• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The curse(?) of small universe syndrome

It is my understanding that 'Project Star Gate'(real world) of CIA back in 1980s determined that all humans are psychic. Just not good enough.
You can read the 1993 summary report yourself, but it's a slog.

The project wasn't started by the CIA, but handed over to it. It looked primarily at "remote viewing" and found that the evidence was ambiguous and methodologically weak and didn’t prove the existence or nature of any paranormal phenomenon and furthermore didn't make any broad claims about universal human psi abilities. It did recommend additional study but the program was terminated and declassified,
 
Billions of humans. Billions of conversations being had. We're only privy to a couple of hundred.
It's a common feature of Star Trek. We see only small snippets of life in the Federation yet assume that's every person's experience on Earth.
 
Billions of humans. Billions of conversations being had. We're only privy to a couple of hundred.
The internet makes information easily available to anybody at the touch of their finger tips.

Something that profound & game changing would be spread far & wide.
 
But that's putting the effect before the cause. It just doesn't work. There's no way an incorporeal form of reproduction could be produced by the natural evolutionary process, because that process is shaped entirely by what propagates genes, and an incorporeal, non-biological organism wouldn't have genes and would be based on something entirely different.
This is reminding me of an argument a Creationist put to me once. He claimed bees could not have evolved, because if the queen evolved first she would have died very quickly because she had no workers to collect food and defend the hive. But if the workers evolved first, they would have died within a generation because they cannot reproduce by themselves.

Of course we don't know any details of how the races with godlike powers reproduce or how they came about the first time. But I would not conclude from that that something artificial must have been involved.
 
Of course we don't know any details of how the races with godlike powers reproduce or how they came about the first time. But I would not conclude from that that something artificial must have been involved.

I did come up with a handwave for it when I wrote TNG: The Buried Age, but that was two decades ago so I don't remember it off the top of my head.
 
The internet makes information easily available to anybody at the touch of their finger tips.

Something that profound & game changing would be spread far & wide.
You still need to seek the information out, have a reason to do so and then bring it into the conversation. I have all sorts of information in my head, but unless the conversation steers to that direction it's gonna stay in my head. "Miranda Jones" was piece of information in my head and something I haven't actively thought about in years. But when the conversation moved to Human ESPers that little factoid bubbled up.

Human ESPers is not some sort of secret in the Star Trek Universe. It's just not a topic that our heroes have had reason to discuss. And our heroes are a very, very small sample of Humanity in the Federation. Elsewhere in places where the topic is at the center of research you can be sure it comes up more often,
 
Elsewhere in places where the topic is at the center of research you can be sure it comes up more often,
If you find out that you could potentially turn yourself into a ESPer, all you need to do is expose yourself to "Strange Energies" intentionally at the Galactic Barrier.

Would you do it?

You know the odds of success & failure from past attempts by other folks.
So far, there are 18 people who have been exposed to the "Strange Energy" within the Galactic Barrier
- 15 of those people died due to exposure, that's a 83⅓ % chance of death.
- 3 of those people survived and developed ESPer like Super Powers, that's a 16⅔ % chance of success
- 2 of those became Megalomanical & Evil. So far, ⅔ became evil.
- 1 of those remained a good person for various reasons. So far ⅓ remained good.
Unfortunately, it's a relatively limited sample size.

You know what happens to those who fail to gain ESPer powers (Potential Death).

You can take a ESPer rating test for yourself to see how predisposed to ESP you are.

Would you risk it all to gain ESPer powers?
 
If you find out that you could potentially turn yourself into a ESPer, all you need to do is expose yourself to "Strange Energies" intentionally at the Galactic Barrier.

Would you do it?

You know the odds of success & failure from past attempts by other folks.

Unfortunately, it's a relatively limited sample size.

You know what happens to those who fail to gain ESPer powers (Potential Death).

You can take a ESPer rating test for yourself to see how predisposed to ESP you are.

Would you risk it all to gain ESPer powers?
Don't have to. I was born a ESPer.
 
Augments were not mentioned much, save for occasional research. Then in DEEP SPACE NINE it's illegal, making Darwin Station rather odd given the laws.
In a show that normally has very high quality -- and highly intelligent -- writing, I thought that episode was one of the dumber plot twists Trek has ever done.
 
I suggested earlier that the TNG-era shows never depicted human telepaths because belief in human telepathy had declined since the 1960s. But once I wrote it, it didn't quite sit right to me, because there were other contemporary shows like Babylon 5 and The X-Files that still embraced the idea of human telepathy.

So it just occurred to me to wonder if the real reason is just that the writers of the TNG-era shows got too used to stereotyping species by their defining traits. You want a warrior character, it's a Klingon; you want a capitalist character, it's a Ferengi; you want a telepathic character, it's a Betazoid or Vulcan. So it just didn't occur to them to write about human telepaths despite TOS having established their existence. Humans were just the baseline, ordinary species you used when you didn't need a character with special abilities. By contrast, TOS focused more heavily on humans, especially early on, and had few alien species that appeared more than once. So if they wanted to do a story about a character with psi powers, there was a greater chance it would be a human.
 
Sarek communicating with Michael over light years because they melded when she was a child seemed a bit much, though.

"Amok Time" established that Spock's and T'Pring's "minds were locked together" so that they'd be drawn together at the time of mating, even across interstellar space. Spock felt the Intrepid crew's destruction from light years away in "The Immunity Syndrome." And though "All Our Yesterdays" never actually explained why being in the past made Spock act like a primitive Vulcan, one interpretation is that he was telepathically influenced by the Vulcans of that era even across many parsecs. Outside of Vulcans, TNG: "Haven" established that Wyatt Miller and his true love Ariana were bonded telepathically across a great distance. So there's always been precedent in Trek for Vulcans and other telepaths being able to communicate instantly across interstellar distances.

Come to think of it, "Haven" might qualify as an example of TNG depicting human psychic ability. The episode never claimed that Tarellians were telepathic; Lwaxana just said that all consciousness was bound together, and that it may have been Wyatt and Ariana's mutual belief in the principle that allowed them to connect. Of course, that's just her own conjecture, but the episode did seem to imply the belief that the potential for telepathy existed in all beings, which is a common enough conceit in fiction. But it could be interpreted as both Wyatt and Ariana having some esper/psi ability that bonded them. Maybe that's why Lwaxana and Wyatt's parents thought he and Deanna would be a good match, because he had some psi talent of his own. (Which doesn't fit with my theory from The Higher Frontier, though. But maybe Wyatt's family tree included a Betazoid ancestor.)
 
Or you can watch Men Who Stare at Goats...

:lol:

Psychic ability in Star Trek seems to be all over the place, which is not unexpected. Sarek communicating with Michael over light years because they melded when she was a child seemed a bit much, though.

:shrug:
Plus those long distance charges.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kkt
It is established in "Encounter at Fapoint" that Troi can communicate telepathically with Riker. She says she "taught" him. Does that mean that in the Trek universe, any human can be taught telepathic communication? Or does that mean that Riker was one of those who, like Gary Mitchell, had a special potential and just needed something (or someone) to unlock it? He was, after all, focused on by Q later. Maybe there's something special about him?

Now, granted, that particular bit of their characters was eliminated after Farpoint as they dialed back Troi's telepathy to being more limited empathic abilities, but it's still interesting given the discussion here.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top