• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

iPhone 3G or Blackberry Storm ?

Brent

Admiral
Admiral
So, I'm thinking about upgrading and changing phones. One thing, I am with AT&T now, and my contract is up which means I am eligible for an upgrade phone, which means I get the discounted price on the iPhone 3G.

But, dang that Blackberry Storm looks awesome and good competition to the iPhone. This would mean I would have to switch over to Verizon though, and get a new number. I think the data plans are also more expensive with the Blackberry, for example the email and internet plan is much more expensive than with AT&T. I went to ATT and they said I'd only be paying $10 a month more with the iPhone 3G than what I am paying now, so it isn't that much more expensive, but with the Blackberry I think it will be about $30 more a month than I am paying now at least.

So my question is, is the Storm really that much better to warrant me switching phone companies and paying more monthly? Or should I just get the iPhone 3G? I really like the camera specs on the Storm, and the touch screen on it.
 
I just bought an iPhone 3G and I love it. The touch screen is intuitive and the Apps store provides so many cool tricks.

I have heard nothing but bad things about the Storm. I have a coworker that bought one (our company email supports Blackberry but not iPhone) and returned it the next day.
 
I've heard the blackberry storm has problems. Sort of a vague statement though I know, but I definitely haven't heard anyone say it's "better".

I think if you're set on a touchscreen, go with iPhone. Besides it has multi-touch. I believe Apple patented the tech for it.

If you want a blackberry, go for a more traditional blackberry with buttons. That's it's real strength anyways.
 
The CNET reviews are "OK" for the Storm. However, I use my BB at work (8703) and I don't want to be typing on a smudgy piece of shit that doesn't work half the time. For the features and if you want to go the Blackberry route (Blackberries are the smoothest pieces of machinery ever created for e-mails) then I would go with the Blackberry Bold.

I'm somewhat hesitant to jump on the touchscreen bandwagon. Even the Iphone blows if you want it for e-mails.
 
If you pay insurance every month on your phone also, I would suggest being very careful with Verizon and their insurance provider, Asurion. I'm on my fourth Blackberry in as many weeks, all due to the inept bungling of Asurion following the malfunction of my first phone.

I got the Blackberry Curve back in October as part of some Verizon deal because I "qualified" for "VIP Service," and the Curve was being offered at one third the normal price. Having started a new job as a producer, I figured being able to check my email on the move would be invaluable. So I did it.

Blackberries are designed to automatically 'lock' their keyboards once there's moisture damage. (There's a little sticker under the trackball that turns red if moisture damage occurs). What this does is essentially allow you to receive calls, texts, emails, etc. however prevents you from answering or retrieving any. My first Blackberry worked just fine for about three months. On the very last day of shooting our show, it crapped out on me. The next day I went to Verizon to figure out what was wrong. Moisture damage had caused the phone to cease operation.

Described as a "preventative measure" to me, the keyboard had 'locked.' I was instructed to pay a $50 deductible to Asurion and wait three days for my replacement to be shipped to me. This, despite there being at least a dozen brand new models of the same phone in the store that night. When confronted with this immutable fact, I was told that they had 'sale models,' not 'warranty models.' I was also told that basically I had three options:

1) Pay the insurance deductible ($50),

2) Purchase a brand new phone at full retail cost ($160) or

3) Cancel my plan with Verizon Wireless at a cost of $160 plus my outstanding balance (here's a hint, its not zero)

I paid the deductible. Three days later, the phone arrived. After that, it was another 12 hours (to charge the phone prior to activation) before I was with a working cell phone again. A

The first phone Asurion sent me was a refurbished phone, with dead keys (the "N" key refused to work), a faulty "SEND" key (I had to either press it repeatedly or hold it down in order for it to function) and a microphone which refused to transmit whatever I was saying. I had to use my hands-free headset in order to use the phone at all. Upon complaining about this, and insisting they send me a brand new phone, I waited another three days for the phone to arrive, another 12 hours for the phone to charge and was again with a brand new, (non-refurbished) working cell phone.

However, because Blackberries do not use SIM cards I had to re-enter all my phone numbers manually, myself. I was also expected to return both faulty phones to Asurion within fifteen days or be charged full retail price for both. Fun!

