• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

We see people stacked like wood frequently

It's too bad these people died. I understand their desire to live in a better country. But instead of choosing an illegal action perhaps they would have been better off trying to make their own country a better place to live. At least if their lives were to be sacrificed then it would have been for a better future for their country.
 
Seems like arguments against illegal immigration would be better made on economic and sociological grounds than by spurious causal arguments that just come off as being the opportunistic use of a terrible tragedy.

I don't see this as being a very constructive leaping off point to begin a mature conversation on immigration at all frankly.

My argument versus illegal aliens is based on the concept of right and wrong. Do the right things and life has a way of working out. Do the opposite and things like this happen.

Am i saddened that these people were killed? Absolutely. Am I surprised that their actions led to this? Not by a longshot.

Wait wait wait...

Are you suggesting that the universe or fate or whatever you want to call it, keeps up with US immigration law and endangers (or stops protecting) those who ignore it?

No, I'm saying that good choices more often than not lead to positive outcomes. Bad choices...well, not so much.
 
^ I'm thinking more along the lines of the OP itself. To paraphrase "If Mexicans didn't try and get into the country, they wouldn't die in car crashs. Do you agree or not? Yes? Then illegal immigration is bad wouldn't you say?"

It's a bit of a simplistic way to ignore all other issues related to it.

Yes, and I'd like to test it...

To your point, TLS, if I were to murder an illegal immigrant, should I be held responsible for murder in the US justice system, or does the fact that he was here illegally and wouldn't have been killed had he stayed home absolve me of murdering him?

I'd say that you're a murderer who should be in prison and he's a dead criminal alien.
 
My argument versus illegal aliens is based on the concept of right and wrong. Do the right things and life has a way of working out. Do the opposite and things like this happen.

Am i saddened that these people were killed? Absolutely. Am I surprised that their actions led to this? Not by a longshot.

Wait wait wait...

Are you suggesting that the universe or fate or whatever you want to call it, keeps up with US immigration law and endangers (or stops protecting) those who ignore it?

No, I'm saying that good choices more often than not lead to positive outcomes. Bad choices...well, not so much.
Yes, because of course no law-abiding citizen was ever involved in a car accident.
 
Thisiswhywecanthavenicethings.jpg
 
Jesus Christ's ministry was a living embodiment of Micah 6:8. If we're to be followers of Christ, we must be willing to set aside some of Paul and the Pastoral letters. We have before (slavery, women in ministry, "dress codes"), why not now?

If we could somehow get every Christian to truly absorb this, the world would be that much closer to perfect.

I'm a little embarrassed, but the best I can think to say is: Very, very well said.

Thank Q. ;) Though I don't advocate throwing out Paul (or other Scriptures), just putting the emphasis in the right place for the right situations.

TLS, he or she may be a "dead criminal alien," but he or she is still a child of God and should be treated with the respect all such deserve. And being a criminal in the eyes of the US Justice System is no more a basis for passing judgment on their worth as a human than being a criminal in the eyes of the Roman Empire was 2000 years ago.
 
TLS is equating the law with morality which is clearly a very dangerous way of looking at things. The law can never be viewed as morality as laws are passed and abolished seemingly at random.
 
And I wasn't trying to turn this into a religious subject but since you mentioned it, the Bible also says we must obey the laws of our land as they have been established by God.

Paul did. Paul who was regularly put in jail for civil disobedience. Paul, fellow Apostle along with the Disciples who stated early on in Acts 'We ought to obey God rather than men.' Obeying God, Who destroyed Sodom and Gomorrah for the way they treated those who immigrated into their rich lands to look for a better life, as well as how they treated their own poor and widowed, and filled His Word with more teaching and study on helping the poor and widowed than any other subject.
Just some context.
 
Many pick and choose from the Bible only to further their own agendas..instead of looking at the spirit of the entire document..

