• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers All Things STAR WARS - News, Speculation & Spoilers Thread

They blame the failure of The Rise of Skywalker on The Last Jedi. Because that makes sense?

Yes, it makes perfect sense. Your desire to see a sequel is directly proportional to the good emotions you felt when leaving the theater for the previous installment a couple years before. I'm not joking. For example, I saw Jurassic World and Fallen Kingdom in the Theater, but skipped Dominion because I was disappointed with Fallen Kingdom. I caught it on streaming. Haven't seen Rebirth Yet. And I own replicas of both Grant's Raptor Claw and the Barbasol can, so I'm an actual fan of the franchise.
 
Yes, it makes perfect sense. Your desire to see a sequel is directly proportional to the good emotions you felt when leaving the theater for the previous installment a couple years before. I'm not joking. For example, I saw Jurassic World and Fallen Kingdom in the Theater, but skipped Dominion because I was disappointed with Fallen Kingdom. I caught it on streaming. Haven't seen Rebirth Yet. And I own replicas of both Grant's Raptor Claw and the Barbasol can, so I'm an actual fan of the franchise.
Actually, the failure of The Rise of Skywalker, if a movie that made as much as it did can actually be called a failure, rest entirely with the fact that The Rise of Skywalker was a crappy movie. TRoS was easily the nadir of the franchise and far, far worse than The Last Jedi.
 
Yes, it makes perfect sense. Your desire to see a sequel is directly proportional to the good emotions you felt when leaving the theater for the previous installment a couple years before. I'm not joking. For example, I saw Jurassic World and Fallen Kingdom in the Theater, but skipped Dominion because I was disappointed with Fallen Kingdom. I caught it on streaming. Haven't seen Rebirth Yet. And I own replicas of both Grant's Raptor Claw and the Barbasol can, so I'm an actual fan of the franchise.
I recall very much enjoying Jurassic World and didn't go to the theater.

Conversely, I enjoyed TLJ though mixed, and saw TROS in the theater.

Anecdotal but I don't go see a film because I liked the last one. Otherwise, ROTS would have been the last SW film I saw in theaters.
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

First the reports of a rejected Star Wars film by Steven Soderbergh, now reports that David Fincher wanted to make a Star Wars film.
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

First the reports of a rejected Star Wars film by Steven Soderbergh, now reports that David Fincher wanted to make a Star Wars film.

I mean, I would love either a Soderbergh or Fincher Star Wars film. But I also get LFL's denial of Fincher for final cut. It is THEIR franchise. Not Fincher's. If he wants to play with their toys, one would think he has to play by their rules.
 
Rejecting movies from FIncher and Sodenbergh I think is a good example why the franchise is in so much trouble. They need to bring in top notch talent and let them do their thing.
Nope.

No director gets carte blanche, and that should have applied to Lucas as well.

It's the same reason I don't want fans entirely in charge. Both are unwilling to cut out material they're attached to.
I mean, I would love either a Soderbergh or Fincher Star Wars film. But I also get LFL's denial of Fincher for final cut. It is THEIR franchise. Not Fincher's. If he wants to play with their toys, one would think he has to play by their rules.
Exactly.

It's absurd to think a director gets their own way with any franchise.
 
It's absurd to think a director gets their own way with any franchise.

Kathleen Kennedy and Lucasfilm gave director Rian Johnson significant creative control over
The Last Jedi, leading to his prominent role and resulting in a film that was both embraced by Lucasfilm and polarizing for fans. Kennedy highly praised Johnson, calling him a "creative force".


The fact that I would basically be able to write it from scratch in a way
...
He was convinced Lucasfilm would say no to his ideas...
...
To his surprise, Kennedy signed off on his pitch


 




Still absurd. Art benefits from limitations.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top