• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

actress are they that good

drychlick

Captain
Captain
in my story i am writeing a man gf is kidnap and replace by a out of work out actress what i am asking are actress that good to take over a person life have a great day;)
 
She'd have to be not only a great actress, but the girlfriend's identical twin-- and psychic, too. There's no way an actress could step into somebody's life and continue all of the ongoing conversations, routines, personal jokes and intimacies et cetera between two people.

The only way this could be pulled off would be to fake a serious accident that resulted in some measure of brain damage to account for her lack of knowledge and enough physical damage that bandages and plastic surgery would account for physical differences.
 
dude, if you're writing, use spelling and grammer! They aren't expensive.

In the story I'm writing, a man's girlfriend is kidnapped and replaced by an out of work out actress.

What I'm asking is, are actresses good enough to take over a person's day-to-day life?

Have a great day!
Fixed that for you. Mind you, not very well, but it's okay.

Who is doing the replacing, the man or the kidnappers? Why? There also has to be a very strong physical resemblance if she's going to be seen up really close. And how far does she go with her 'boyfriend'? Who's in on it? Ask yourself a bunch of questions, and figure out how much the story needs it.
 
I'd imagine that if an actress was so good she could convincingly replace someone and not even have someone who loves that person notice then she'd be making millions in Hollywood. :)
 
Strnagely enough, I have just watched an episode of Dawn French's Murder Most Horrid which had a similar story. In this episode titled Mrs Hat and Mrs Red, a poor woman (Mrs Hat) notices that a rich woman (Mrs Red who is making a scene in a supermarket) is the spitting image of her.

Mrs Hat becomes curious and follows Mrs Red home. looking through the window she sees Mrs Red burning a photo album and writing a note. Then Mrs red leavesd the house. Mrs Hat climbs in the window and starts looking around. The note states that Mrs Red is leaving her husband.

Mrs Hat ends up having a bath when Mrs Red's husband comes home. He walks into the bathroom but doesn't realise the woman isn't his wife.

Mrs Red was a really awful woman so when she has a drastic change in personality ,and becomes a much nicer person, her husband and daughter don't worry about certain odd behaviour.

Won't say how the episode ends (it is up on You Tube if you want to find out).
 
Last edited:
If it were only a casual girlfriend...like, several dates...it is within the realm of plausibility, for the sake of a story, that the appropriate actress could take over the "role." But since she wouldn't be all that close to him, we must wonder why this scheme would be useful...and if the girlfriend were closer, it becomes much harder to believe that an actress could pull off the impersonation.

It's another big wrinkle that the "original" must be taken out of the equation for a while, too.
 
A thought: it has happened in real life, but usually the actress was mixing with people who didn't know the real person well at all, not her friends and family
 
If he is writing for his own pleasure does it really matter if his spelling and grammar aren't perfect?
 
If he is writing for his own pleasure does it really matter if his spelling and grammar aren't perfect?

Grammar always matters. It is the only thing that sustains me. Where is my red pen when I need it?

(Oh wait, you're not supposed to use red pens anymore. It's damaging to the childrens' morale. :rolleyes:).
 
(Oh wait, you're not supposed to use red pens anymore. It's damaging to the childrens' morale. :rolleyes:).

When my teacher friend told me that I almost fell over. Dumbest thing I've ever heard. Maybe we should stop correcting them altogether. After all, telling someone they made a mistake could be seen as negative!
 
(Oh wait, you're not supposed to use red pens anymore. It's damaging to the childrens' morale. :rolleyes:).

When my teacher friend told me that I almost fell over. Dumbest thing I've ever heard. Maybe we should stop correcting them altogether. After all, telling someone they made a mistake could be seen as negative!

No joke. In the UK teachers are encouraged to talk about "deferred success" rather than "failure" in case it damages the child. This in a country that is hurtling down the educational league tables of the "developed" world to join the US somewhere near the bottom.

My wife is a teacher and she's not even allowed to say "I'm warning you!" to a child because that constitutes a threat. (Of course it constitutes a bloody threat! Why else would she say it???)

[Rolls eyes, rustles newspaper loudly, harrumps, puts pipe back in mouth]

Stoatie
 
;)thank you all for your time for writing back! what i am try to said in my story how well do we know our lover? yes in my story i have the 1 real gf kidnap and have the real gf tie up some where like her own apartmemt ? how that for evil lol thank again for you time bye people
 
If he is writing for his own pleasure does it really matter if his spelling and grammar aren't perfect?

Grammar always matters. It is the only thing that sustains me. Where is my red pen when I need it?

Then for your "pleasure" I will re-post something that I posted here a few months ago. It is a comment that appeared on my local newspaper's website written by my fellow Tasmanian, Shane K (King)

okay dean my (cousin) has been caught right thats a great please do not attack cousin crystal deans sister my female cousin when she not on this websight to defend herself as for somone posting that i should say sorry to pam the answear to that is no way cos dean is not martin bryant. okay i will state this if dean when he and two other acompanying him at the attack of bashing macro to his brain leaked and macro died he would be classed as a killer dean is not a violent person now think about it dean wasent the only one invoved in the attacking of macro its ws two otheres at the scence with dean all the mecury has done is posted my cousin dean pics all over the mecury why mecury wasent the other two invoved at the attack mentioned regardless of them being in jail as well as when dean escape he escaped with two other jail mates why wasent there pics of the other two invoved in the bashing of macro mention or there pics next to deans in your newspaper the mecury is it cos the others where abbos why wasent the others mention one is a cousin thats a abbo and the other abbo is the uncle of my abbo cousin two there pics werent posted discremanantion

Compared to that drychlick has almost perfect grammar and spelling.

Sadly I was actually able to undertand what Shane K wrote.
 
;)thank you all for your time for writing back! what i am try to said in my story how well do we know our lover? yes in my story i have the 1 real gf kidnap and have the real gf tie up some where like her own apartmemt ? how that for evil lol thank again for you time bye people

I'm going out on a limb here and assuming that English isn't your first language and thus your work isn't in in English.

Because your English here?

Not so good.
 
;)thank you all for your time for writing back! what i am try to said in my story how well do we know our lover? yes in my story i have the 1 real gf kidnap and have the real gf tie up some where like her own apartmemt ? how that for evil lol thank again for you time bye people

I'm going out on a limb here and assuming that English isn't your first language and thus your work isn't in in English.

Because your English here?

Not so good.
I think the plan is to write the story on his phone and text message it to his publisher.
 
;)thank you all for your time for writing back! what i am try to said in my story how well do we know our lover? yes in my story i have the 1 real gf kidnap and have the real gf tie up some where like her own apartmemt ? how that for evil lol thank again for you time bye people

I'm going out on a limb here and assuming that English isn't your first language and thus your work isn't in in English.

Because your English here?

Not so good.
I think the plan is to write the story on his phone and text message it to his publisher.

Well. I'm sure that will go over well.
 
;)thank you all for your time for writing back! what i am try to said in my story how well do we know our lover? yes in my story i have the 1 real gf kidnap and have the real gf tie up some where like her own apartmemt ? how that for evil lol thank again for you time bye people

I'm going out on a limb here and assuming that English isn't your first language and thus your work isn't in in English.

Because your English here?

Not so good.

Google translate is NOT your friend. :(
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top