I really wanted to love this but had to settle for liking it. There is much to like. The design is glorious, from the costumes to the retro-tech, to the look of New York. The cast were all great, the chemistry & dynamic between them all was great (I could’ve done with a little more bickering between Ben and Johnny) and the plot nicely balanced the personal and the world-threatening.
I liked how, like this year’s Superman, it began with our hero(es) established and with a past (obviously 4 years, rather than the emphasis on 3s in Superman’s opening scroll). And the space scenes make me wish Matt Shakman had made that Star Trek film. Lots of nice in-jokes and nods like HERBIE or the empty Latveria chair at the UN.
Ultimately, though, it just didn’t feel like top-tier Marvel. It was better than Captain America: BNW but not as good as Thunderbolts. Hard to say exactly why it didn’t land; perhaps we’ve just seen all these powers and threats too often.
Count me as another who expected to see them moved to the rest of the MCU during this film. It actually seems a bit of a shame that we won’t get to see them do so in a sequel - Doomsday may well feel crowded or rushed. Of course, I remember 13 or 14 years ago saying that I wish we’d gotten a second WWII-set Captain America film before The Avengers.
Expected more from the post-credits scene but I can see why they want to maintain the mystery about Doom.