They didn't call it "The New Testament" for nothing..in many cases, Jesus comes across as a "divine humanist"...

back to cases..
This is a tragedy, and not so much the fault of those folks that died, but the fault of the coyote ,whose business model "max out the number of folks in the car no matter how unsafe it is" truely lead to the deaths..and now the survivors probably will get legal residence due to the suffering they received from the coyote scumbag.

I didn't see anyone blame the greedy coyote... I do..
 
^^ Many people are to blame. The businesses that exploit illegal immigrants should be punished severely as well. In addition to the exploitation of Human Beings, they also drain our social resources; but in their case, it's to line their own pockets.

Remember, everyone, please: Do not make the discussion into a personal conflict. Do not be insulting. If you have an opinion, explain it; if you disagree with an opinion, rebut it.

Not to take away from the tragedy, but isn't this skirting the kind of political/hot-button topics that we're not supposed to have in Misc? :confused:
Locutus of Bored has spoken :)

Oh, that's great. :techman: Locutus was an outspoken critic of the ban before he got power, so I guess it's not surprising.
It was Bonz who actually lifted the ban, since she's the one with Teh Powah. None of the Mods wanted the ban to last forever.
 
Jesus Christ's ministry was a living embodiment of Micah 6:8. If we're to be followers of Christ, we must be willing to set aside some of Paul and the Pastoral letters. We have before (slavery, women in ministry, "dress codes"), why not now?

If we could somehow get every Christian to truly absorb this, the world would be that much closer to perfect.

I'm a little embarrassed, but the best I can think to say is: Very, very well said.

Thank Q. ;) Though I don't advocate throwing out Paul (or other Scriptures), just putting the emphasis in the right place for the right situations.

TLS, he or she may be a "dead criminal alien," but he or she is still a child of God and should be treated with the respect all such deserve. And being a criminal in the eyes of the US Justice System is no more a basis for passing judgment on their worth as a human than being a criminal in the eyes of the Roman Empire was 2000 years ago.

I never said their worth is less than anyone else's. I feel sad that they were killed. They are what they are however. They are dead. They were criminals in this country. They were aliens. Had they honored our laws they would still be alive.
 
If we could somehow get every Christian to truly absorb this, the world would be that much closer to perfect.

I'm a little embarrassed, but the best I can think to say is: Very, very well said.

Thank Q. ;) Though I don't advocate throwing out Paul (or other Scriptures), just putting the emphasis in the right place for the right situations.

TLS, he or she may be a "dead criminal alien," but he or she is still a child of God and should be treated with the respect all such deserve. And being a criminal in the eyes of the US Justice System is no more a basis for passing judgment on their worth as a human than being a criminal in the eyes of the Roman Empire was 2000 years ago.

I never said their worth is less than anyone else's. I feel sad that they were killed. They are what they are however. They are dead. They were criminals in this country. They were aliens. Had they honored our laws they would still be alive.

Or they could just as easily have been murdered by drug lords in their own country. But, who cares about them anyway. They were criminals! And aliens!
 
Thank Q. ;) Though I don't advocate throwing out Paul (or other Scriptures), just putting the emphasis in the right place for the right situations.

TLS, he or she may be a "dead criminal alien," but he or she is still a child of God and should be treated with the respect all such deserve. And being a criminal in the eyes of the US Justice System is no more a basis for passing judgment on their worth as a human than being a criminal in the eyes of the Roman Empire was 2000 years ago.

I never said their worth is less than anyone else's. I feel sad that they were killed. They are what they are however. They are dead. They were criminals in this country. They were aliens. Had they honored our laws they would still be alive.

Or they could just as easily have been murdered by drug lords in their own country. But, who cares about them anyway. They were criminals! And aliens!

But they weren't murdered by drug lords, were they? We know how they died.

Or should we have no laws?
 
You're aware that our founding fathers didn't follow the "laws of the land", aren't you? Even Jesus Christ didn't follow the "laws of the land".

Not to mention "people should follow the laws of the land" is, in fact, quite obviously, an ideology.
TLS. Please address this salient point.

That's not an ideology Misfit. It's common sense. We as a people have established these laws. It's only reasonable that they be adhered to. No?
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top