• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

VOY #17: Death of a Neutron Star by Eric Kotani Review Thread

Rate VOY: Death of a Neutron Star

  • Outstanding

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Above Average

    Votes: 1 100.0%
  • Average

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Below Average

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Poor

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    1

Damian

Rear Admiral
Rear Admiral
I just completed this novel last month. Originally released in March 1999 and according to Memory Alpha takes place in 2375 (which would place it around season 5 of TV series. One of the few numbered Voyager novels to feature Seven of Nine IIRC. According to Memory Alpha, Kotani based the book on a science paper he was working on sometime during the 1980s but decided to adapt it into a science fiction work. Dean Wesley Smith was also credited on the title page, though not the cover (not sure why).

Anyway Voyager decides to study a dying neutron star. They encounter a shuttle escaping form the Qavok Empire, a warlike reptile-like species. The shuttle includes people from a nearby system, the Lekk system. They also encounter a Xorm vessel, ostensibly there for scientific research. Captain Janeway and the crew learn the Qavok are trying to detonate a warp core within the star to divert one of it's flares towards' Lekk to destroy one of their enemies. The crew also learns the ejection could post a significant threat to the Federation in years to come (I'm not sure if that's even possible, given they are thousands of light years away, maybe someone can clarify that). So they decide to try to stop the Qavok and divert the ejection into open space outside the galaxy where it won't harm anyone. But then they learn the Xorm are trying to manipulate the star to do it's bidding and eliminate the Qavok. So they must stop them as well (despite the Qavok trying to eliminate the Lekk, Voyager can no more standby and see the Qavok exterminated than the Lekk).

I found this to be an above average book. I imagine since it was based on what was to be an actual scientific paper it's probably scientifically accurate to a large degree. I did find it very science oriented. Obviously some there was some dramatic license I'm sure to advance the story. But it was very good overall. There's a lot of tension as Voyager must deal with the gravitational changes as the star goes through it's final stages. I suppose if there's one weakness it's the warlike Qavok. They are developed pretty well, but it's a bit obvious making the reptilian species the baddies. It might have been more interesting had they been the good guys for a change. Though the humanoid Xorm are similarly bad guys ultimately so there's that. And Voyager did go to bat for the Qavok as well (which honestly makes sense).

The book did a good job with all the main Voyager characters as well. This apparently was Kotani's only Star Trek novel but I thought the characters were handled well. He also makes a mention to a new shuttlecraft, which I took to mean the Delta Flyer. Memory Alpha also makes mention of that possibility though when the book was written the Delta Flyer had not yet been introduced.

So overall I'd recommend this novel to anyone wanting to read an older Voyager novel. It was an entertaining standalone novel. Too bad Kotani never wrote any other Star Trek novels.
 
I had been planning on checking this one out since it's on Hoopla, this has me looking forward to it a lot more now.
 
I had been planning on checking this one out since it's on Hoopla, this has me looking forward to it a lot more now.

Definitely worth a read. IMO it was one of the better Voyager numbered novels. It's actually an overall good science fiction novel in general thanks to the scientific aspects Kotani included in the story.
 
By the power vested in me, I now pronounce this a review thread.

You may now vote in the poll.

Thanks. I always check with novels I read to see if a review thread already exists before posting a new one and I didn't find any for this book. I wasn't sure if I should make it a review thread or not since it's an older novel but I appreciate it :)
 
I remember buying this one brand new when it first hit bookstores. Of course I remember no one had any idea it was coming out, since just a few weeks earlier I had asked my local bookstore if any new Voyager books were coming out and the acetate order form showed nothing. So this one showed up out of the blue in 1999 with Voyager flying between the planets.

Of course this book has two covers, apparently and it’s unknown if the second one had a short release or what, since when you go to Memory Alpha and Memory Beta they have a scan of the Janeway/Tuvok cover in a really good scan for something from 1999. Or the Janeway cover is used on the E-book version.
 
I do not believe any version with Janeway/Tuvok was ever published in hard copy.

The writeup for the novel in Voyages of Imagination mentions that "Eric Kotani" is the pseudonym of academic Yoji Kondo but doesn't mention Dean Wesley Smith at all, weirdly.
 
I do not believe any version with Janeway/Tuvok was ever published in hard copy.

The writeup for the novel in Voyages of Imagination mentions that "Eric Kotani" is the pseudonym of academic Yoji Kondo but doesn't mention Dean Wesley Smith at all, weirdly.

Hmm, didn't know that about the author. And it's interesting how they have Smith's name on the title page but not the cover. Memory Alpha doesn't have any information on that either. If I had to wager a guess, maybe Smith helped Kotani (or Kondo) with some details and maybe some continuity stuff to keep it consistent with Voyager but it was Kotani's story overall. I know Smith wrote several Star Trek novels himself. At the very least I'd have to think if they wrote the book together that he'd be on the cover too. But that's just a wild guess on my part. I honestly don't know all the ins and outs of writing a Star Trek book, the legalities, when a writer has to be credited and how. And short of Smith or Kotani speaking, or someone familiar with it, I guess we'll never really know.

I mean, I know the general public is clamoring to know the true story behind the writing of "Death of a Neutron Star" and all :lol:
 
Ooh, I found the answer on Smith's web site:
[T]he Eric Kotani novel “Death of a Neutron Star” was supposed to be a complete ghost novel. But then about five years back a fan came up to me at a convention and asked me to sign it. I asked him why I would do that, since I hadn’t written it. (I actually had from a wonderful Eric Kotani idea and partial manuscript, but was under a non-disclosure agreement.) He said, “Your name is on the inside.” Sure enough, no one had bothered to tell me I was outed on that book.
 
My favorite part of this story is it indicates that when Smith got his comp copies of Death of a Neutron Star, he didn't even glance at them. I guess you are much less excited over your one hundredth novel than your first.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top