I mailed the phones back on Christmas day on my way to the airport. Within three days, phone number 3 was malfunctioning. I was told because of Asurion's policy, they would not be able to ship me a replacement until they'd not only received the first two phones (which, were still en route due to holiday delay with the US Post Office) AND once I'd sent the current phone (#3) to them via UPS so they could track it, effectively leaving me phone-less.

After much ballyhooing about how none of this was my fault, that I was in a precarious position being out of town and quite frustrated with how poorly the insurance company was handling the situation, and about how I definitely was expecting another new phone, I was emailed a label to take to UPS to mail phone #3 with.

The next day (per my request) a new phone arrived. 12 hours later, it was charged and activated. With only my family, my girlfriend, and my uncles' phone numbers on me, I hoped that the phone would at least hold out until I returned to L.A. so I could get my numbers from my old Razr or at worst, switch my number back to the Razr, which, ironically never gave me ANY trouble like this before.

My advice: Be very careful about the Blackberry. Check out the insurance plan for both phones and see what the company will do for you in case of emergency. Apple's Genius Bar would have solved this problem for me in one day had I been having this issue with an iPhone. Instead, I've been beyond stressed and out of touch with just about everyone I know, at a time when I'm job-hunting and traveling.
 
Last edited:
Wow...what kind of water damage did the original have?

I've had my blackberry pearl since August. I love it!
 
I live in Waterloo, Ontario, where Blackberries were invented, designed and are manufactured. RIM owns this town. I still bought an iPhone.
 
I have nothing against Blackberries, but if you want one, don't get the Storm.

Blackberries are better at things like e-mail management and having real keys for people who like that. iPhones are better at things like web browsing and taking your movies and music with you. It's great that both exist, some people need one more than the other.

The Storm, on the other hand, is a strange attempt to sort of "be" the iPhone, but it doesn't come close. If you want a full-screen, touch device then get the iPhone. If you want physical keys and lots of e-mail features, get some other Blackberry. But don't get the one phone that tries to be both and fails at being either.

(As for me, I love my iPhone. But that shouldn't be what you base your choice on. I'm just saying, in case you wondered.)
 
Wow...what kind of water damage did the original have?

I've had my blackberry pearl since August. I love it!

The best the Verizon people could theorize was that steam had built up in my pocket and caused the initial damage.

Which is entirely possible, but doesn't explain the moisture damage from Phone #3, which basically sat on my night-stand or on the dining room table next to my laptop for most of the three days it operated.
 
However, because Blackberries do not use SIM cards I had to re-enter all my phone numbers manually, myself.

Verizon has a "Backup Assistant" application (available via "Get it now--tools on the go" menu) that will backup your address book to a secure online website. You can then restore that address book to a new phone as long as the phone number is the same. You can set it to automatically do the update too, so you don't have to worry about it.

Backup Assistant
 
However, because Blackberries do not use SIM cards...

It's beccause Verizon and Sprint do not use SIM cards. So yes, your particular Blackberry does not have one but it's not correct to say that Blackberries in general don't have them.

A Blackberry on AT&T or T-Mobile would have a SIM card.
 
However, because Blackberries do not use SIM cards I had to re-enter all my phone numbers manually, myself.

Verizon has a "Backup Assistant" application (available via "Get it now--tools on the go" menu) that will backup your address book to a secure online website. You can then restore that address book to a new phone as long as the phone number is the same. You can set it to automatically do the update too, so you don't have to worry about it.

Backup Assistant

Is this the same one that costs $10 a month in order to use?
 
However, because Blackberries do not use SIM cards I had to re-enter all my phone numbers manually, myself.

Verizon has a "Backup Assistant" application (available via "Get it now--tools on the go" menu) that will backup your address book to a secure online website. You can then restore that address book to a new phone as long as the phone number is the same. You can set it to automatically do the update too, so you don't have to worry about it.

Backup Assistant

Is this the same one that costs $10 a month in order to use?

It's $1.99 a month but if you register as the account owner on My Verizon the fee is waived. That's according to the site. I know I don't pay for it.
 
I live in Waterloo, Ontario, where Blackberries were invented, designed and are manufactured. RIM owns this town. I still bought an iPhone.


I'm surprised they didn't run you out of town on a moose or polar bear or whatever.

Other than a couple of white screen freezes that were quite an inconvenience during a road trip to San Antonio, I haven't had any trouble with my iPhone. And thank God the screen freezes were fixed really quickly.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top