• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Funniest comedies ever?

Mick of Time

Lieutenant
Red Shirt
I've been on a comedy kick recently, so I'm interested in getting some opinions on your favorite comedies. What are your faves,and why? Mine, in no particular order:

Airplane! - ZA & Z tried, but they never again reached the comedic heights they did here (no, not even with Police Squad!). Every character is given something funny to do or say, and the fact that everything is played straight makes it even more funny. Hilarious no matter how many times I've watched it. Avoid the sequel.

Tootsie - this is maybe the most organically funny movie I've ever seen. I'm still staggered to this day how naturally funny Dustin Hoffman is - prior to this movie, I'd have had no idea. Kudos to Bill Murray, whom everyone forgets is in this flick (by everyone, I mean me). Every scene between Sydney Pollack and Hoffman is pure gold. And Jessica Lange was never hotter. YOWZA. But Dabney Coleman still stole the show, as he does for me in everything he's in. I never understood why he didn't become a bigger name - he and Alan Rickman are the greatest bad guys in history.

A Fish Called Wanda - do I even need to say it? A tour-de-force from everyone involved, but good God Almighty, how funny is Kevin Kline here? The scenes between him and Michael Palin are fantastic. And, to top it off, I just recently found out that this was directed by Charles Crichton, the director of my favorite Ealing Studios move The Lavender Hill Mob (which stars a VERY pre-Star Wars Alec Guiness and was so forgettably remade a few years back). There's a sweetness here, too, which provides a wonderful counterpoint to the antics. The same ensamble tried again with Fierce Creatures, but didn't even come close to the gem they achieved here.

All of Me - Steve Martin's best physical comedy, ever. And Lily Tomlin has always been my favorite comedienne. She projects an almost regal demeanor in her serious scenes which provides a great contrast to the comedic zaniness she's capable of. And it's got one of my favorite one-liners of all time in it. Hate to spoil it if you've not seen it, but if you have, the setup is "I faked all my orgasms!" Steve's response is effing brilliant.

Young Frankenstein - this is Mel Brooks's best stuff. Teri Garr was never funnier, nor was Gene Wilder. But I loved, loved, loved Marty Feldman here. I'll on occasion call something strange or unusual "Abby-something" to this day. He died far too young. Did anyone see the movie he and Wilder made about Sherlock Holmes's brother? I've heard mixed reviews, but I'm curious about it still.

Coming to America - given his recent output, it's easy to forget how talented Eddie Murphy once was. Even Arsenio Hall was funny here, which can only be the result of the direct intervention of a supreme being. Man, what happened, Eddie? Pluto Nash? Daddy Day Camp? NORBIT? I liked him in Dreamgirls - maybe more dramatic roles are the way to go now.

That's all I've got at the moment. More later, if I think of any.
 
One of my all-time favorites is Dirty Rotten Scoundrels, starring Steve Martin and Michael Caine as french riviera conmen who bilk rich old women out of their inheritances - lots of great stuff in this movie!
 
I've never laughed harder at a movie than I did at "Noises Off!"

Last year a friend of mine was in a stage version and it was pretty funny, but the movie version still cracks me up (RIP 3 cast members: Denholm Elliot, Christopher Reeve, and John Ritter :().
 
Some Like It Hot. A classic. Tony Curtis pretending to be Cary Grant; he and Lemon pretending to be women and "Well, nobody's perfect!"

Blazing Saddles. Some of the best sight gags ever. A great companion for Young Frankenstein, which has already been mentioned.

The Original Pink Panther (1963). No one is better than Peter Sellers. Never has ineptitude been more beautifully portrayed.

Dr. Strangelove or How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb. "Gentlemen! You can't fight in here. It's the War Room!"

A Fish Called Wanda. It never gets old. One of the few comedies I can watch again and again.
 
I would also mention Dr. Strangelove, any Monty Python movies (maybe not the Meaning of Life, but certainly Holy Grail and Life of Brian), and just to be crazy, I'll throw in Spaceballs...
 
Leaving out those that have already been mentioned (Young Frankensteen and Airplane! my favorites) I have to put in a bit for:

What's Up, Doc? - never been a Babs fan, but few people can deliver a punchline as well as she can in this underappreciated slapstick comedy.

The Princess Bride - not what I'd call gut-bustingly funny, but instead it goes for sharp wit and beautiful characterization.

Galaxy Quest - arguably the best Star Trek movie ever made. ;)
 
We've all seen it so many times the jokes fall flat now but the first time I saw Caddyshack I rolled with laughter every time Bill Murray was on the screen.

I'd agree with just about everything mentioned so far except Scoundrels just never found it funny. I do seem to remember laughing rather hard at Shrek too...
 
Caddyshack is a perfect choice for this! :lol: I've got that on the list for my next "Guys' Movie Day Marathon".
 
God, I'd forgotten all about What's Up, Doc? . One of my favorite movies as a kid. I'm chuckling right now just thinking of the chase scene. I was never much of a Ryan O'Neil fan, but he and Babs played off of each other perfectly here. Agree on Pink Panther - I could watch Peter Sellers take a lap around an empty room and laugh hysterically. I didn't mention Caddyshack for precisely the reason mentioned above - I've seen it dozens of times, so the jokes are stale now. It's wonderful on first viewing, though. I'll throw in Animal House, also. I met Tim Matheson in a restaurant some years back and had a chance to chat with him for a bit. He was very gracious about my ignoring three decades worth of work on his part to ask about Animal House and what it was like to work with Belushi ("Interesting."). Also a really nice guy, who thoroughly enjoys being recognized. And, Kryton, I've never even heard of Noises Off!, but will definitely check it out. Such recommendations are precisely what I hoped to get out of this thread. Thanks.
 
Mick: An awesome cast (Michael Caine, Carol Burnett, Denholm Elliot, Christopher Reeve, John Ritter, Julie Haggerty, Marilu Henner, and others).

Noises Off! probably works best if you've EVER done any sort of theater performing, but it's honestly not necessary. Please, enjoy...I picked it up at Best Buy for less than $10. :) (BTW: From the same director as What's Up, Doc...Peter Bogdonovich, FWIW.)
 
Last edited:
The Lady Eve, Bringing Up Baby, Ball of Fire - two of them from the 1940s and one from 1938 and still very funny today.
 
One of my all-time favorites is Dirty Rotten Scoundrels, starring Steve Martin and Michael Caine as french riviera conmen who bilk rich old women out of their inheritances - lots of great stuff in this movie!

This is the correct answer.

OKLAHOMA! OKLAHOMA! OKLAHOMA! OKLAHOMA! OKLAHOMA!

:guffaw::guffaw::guffaw:
 
"Not another teen movie" was a really funny movie if you've seen most of the movies it spoofs
 
Comedy is probably the most subjective category. Hell, Matthew McConaughey and Kate Hudson make the same dumb romantic comedy over and over again and people keep going to see them. And there's an audience out there for such crap as Meet the Spartans and Epic Movie.

For me, the last time I laughed loudly multiple times was There's Something About Mary.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top