• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The title of this year's Christmas Special is....

I don't think I've seen Time and the Rani, at least I certainly don't remember it, but I enjoyed the Mark of the Rani and quite liked her character. Plus, it makes me smile, the way she basically regards the Doctor and the Master as two little kids, always fighting with each other.
 
I know I've said it before, but I kinda liked the Rani as a character. It was just her stories that blew goats. Hell, I even kinda liked the fact that she had a studly young male companion in 'DiT'. I think thats about all I liked about that story though.
 
Last edited:
The Rani should be Jenny's or Romana's main adversery in a spin off series. Yeah I know, I'm dreaming. :)
 
I would love for Jenny to make apperances in something outside of Doctor Who, my dream is that she appears on SJA, and takes Luke as her companion.

the other dream is that she takes me as her companion
 
my dream is that she just takes me.
thats my dream get your own. Ive dreamt about it ever since she appeared on the Bill. No one was willing her to regenerate more than I, at the end.

and just think of the fun you can have with a woman who can regenerate, she wouldnt even need a safe word. ;)
 
my dream is that she just takes me.
thats my dream get your own. Ive dreamt about it ever since she appeared on the Bill. No one was willing her to regenerate more than I, at the end.

and just think of the fun you can have with a woman who can regenerate, she wouldnt even need a safe word. ;)

er...ok I think that's probably the creepiest thing I've read on the internet in a long time!

And you were willing Jenny to regenerate? So you wanted rid of the hottness of Georgina and were hoping the 2nd Jenny was Bella Emberg or something?
 
my dream is that she just takes me.
thats my dream get your own. Ive dreamt about it ever since she appeared on the Bill. No one was willing her to regenerate more than I, at the end.

and just think of the fun you can have with a woman who can regenerate, she wouldnt even need a safe word. ;)

er...ok I think that's probably the creepiest thing I've read on the internet in a long time!

And you were willing Jenny to regenerate? So you wanted rid of the hottness of Georgina and were hoping the 2nd Jenny was Bella Emberg or something?
based on her last regeneration, she would continue to look like Georgia, but still there are other girls she could regenerate into.
 
She didn't regenerate!!
:lol: yeah ok I recall the debate, either is the energy from the genesis device healing her, or its her regenerating like the Doctors hand did.

two girls I would like to see play Jennys future generations

Alyson Hannigan & Jemima Rooper.
 
It baffles me there's a debate at all. For me, it's absolutely BLATANT that she's revived by the terraforming device. At best, I would accept that she was still in the first 15 hours of her life and hence could 'regrow' ala Ten, but the terraforming energy is very clear when she exhales.
 
It baffles me there's a debate at all. For me, it's absolutely BLATANT that she's revived by the terraforming device. At best, I would accept that she was still in the first 15 hours of her life and hence could 'regrow' ala Ten, but the terraforming energy is very clear when she exhales.
I agree. Plus, the "Golden energy streaming out of whichever Time Lord is regenerating" thing has been done three times. If Jenny was regenerating in a Time Lord manner, they would have used the same effect, IMO.

I put her resurrection down to a combination of Doctor-style physiology and terraforming energy. But it wasn't a regeneration.
 
so what happens when they want to bring her back again but the actress is unwilling to return?

this first one may not be a true regeneration, but I would not be surprised if she does in the future.
 
so what happens when they want to bring her back again but the actress is unwilling to return?

this first one may not be a true regeneration, but I would not be surprised if she does in the future.

Quite simple. A new girl turns up and says 'Hi Dad.' and explains that she regenerated off screen! Simple.

We didn't see Eric Roberts regenerate into Derek Jacobi after all...Not to mention McGann into Eccelston!
 
so what happens when they want to bring her back again but the actress is unwilling to return?

this first one may not be a true regeneration, but I would not be surprised if she does in the future.

Quite simple. A new girl turns up and says 'Hi Dad.' and explains that she regenerated off screen! Simple.

We didn't see Eric Roberts regenerate into Derek Jacobi after all...Not to mention McGann into Eccelston!
this is not a question of on screen or off screen, if as some are saying she can not regenerate then you wont be able to recast her, be it on or off screen.
 
I, for one, am saying that she didn't regenerate in this case (Healing terraforming energy and all that) not that she can't regenerate at all. Maybe she can regenerate, maybe not - I don't mind either way.

Anyway - since when has casting a new actor in an established role been a problem in TV shows? Happens all the time. Suspend your disbelief!

:D
 
Heck they could have a fifty year old blonde woman turn up and claim it was Jenny...timey wimey etc etc...
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top