• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Question for religious Christians

I'm not a Christian, so I think my perspective on this subject is lacking. My feeling is Christmas is a very religious holiday. For those who follow Christian religion, this would be marking the birth of the son of God, and the foundation of their faith. To me, that sounds like a very sacred time.
Here's my question: I always felt that it would be somewhat insulting to ignore the religous aspects of Christmas, and only look at the secular side.
Well, is it? I'd like to hear from your perspective.

Oh, and, sincerely, have a happy holiday.
Since you've directed your inquiry toward "religious Christians," and I consider myself such, I'll try to answer your question as it relates to me. :)

I don't really connect the commercialism that surrounds the Christmas holiday season with the celebration of the birth of Christ. I know that in a lot of ways, they're all connected, but it's just not the way I think about it. The holiday season provides a much needed reason to reconnect with family you only see once a year, and to take a break from hectic work and school schedules to spend time together.

Celebrating Christ's birth at this time is almost coincidental to my mind. At our church, we always prepare and sing a Christmas music program with choral pieces that communicate the details of His birth and what His life eventually came to mean for mankind. We also schedule a church family Christmas dinner early in December to eat and share gifts with one another. The kids often present a little program, we tell funny stories and sing funny songs, then we sing carols, and our pastor presents a Christmas-themed challenge. As brothers and sisters in Christ, we have a familial bond that is as strong as - and for some, stronger than - our relationships with our blood relatives. When Christmas Day falls on a worship day (Sunday or Wednesday for us), we always have a service. A couple years ago when the 25th was a Sunday, it was such a joy to spend Christmas day with my WHOLE family, not just my kin. We also usually celebrate communion (the Lord's Supper) close to Christmas time as a reminder that He wasn't just born, but also died to pay the penalty of our sin. This year, we had a Christmas Eve communion service that was a great blessing.

It is true that, while we often allow ourselves to get swept up in the pomp and circumstance of Christmastime, the event we celebrate that has the most spiritual significance to us as Christians is the resurrection. Christ's death and resurrection were His entire purpose in being born as a human, and the accomplishment of our salvation.

As far as whether find it insulting for folks to celebrate a secular Christmas, no, I really don't. The Christmas holiday is a huge part of our modern culture. I am not easily offended in the least. The only "secularization" of the holiday that bothers me is those who are militantly anti-Christianity, who want to prevent people from wishing others a Merry Christmas, or from sharing what Christ's birth means to them, or from displaying a nativity scene.

I was happy to notice how many people pointedly wished me a Merry Christmas this year. A few years ago in my area, local merchants were warned not to wish people Merry Christmas for fear of offending non-Christians. I have no objection to being greeted with Happy Holidays or any of the other generic holiday greetings. It's just nice to hear it again.
 
I don't really connect the commercialism that surrounds the Christmas holiday season with the celebration of the birth of Christ. I know that in a lot of ways, they're all connected, but it's just not the way I think about it. The holiday season provides a much needed reason to reconnect with family you only see once a year, and to take a break from hectic work and school schedules to spend time together.

That's pretty much what I do also. I treat Christmas as a time to remember the birth of Jesus, but not necessarily celebrate it as his definitive birthday. The most important aspect to me is catching up with friends and family I don't get to see the rest of the year.

As far as whether find it insulting for folks to celebrate a secular Christmas, no, I really don't. The Christmas holiday is a huge part of our modern culture. I am not easily offended in the least. The only "secularization" of the holiday that bothers me is those who are militantly anti-Christianity, who want to prevent people from wishing others a Merry Christmas, or from sharing what Christ's birth means to them, or from displaying a nativity scene.

I was happy to notice how many people pointedly wished me a Merry Christmas this year. A few years ago in my area, local merchants were warned not to wish people Merry Christmas for fear of offending non-Christians. I have no objection to being greeted with Happy Holidays or any of the other generic holiday greetings. It's just nice to hear it again.
I absolutely agree with this. I remember the PC brigade last year suggesting that we all say "Happy Festivus" or calling the whole time "Winterval", banning Christmas decorations in the workplace, etc. The flipside of this was town council staff were advised to forego eating or drinking in meetings during Ramadan, for fear of 'insulting' any Muslims observing it :rolleyes:. I have it on fairly good authority that eating in the same room as someone fasting (by choice!) isn't disrespectful. So on the one hand, those with a strong anti-Christian sentiment think you should abandon Christmas, or its religious meaning at least, and in the same breath you're advised to observe another person's customs and traditions (which is odd, to say the least! :p).

I wouldn't be offended if someone wished me a happy Hannukah, and last month I was fortunate enough to be invited to stay with my friend's family for Eid. People wished me well, and I returned the gesture. I fail to see how people could be offended by the likewise offer of saying "Merry Christmas". If anything, I think it's courteous and a show of respect to wish somebody a happy <insert festival>, regardless of their own personal belief, and I think a lot of people think the same way.

The important thing to me is, people spend the day how they want, and not try to convert the masses to their own particular way, which seems to be getting more and more common...

Just my two pennies :)
 
A friend of mine who works for the University of Georgia was really bummed this year because her supervisor banned ANY decorations or celebrations of ANY kind because he wanted to be politically correct. They didn't get to have the office Christmas party they usually have, didn't get to decorate the office for the holiday, nuthin'. Took a lot of fun out of the season for her and her coworkers.

Regardless of the label you put on it, EVERYONE needs a break now and then from the grind of their daily routines. WHY shut down the spirit of celebration that EVERYONE ELSE is participating in? Of course, her supervisor has other problems of which this is just one example, but still! Just because you're a humbug, why force everyone else to be? :p
 
I'm not a Christian, so I think my perspective on this subject is lacking. My feeling is Christmas is a very religious holiday. For those who follow Christian religion, this would be marking the birth of the son of God, and the foundation of their faith. To me, that sounds like a very sacred time.
Here's my question: I always felt that it would be somewhat insulting to ignore the religous aspects of Christmas, and only look at the secular side.
Well, is it? I'd like to hear from your perspective.

Oh, and, sincerely, have a happy holiday.

I can only speak from my perspective as a Christian, I would consider it sad to ignore the real meaning of Christmas yes. I must admit in our consumer world I do fall into celebrating the "presents" aspect of it all, perhaps with too much focus. Since I didn't have much money for presents this year it did make me reflect more on what the real meaning of Christmas is and as I get older I get more intune with that and out of tune with the consumer nature of it all. I also consider it a very important time for family to get together.
 
This year my church encouraged us to spend less and give more . . . specifically to a charity called Advent Conspiracy whose goal is to build wells in Africa for clean drinking water. I though it was a great idea and we raised a good chunk of change :D

I don't like the whole PC-better-say-"Happy Holidays"-because-"Merry Christmas"-is-offensive movement . . . I know people also celebrate Hannukah and Kwanzaa, but this whole stepping on eggshells business just drives me nuts
 
This year my church encouraged us to spend less and give more . . . specifically to a charity called Advent Conspiracy whose goal is to build wells in Africa for clean drinking water. I though it was a great idea and we raised a good chunk of change :D

I don't like the whole PC-better-say-"Happy Holidays"-because-"Merry Christmas"-is-offensive movement . . . I know people also celebrate Hannukah and Kwanzaa, but this whole stepping on eggshells business just drives me nuts

Yep, people also celebrate Christmas *shocker* so why can't I wish them a Merry Christmas. I say let it all be open, free speech and religious freedom and all.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top