• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Why Does A Trash Compactor Have A Monster Anyway?

Okay, so how come the Dianoga doesn't get crushed when the compactor operates?

I remember hearing the sound of sliding metal just before the dianoga disappears and Luke resurfaces. I always took that to be that it had some hatch it swam to before the compactor operated.
 
"If lasers just bounce off the walls of the trash compactor, why don't they just build the whole Death Star out of the trash compactor?!"
- Arj Barker
 
"If lasers just bounce off the walls of the trash compactor, why don't they just build the whole Death Star out of the trash compactor?!"
- Arj Barker

The same reason why airplanes aren't made out of the same material the indestructible black boxes are. LOL

Here is how Kenner interpreted the Trash Compactor monster in the Death Star Playset: Profile and Top
 
^^^
Yep. I had that.

But honestly, if you can't trust the Empire to run the Galaxy you certainly can't trust the Empire's sanitation department to check to see if there's any monsters hiding in their trash compactors...
 
"If lasers just bounce off the walls of the trash compactor, why don't they just build the whole Death Star out of the trash compactor?!"
- Arj Barker

The same reason why airplanes aren't made out of the same material the indestructible black boxes are. LOLhttp://www.rocketfettscollection.com/vintfigs/trashmon.jpg
I saw Arj Barker doing stand up a couple of weeks ago and he starts off his set with "I don't wanna be one of those hacky comics that talks about airplanes or something, like 'Why don't they just build the whole plane out of the black box?!'" And then went on to mention how he'd seen Star Wars recently, and used his trash compactor line. It was pretty darn funny. :lol:
 
If, as he claims, George Lucas is inspired by Japanese cinema, then why does the beast with the tentacles ignore Leia and molest Luke?:eek::wtf:
 
Why do garbage bins have rats?
I bet the garbage bins on the ISS don't have rats.:p

Samuel Waters said:
I remember hearing the sound of sliding metal just before the dianoga disappears and Luke resurfaces. I always took that to be that it had some hatch it swam to before the compactor operated.

Makes sense. Not much point in compacting water. Although you'd have to assume that the thing could fit through holes designed to sluice water.

Of course, there's no actual need to presume any given creature survives outside of R2-D2's divine intervention. Maybe that was it's life cycle in that particular niche--born as a microscopic larva thing, grow, reproduce (asexually, hermaphroditically, conventionally sexually?--could be more than one), give birth, attack jerks who invade environment if necessary, get crushed once a month, hope children have a better life (they won't, because they'll all be ionized gas in a few days).
 
Why do garbage bins have rats?
I bet the garbage bins on the ISS don't have rats.:p

Samuel Waters said:
I remember hearing the sound of sliding metal just before the dianoga disappears and Luke resurfaces. I always took that to be that it had some hatch it swam to before the compactor operated.

Makes sense. Not much point in compacting water. Although you'd have to assume that the thing could fit through holes designed to sluice water.

Of course, there's no actual need to presume any given creature survives outside of R2-D2's divine intervention. Maybe that was it's life cycle in that particular niche--born as a microscopic larva thing, grow, reproduce (asexually, hermaphroditically, conventionally sexually?--could be more than one), give birth, attack jerks who invade environment if necessary, get crushed once a month, hope children have a better life (they won't, because they'll all be ionized gas in a few days).

Entirely possible too that the compactor doesn't run all that often. Could have been switched when the troopers saw the gang go down the chute.

"What the hell? Jenkins, mag lock the maintenance hatch and turn on the compactor."
 
Okay, so how come the Dianoga doesn't get crushed when the compactor operates?

How's this?
It does: the Dianoga was introduced to that vat as a microbial biological waste digester. Left unchecked it grows into a colony which acts like a massive creature (don't we all?), but this isn't a problem, as it gets squashed by the action of the compactor fairly regularly. The left over cells then start to regrow, and the dominant colony eventually becomes a new Dianoga creature (for a bit).
Very cod science, I know, but within Star Wars...
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top