• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Trek vs....

sbk1234

Rear Admiral
Rear Admiral
Let's face it. We've had Trek Vs. Star Wars threads and discussions up the Yin-yang. Let's look at something different. What's your take on Star Trek vs. the original Lost In Space? I'd be most interested in looking at the villains, such as The Borg vs. Tobar the Carrot Man.
Cosmic thoughts?
 
I'm not very familiar with LiS or NuLiS, but it occurs to me that certain elements of the series may have been inadvertently (?) lifted by the creators of Voyager. You've got a ship trying to find its way home, integrating an enemy into the crew, and the breakout character is an artificial intelligence.

Personally, I'd like to see the Robot on the bridge of the Enterprise-D. He can take over Troi's job as useless expositor of danger when she is off duty.
 
Voyage wasn't technically "lost", I remember watching LIS reruns as a kid, anyone recall how the the ship was lost in the first place? And why they couldn't figure where they were by looking out a window at the stars?

The robot from LIS would be great if ever there was a TNG movie again, Data's replacement at the end of Nemisis was B4, the robot on LIS was B5. A better choice.
 
Voyager was technically lost until Message in a Bottle (if Memory Alpha's summary is accurate).

The Jupiter 2 crew seemed to know roughly where they were in relation to Earth and Alpha Centauri, but they couldn't get anywhere because there was too much plot in the way.

Except in a few episodes, neither ship was "lost" in terms of disorientation. They were astray, and considered lost by authorities.
 
Bill Mumy as his Twilight Zone character Anthony Fremont Vs Star Trek's Charlie X could have interesting outcomes... would that count?
 
...I remember watching LIS reruns as a kid, anyone recall how the the ship was lost in the first place? And why they couldn't figure where they were by looking out a window at the stars?

If I remember right, Dr. Smith was trying to sabotage the Jupiter II and was caught on board. His extra weight and sabotage threw them off course.

Link
Mumy said about Harris' guest role that in his first episode, "It was actually implied that this villainous character that sabotaged the mission and ended up with us, was going to be killed off after a while."
Link 2
It's October 16, 1997 and the United States is proceeding towards the launch of one of history's great adventures: man's colonization of deep space. The Jupiter 2, a futuristic saucer-shaped spaceship, stands on its launch pad undergoing final preparations. Its mission is to take a single family to a planet of the nearby star Alpha Centauri, which space probes reveal possesses ideal conditions for human life. The Robinson family was selected from among 2 million volunteers for this mission. The family includes Professor John Robinson (Guy Williams), his wife, Maureen (June Lockhart), their children, Judy (Marta Kristen), Penny (Angela Cartwright), and Will (Billy Mumy). They will be accompanied by their pilot, US Space Corp Major Donald West (Mark Goddard), who is trained to fly the ship in the unlikely event that its sophisticated automatic guidance system malfunctions.

Other nations are racing the United States in the effort to colonize space, and they would stoop to anything, even sabotage, to stop the US effort. Dr. Zachary Smith (Jonathan Harris), a medical doctor and environmental control expert, is actually a foreign secret agent. He reprograms the Jupiter 2's B-9 environmental control robot (voiced by Dick Tufeld) to destroy critical systems on the spaceship eight hours after launch. Smith is trapped aboard at launch and his extra weight throws the Jupiter 2 off course, causing it to encounter a meteor storm. The robot's rampage causes the ship to become lost.
 
Last edited:
James T. Kirk vs. T'J. Hooker.

Jean Luc Picard vs. Professor X

Geordi LaForge vs. Kunta Kinte

Pavel Chekov vs. Alfred Bester

Hikaru Sulu vs. Elton John

I'm bored.
 
James T. Kirk vs. Jack O'Neil/O'Neill

Oddly enough, I can imagine them just talking each other down somehow, then cracking open some cold ones and go fishing. Yes, it's boring and not dramatic, but the snarky one liners from both would be entertaining, and it would be in character for them to do something like that :p
 
the federation against the Goa'uld in Stargate would be interesting or maybe the Klingons against the Asgarde.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top