• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

US version Of Torchword in development!

Then again, from how I read it, it seems Barrowman may only be involved in the pilot. Perhaps as a way to pass the torch (no pun intended)...
that is one way to read it, would still make this show part of the Whoverse however, which is my worry.

Can't see why you'd think that - Robert Llewellyn was in one of the Red Dwarf US pilots and that sure as hell never became associated with real Red Dwarf, let alone become some canonical element of it.
yes one actor, if the show recasts Gwen, Ianto, Owen & Tosh it wont really be an issue, but if its just John Barrowman as Captain Jack with new characters and it left vague as to where in the timeline it could fit, and S4 is not made by the BBC proper, it could be seen as S4.
 
But it really wouldn't be unless one of the showrunners specifically says it is a direct continuation following Children of Earth. It would be Torchwood US s1, not Torchwood s4. There's really nothing to worry about.

The true s4 will be the one with PC Andy in it. Accept no substitutes.
 
Clearly Torchwood US is just the next logical step in the RTD gay agenda(TM) - first Cardiff/London, then the USA, then THE WHOLE WORLD.:rolleyes:

Well, in a country where controversies arise over the supposed sexual orientation of Tinky Winky and SpongeBob SquarePants (like the US or Poland), it's safe to assume that an American remake of "Torchwood" would contain only straight characters... except maybe for the hot lesbian/bisexual (in any case female) supporting character. This is under the assumption that the remake won't air on HBO.
 
Last edited:
Wamdue, BBC don't get Primeval because it's not a BBC property and they aren't having it produced for BBC. Watch saved Primeval by doing a deal with ITV and the production company so ITV get series 4 and Watch get series 5. UKTV isn't wholly owned by BBCWW so it's being produced for Watch not BBCWW... It's not comparable because Torchwood belongs to the BBC.
 
Blimey, I must ge getting psychic in my old age 'cos this thread has unfolded pretty much how I thought it would!

I highly doubt that if this gets made (and at the moment there isn't even a Pilot commitment let alone a Series) that it will be set in the same continuity as the original series. They'll just have Lincoln or someone having set Torchwood up instead.
 
It sounds like this is going to be some kind of remake like the US version of Life on Mars. And this can not happen because it doesn't make a lick of sense. Making a US version of Torchwood which is a spin-off of Doctor Who is like making an UK version of Stargate Atlantis which is a spin-off of Stargate SG-1. You can't a remake of a spin-off without making a remake of the original show and you should only do that if your remake concept is good enough.

Irony. :guffaw:
 
It's possible with events like those in "Children of Earth," where the aliens threatened the entire planet, that Torchwood felt an obligation to branch out. Or maybe the USA said, "So...who are these Torchwood people that saved the day? We want our own!"

Indeed. Explaining why there's a Torchwood in the U.S. is easily done and is the LEAST of this show's potential problems.
 
Personally, I can't wait for the American Doctor Who remake, where he's played by Jeff Goldblum and his TARDIS, instead of being a blue police box, is a Paddy Wagon. And it's all set in Vancouver and he flirts every week with his wise-cracking assistant. But I'm dreading the 'will-they/won't-they' chemistry being ruined in season 4 when they get married. But they'll sort it out by having him regenerate into Taylor Lautner.







Hey, I'm joking, relax with the tomatoes and rotten eggs!
 
Clearly Torchwood US is just the next logical step in the RTD gay agenda(TM) - first Cardiff/London, then the USA, then THE WHOLE WORLD.:rolleyes:

Well, in a country where controversies arise over the supposed sexual orientation of Tinky Winky and SpongeBob SquarePants (like the US or Poland), it's safe to assume that an American remake of "Torchwood" would contain only straight characters... except maybe for the hot lesbian/bisexual supporting character. This is under the assumption that the remake won't air on HBO.
if it is on HBO it will have to add a drugs sub plot, all the HBO shows ive seen featured either homosexuality or drugs, some both, same can be said for Showtime as well.
 
And they want to remake DW too? :wtf: :wtf: :wtf: :wtf: :wtf:

No they don't.

It's scary that people can't tell the difference between the story part of the article and some speculation at the end from the writer. (Who seems to be under the impression that Tennant's departure basically means the end of the BBC series.)

***

BTW I wonder if the "Save Ianto Jones" nutters have started writing to Fox yet...
 
Clearly Torchwood US is just the next logical step in the RTD gay agenda(TM) - first Cardiff/London, then the USA, then THE WHOLE WORLD.:rolleyes:

Well, in a country where controversies arise over the supposed sexual orientation of Tinky Winky and SpongeBob SquarePants (like the US or Poland), it's safe to assume that an American remake of "Torchwood" would contain only straight characters... except maybe for the hot lesbian/bisexual supporting character. This is under the assumption that the remake won't air on HBO.
if it is on HBO it will have to add a drugs sub plot, all the HBO shows ive seen featured either homosexuality or drugs, some both, same can be said for Showtime as well.

Well, since regular American TV is so restrained when it comes to "adult content", the few networks with actual freedom in that regard tend to compensate by going all the way. It's a "finally I'm allowed to do what I never could do before" thing.
 
Last edited:
How will they explain how Jack is immortal to US audiences they have no idea on the whole who The Doctor is and Rose etc.
 
Whether they were overdoing it or not is a matter of opinion. But I can guarantee that a lead male gay character who is as manly and cool as Jack is not fit for American tv. Maybe if he doesn't swear, though. :p

Remember the fuss that the ridiculous Katy Perry song caused. So she kissed a girl? Big fucking deal. Who gives a shit? And why is that so outrageous? Sheesh.
 
you know watching the US make such a fuss about Jack, might be the one reason why this "idea" isa good one.

What would be the point of paying to remake Torchwood if you loose all the Who parts? you might as well just make a similar show, with a more US TV friendly lead.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top