Nerys how dare you disagree with even just a little bit!![]()
No I think it's absolutely possible and likely that the Federation knew about a dangerous species out there. But I just don't think they'd have had as much information on them - certainly not a name - otherwise when the Enterprise finds colonoies on the Neutral Zone border excavated someone - even from S31 would have come a calling. But I suppose a big universe and an even bigger bureaucracy!
Am glad you think like me about Annika's personality as seen so far. She already seems quite a strong stolid little figure shaped as much by her parents studies and lack of contact with other people.
This story continues to intrigue me. First of, I liked the reaction the Hansens had to seeing Earth again after being away. It is interesting to note the reaction of Annika here and her later feelings as Seven about seeing Earth in the episode where all of the crew where being brainwashed into believing they were on their way home but instead on their way into the digestive tract of a spacefaring creature!
I think you captured very well how the Hansens were caught up in just how busy and populated San Francisco was. After all they spent an extensive amount of time studying in the wild so I think that their reaction is very true to form.
However, and I know part of this story must be explaining how the parents are willing to go into deep space after the Borg, I do think a line in the story after they transport Annika to Aunt Irene checking she got to the other end ok would have been warrented. i don't think they were horrible or uncaring but the fact they didn't do that jarred with me as I read. Especially in light of the fact that transporters are possibly a technology the Hansens don't need to use very often and certainly not Annika.
Part of the problem of the Hansen story-line is the time line as dictated by Voyager and the meeting of the Borg by the Enterprise in TNG. Obviously there had to have been some prior Federation contact with the Borg. So in endeavouring to tell this tale you have a tricky line to tread and having Sloan/Section 31 connections allows for certain degrees of secrecy which is valid.
How and ever, I do think that there was perhaps too much in the way of information garnerned from a few debris pieces. Also the infamous Borg audio call - I'm not sure if I wanted the Federation to know as much as this pre-TNG knowledge! It makes them seem wholly incompetent not to have done more.
Personally, I think the evidence should have provided more questions for the Hansens and a burning desire to go out and find the answers. I figured at the start of their visit to Earth that they were going to be given a secret mission to find and examine the 'enemy/Borg' by Starfleet/S31; but it would be a mission Starfleet/S31 would pointedly refuse to acknowledge on deniablility grounds because the Hansens would need to traverse enemy/foreign space such as the Romulans, etc.
Whilst I eagerly await the appearance or the first discovery of the Borg I like the current mystery surrounding their being and like a foggy shroud would like to just see glimpses of their nature a bit at a time. We all know what they are like the strength of this story is in the little re-revelations - such as earlier in your story when it puzzled the Federation crew 'who'd design a cube for a spacecraft?'.
It strikes me as the 24th-century equivalent of the "pre-9/11 mentality": treating it as a scientific mystery rather than a serious threat. And we have, just as if you would observe if you read the 9/11 Commission Report, all the signs there--but perhaps "siloed" in some way by organizational flaws. Some pieces of info are with Section 31, some with Starfleet proper, some with Starfleet Intelligence, some (I would suspect) with Department of Temporal Investigations, some with the scientific community, some possibly with the Romulans, and none of them TALKING to each other like they should. Possibly the Hansens are going to be the only link and THEY are getting ready to leave Federation territory before they can put all of the pieces together!
Now, the mention of the Romulans raises something else. Yes, I know there's a war going on at this time between the Federation and the Cardassians, but shouldn't the discovery of someone tampering with their people to this extent--someone THIS powerful--occasion some pretty urgent, high-level contacts with the Cardassians? If I were Starfleet, I'd want to initiate contact to find out if this is indeed as surprising to the Cardassians as it is to the Federation. (I'm sure a skilled diplomat accustomed to dealing with them would be able to spot the difference, in concert with Intelligence and possibly S31.)
Especially since you can't get hold of the Romulans (since they're presumably still refusing all contact), I would think getting hold of the Cardassians might be a smart idea since this suggests reason to believe both powers are under threat. Plus, if you're working towards an eventual peace with them, I would think a friendly warning might be seen as a step in that direction, something that could eventually speed the peace process.
But I suspect the failure to do so is a symptom of the inter-agency problems and "pre-9/11 mentality."
That would help explain something that always bugged me about Seven. Even though some people dismiss "I, Borg" and "Descent" as either "bad" episodes or not canon in some way, Hugh developed intense emotions very quickly and, unlike Seven, tended to err on the side of excess emotion rather than excess logic. And yet he showed no sign whatsoever of memories of a past life! This idea of some sort of predisposition (either genetic or neurological or whatever) might help explain how we got two reactions that were so different: it may well be that had Hugh grown up free of the Collective his entire life, that we would have been looking at a personality a lot like McCoy or Kira--passionate, heart-over-head in decision-making, and with a tendency to shoot from the hip in dealing with others (both for better and for worse).
No I think it's absolutely possible and likely that the Federation knew about a dangerous species out there. But I just don't think they'd have had as much information on them - certainly not a name - otherwise when the Enterprise finds colonoies on the Neutral Zone border excavated someone - even from S31 would have come a calling. But I suppose a big universe and an even bigger bureaucracy!
Am glad you think like me about Annika's personality as seen so far. She already seems quite a strong stolid little figure shaped as much by her parents studies and lack of contact with other people.
And the bureaucracy is what I personally think is creating the problem in this case.
I have no idea whether you read the 9-11 Commission Report (and I don't mean that bad, just the literal statement that I don't know), but it was pretty shocking how many pieces of the picture the American government had in its possession, yet did not put it together. And I am not a conspiracy theorist by any means...I see it as quite simply a systemic failure.
Never did read the Commission but read the different newspaper reports and editorals. All quite shocking but probably to be expected when secrecy is the name of the game.
As for the Cardassian DNA at this stage because it is an unknown enemy and especially in light of the war and S31 involvement I would imagine it is extremely unlikely that the Cardassians will ever get wind of it. Even if feeling spirited to let the Cardassians know about a potential danger too many 'thinkers' would be of the opinion that the Cardassians or unknown enemy might ally or share intelligience. Whilst some might make an argument to do so I dare say they'd be shot down by more vocal others.
As for Hugh? Well I do think it is clear he had a different personality to Seven although we have to take onboard that his dis-assimilation [new word?] was probably more abrupt and painful than Seven's. EMH could draw upon Picard's records from Crusher. So probably some pyschological damage from his point of view perhaps.
Certainly if he had a Picard like rescue and returned to the human race I could imagine him being very impassioned by the rights and liberties of others. A crusader given his past 'imprisonment'.
The question for Tiberius is how can the Hansens get out from under S31 to do what they want to do. Which as we know is going to be extremely dangerous nevermind engendering the wrath of S31?
On topic it is worth noting that the Hansens appear to have a strong relationship and read cues off one another. Obviously developed over years working with each other and usually it appears only with each other. Not sure how healthy that is or how much trouble that will cause down the line for their relationship when they go off to study the Borg.
I've a sneaky suspicion that they might not escape fully from the S31 influence from a drama point of view however it's a bit hard to see how that influenc might be reconciled to canon. Which is why this is such an interesting tale.
And on topic, I do look forward to seeing how they get out from under 31's thumb. Or, even though they'll eventually be alone, WILL they ever be out of their sphere of influence??
We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.