted to see how smart the polar bears would get?

As for "why polar bears," well, why not? If you're going to test various species to see how the island affects them, gotta start somewhere.

But Tunisia reminds me - why does the island teleportation link go to Tunisia of all places? Is it "natural" or was it engineered that way for some reason? Is that how all the ancient Egyptian stuff got to the island (someone blundered across it thousands of years ago?) Are there other teleportation destinations and the teleporter just happens to be aligned with Tunisia and nobody knows how to change it?

And what about that scene with the Antarctic researchers - what do they have to do with anything (if that was explained, I've totally forgotten.)
 
Honestly, this almost seems like something people made too big of a deal about. It was mentioned once, right? Have the producers ever called attention to it? I thought it was simply about Claire trying to reestablish normalcy, but can't find a hairbrush because no one remembered to actually bring one.
 
She was looking through all the luggage bags on the plane. For nobody on an entire plane to bring a hairbrush would be exceedingly strange. Women definitely would bring a hairbrush. Guys might just have a comb. (If the brushes had something to do with the fertility research, that might be a clue as well - only the brushes from women's bags were taken and the guys tended not to have them anyway.)

And no, the producers haven't made a big deal of it. I'm making a big deal of it because it's funny to do that. :rommie:
 
As for the vaccine shots.

Remember Aaron got really sick once and Charlie brought him the vaccine (from Desmond) after giving Aaron the shot Aaron got better. So apparently the vaccine does do something.
 
Okay, you want small?

You remember when Sawyer, Juliet, Daniel and the gang were time-traveling and they stole one of those canoes with an Ajira water bottle in it, got chased by another canoe, were shot at, then time-traveled into a storm where the French expedition crashed and found Jin?

Yeah, I want to know who was shooting at them in the other canoe.

Yes! Exactly. I want to know about the canoe as well and they had better show us. I actually thought we might see that 2 eps ago when Sawyer went down to get the canoe, but it didn't happen.

That happened well after they told us that "they had everything worked out" so if that is true then they must have a plan for show us that scene from the other perspective. At least they'd better.

I'm glad the canoe was brought up! Thought I was going mad!!

I wonder if that is still to come?
Perhaps they are Widmore's sub team chasing after either Ilana's group or the MIB's people, only to start shooting at the time-travelling cohort? With the presence of the Ajira bottle, I always thought the time travellers had arrived in the future of the island when I saw that episode, but it wasn't clear how far into the future they were.
 
Temis the Vorta;3951967 And what about that scene with the Antarctic researchers - what do they have to do with anything (if that was explained said:
That was just Penny trying to find the island.
 
I wonder if that is still to come?
Perhaps they are Widmore's sub team chasing after either Ilana's group or the MIB's people, only to start shooting at the time-travelling cohort? With the presence of the Ajira bottle, I always thought the time travellers had arrived in the future of the island when I saw that episode, but it wasn't clear how far into the future they were.

Oh, I think it's still to come...at least, I hope it is. It'd be a bit of a hole if that wasn't tied in, even in a little way. I think your theory makes sense, and they were definitely in post-316 crash time. I don't think it'll be an epic mythology busting reveal or anything, I just want to see it resolved.
 
Man if there's one thing this thread has driven home for me is just how much stuff is swirling around that's never been answered, and with such a short time to go, will never be answered. :(
 
She was looking through all the luggage bags on the plane. For nobody on an entire plane to bring a hairbrush would be exceedingly strange. Women definitely would bring a hairbrush. Guys might just have a comb. (If the brushes had something to do with the fertility research, that might be a clue as well - only the brushes from women's bags were taken and the guys tended not to have them anyway.)

And no, the producers haven't made a big deal of it. I'm making a big deal of it because it's funny to do that. :rommie:

Maybe they were just foreshadowing what Claire's hair would be like this season. If she had only had a hairbrush, she wouldn't have gone crazy and adopted squirrel baby.
 
2. Why was there a polar bear on the island and what does it have to do with Walt?
DHARMA brought the polar bears for research.
That's how the polar bears got there, not why they were brought there. It's particularly perplexing since the Hydra station was only shown to have two cages, too. What exactly did they need with two polar bears in a jungle environment? And why just two polar bears?

I always thought there was a Walt/polar bear connection because of the comic book that Walt was reading with the polar bear and the insinuation that he had strange psychic ability(especially with animals, remember the pigeon). I guess they were just trying to go for meaningless spookiness.
 
DHARMA brought the polar bears for research.
That's how the polar bears got there, not why they were brought there. It's particularly perplexing since the Hydra station was only shown to have two cages, too. What exactly did they need with two polar bears in a jungle environment? And why just two polar bears?

I always thought there was a Walt/polar bear connection because of the comic book that Walt was reading with the polar bear and the insinuation that he had strange psychic ability(especially with animals, remember the pigeon). I guess they were just trying to go for meaningless spookiness.
I think that's one moment on LOST where coincidence > fate.
 
I'd just like to know why polar bears. Why not some other exotic animal? Why exotic at all? Why not any other types of animals (I think the only other one we've ever seen was a shark)? It doesn't make any sense to have polar bears in a damn jungle.
 
In the latest podcast from Damon & Carlton they indicate that questions that are important to the characters will get answers, and strongly hint that anything that is not important to the characters will probably not get an answer.

In other words, prepare for a lot of things to never be answered. They did mention the canoe shooting scene, and it sounds like that is one of many things that will never be addressed.

They are using the ever-popular "we don't want to dictate to the audience what everything means" cop-out to cover for lazy writing.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top